Download part I - Center for Social Sciences

3. sakonstitucio cvlilebebi: pirovnebebi Tu institutebikonstituciis morgeba pirovnebebze iyo erT-erTi yvelaze Zlieri argumeticvlilebebis kritikosTa mxridan: “sami kaci dadga kibeze da Tqva: me unda viyoprezidenti, me — premier-ministri, es — parlamentis Tavmjdomare, ori postiarsebobs, axla mesame unda SemoviRoT — ase qveyana ar ewyoba” (12 ianvari, I arxi,irakli melaSvili)zogadad, mixeil saakaSvili rogorc sajaro gamosvlebSi, ise politikurmoqmedebaSi, zemoTmoyvanili citatisda miuxedavad, («me ar mainteresebspirovnebebi») did mniSvnelobas aniWebs swored pirovnebebs: roca akritikebsZvel politikur mowyobas, is personalurad eduard SevardnaZes adanaSaulebsyvelaferSi; Tu cdilobs axsnas, ra Seicvleba ukeTesobisken momavalSi, pirvelrigSi axsenebs mmarTvelobaSi axali, profesionali da wesieri adamianebismosvlas; Tu ebrZvis korufcias, is sjis konkretul pirebs. oponentebi,sapirispirod, laparakoben swored institutebze da struqturebze, da araadamianebze.pirovnebebisa da institutebis aRreva sakonstitucio cvlilebebis procesSimarTlac aqtualuri sakiTxia; sami instituti — prezidenti, ministrTa kabinetida parlamenti — modelis SemuSavebis procesSi ukve ganpirovnebulia samadamianSi, romlebic am molaparakebas awarmoeben.zogadad, nebismieri politikosis racionaluri qceva mimarTulia misiZalauflebis gaZlierebaze da uflebamosilebebis zrdaze. magram es ismotivebia, romlebic ar gamodgeba ama Tu im qmedebis sajaro legitimaciisTvis.sakuTari Zalaufleba sajarod politikosma ama Tu im sazogadoebriviinteresiT unda gaamarTlos. amis magaliTia nino burjanaZis pasuxikorespondentis pirdapir kiTxvaze, rodesac is uaryofs imas, rom sameulSimidis brZola ZalauflebisaTvis, magram aRiarebs, rom “sadac xar, ginda rom metiberketebi gqondes konkretuli saqmis gasakeTeblad” (2 Tebervali, rusTavi2).sajaro legitimaciis aucilebloba am mxriv maxes ugebs politikoss, vinaidanzRudavs misi manevrirebis vels. sajaro viTarebaSi mas ar SeuZliaurTierTgamomricxavi argumentebiT sakuTari qmedebis gamarTleba; amdenad,sajarooba politikis pozitiur, mastabilizebel da winaswarmetyvelebadobisgamaZlierebel efeqts iZleva. legitimuri qmedeba unda Candes miukerZoebeli daar unda iyos TviTneburi. oponentebma SeiZleba ostaturad gamoiyenon ZveligamonaTqvamebi. ase, gazeTi 24 saaTi aqveynebs mixeil saakaSvilis 2001 wlisintervius, sadac mixeil saakaSvili daaxloebiT im argumentaciiT gamodisSevardnaZis proeqtis winaaRmdeg, rasac misi amJamindeli opozicia iyenebs(pirovnebebze morgeba, safrangeTis modelis sanacvlod yirgizeTis modelTanmiaxloeba). xelisuflebis mxridan ki Zlier arguments warmoadgens is, rompartiebi yovelTvis mxars uWerdnen ministrTa kabinetis SemoRebas, axla kigaafTrebul winaaRmdegobas uweven am ideis xorcSesxmas.politikosTa racionaluri qcevis modeli TiTqmis zedmiwevniT udgebasakonstitucio cvlilebebis SemoqmedTa strategiis aRweras. sajarod rogorcsaakaSvili, ise Jvania ar laparakoben maT Soris warmoebul vaWrobazeuflebamosilebebis Taobaze; isini warmoaCenen momaval cvlilebebs, rogorcerTian proeqts, magram unda vivaraudoT, rom maT uwevT garkveuli brZolauflebamosilebebis gadanawilebaze, vinaidan sajarod saakaSvili ufroganwyobilia ilaparakos Zlier saprezidento mmarTvelobaze, xolo Jvania —pasuxismgeblobis mqone ministrTa kabinetze. gansxvavebulia momavaliparlamentis Tavmjdomaris pozicia, romelic parlamentis (da sakuTari)uflebamosilebebis gazrdas ara marto kuluarulad icavs, aramed sajarodac“Tavs iwonebs” imiT, rom moaxerxa parlamentis dacva gadametebulidasustebisgan. kidev erTi moTamaSe — parlamenti, romelic bolo momentSi iZensgavlenas kanonproeqtze, kanonproeqtSi cvlilebebis Setanas TiTqmis veraxerxebs (sxvaoba parlamentSi Semotanil teqtsa da saboloo teqsts Soris metadmcirea) ; erTaderTi muxli, romelmac kenWisyraze sakmarisi raodenobis xmebiver daagrova, exeboda parlamentis wevrTa uflebebis SezRudvas — parlamentis20