31.08.2013 Views

EARLY BRONZE AGE DAGGERS IN CENTRAL ... - Bilkent University

EARLY BRONZE AGE DAGGERS IN CENTRAL ... - Bilkent University

EARLY BRONZE AGE DAGGERS IN CENTRAL ... - Bilkent University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

which should be assigned to the daggers presented in this study. At the meantime,<br />

majority of the daggers in Central Anatolia are conservatively dated to EB III. As it<br />

was stated earlier, using a dagger typology as a chronological marker is a dangerous<br />

practice. Nevertheless, it is possible to make some suggestions based on available<br />

evidence such as the probability that the type I daggers recovered in Horoztepe, based<br />

on wear patterns, were in use longer than the type II daggers recovered from the same<br />

context. This is also supported by their close typological similarity to daggers from<br />

earlier contexts, such as from Yazılıkaya. The appearance of certain dagger<br />

typologies, such as the arrival of “Cilician” daggers, ca. 2200 B.C., to Central<br />

Anatolia, along with culturally associated material allows us to make chronological<br />

suggestions.<br />

Maturing of the archaeometallurgical studies will certainly deepen our<br />

understanding of the role daggers played in the EBA Anatolia. Another issue which is<br />

not considered in this study is the social significance of daggers in EBA societies. It is<br />

true that we cannot completely understand the significance of a dagger to the wearer in<br />

the EBA. It is clear, however, that the place daggers hold in the human history is<br />

beyond the role of a simple utilitarian tool. The cultural and ritual connotations of<br />

daggers in the history of Anatolia are clearly evident from the impressive snake motif<br />

handled Çatalhöyük lithic dagger, through the relief of Yazılıkaya (Nergal relief) near<br />

Boğazköz, to Ottoman jewel encrusted daggers.<br />

Finally, experimental archaeology can play a role in our understanding of the<br />

manufacturing techniques of the daggers in Central Anatolia during the EBA. As it<br />

was mentioned earlier, there is lack of molds, yet many of them were certainly cast.<br />

80

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!