Sale of Divested Theatres Brings a Detroit Suit DETROIT—Palling boxoffice receipts are the background for Involved litigation over operation of three major neighborhood theatres filed in Wayne county circuit court here. Involved on one side are United Detroit Theatres and Earl Hudson, XJDT president, local Paramount operating affiliate, and on the other Goldhar-Zimner Theatres, Inc., including Jack Goldhar, former eastern divisional salesmanager for United Artists, and his son-in-law, Ben Zimner, former film salesman, and their respective wives. A charge of "misrepresentation" highlighted the proceedings. The case involves disposition of over $500,000 in leases. TWO SUITS AKE STARTED Two suits have been started—one as a law case, by UDT, based upon alleged nonperformance part of the agreement effective May 24, 1950, by which GZ took over the Regent, Annex and Alger from UDT, and seeking recovery of $125,000 as damages. The other, filed as a chancery case by GZ, sought: 1. Cancellation of the agreements, notes, assignments, and bill of sale which effected the transfer last May. 2. Return of $25,000 down payment and "other damages . . they have suffered . in the premises." 3. That UDT be required to assume GZ's contract with the L&L Concession Co. 4. Appointment of a receiver for the theatres. 5. A restraining order against UDT from further prosecuting its original lawsuit, taking any other action to enforce or cancel the notes and agreements outstanding, and from negotiating or encumbering the stock certificates of Goldhar-Zimner Theatres. First round "in the court Friday may be considered a draw, with UDT losing a motion for rep)ossession or re-acquisition, and GZ losing one for a receivership. The cases will presumably go through the usual lengthy legal process for adjudication. GZ TRIES TO RESCIND DEAL An attempt to rescind the whole deal was made by counsel Ellman and Ellman for GZ on January 24, with an offer to turn over the keys to the theatres, but was turned down on behalf of UDT by Rockwell T. Gust, who has appeared in numerous major industry legal battles, including the historic SIMPP case in federal court. A proposal to negotiate or submit to arbitration was made by Ellman and Ellman for GZ, with the comment that "Judicial considerations of this controversy affecting three theatres which have been and remain In a most precarious condition may delay resolution of fundamental dlffereijces for many months . . . The Interruption In the operation of the theatres or possible mismanagement by a receiver, the damage to the reputations of the theatres and perhaps to the parties can make any ultimate courtroom victory pyrrhlc." This was not accepted, and the filing of suit and countersvit followed. The record in the case disclosed that the Goldhars and Zimmers each own 25 per cent of stock in the company, and stresses their inexperience in exhibition, except for Goldhar's experience in Toronto 28 years ago. The "warm and friendly" relationship hitherto existing between Hudson and Goldhar is emphasized, detailing Goldhar's "trust and confidence" and "respect for (Hudson's) knowledge and experience," as important factors in the negotiations that led to the agreements. Details of the leases assumed by GZ from UDT, as recorded, are: Regent, 1,400 seats, leased from Regent Theatre Co. for ten years, ending Dec. 31, 1955; Mrs. Ida Klatt, widow of a pioneer exhibitor, appeared as president of the company in the accompanying documents; rental $1,500 per month. Alger, 1,182 seats, leased from Saul and Hattie Sloan of the Mercury and Radio City theatres, Nov. 1, 1945, to July 14, 1963; rental $1,820.83 monthly until July 14, 1950, and $1,987.50 thereafter, plus an unspecified annual percentage of gross receipts in excess of $170,000. Annex, 1,496 seats, leased from Riviera- Annex Theatre Co., from March 15, 1933, to Dec. 15, 1954, at $30,000 per year, plus a percentage of net yearly profits. THE CHARGES AGAINST UDT The case acquires significance as the net result of the single largest divorcement procedure in this city, with UDT disposing during the past year of its first run Broadway- Capitol and United Artists theatres, in addition to the trio in this suit. GZ charges that UDT "falsely represented that (it) was required to dispose of the Regent, Alger and Annex theatres to comply with the antitrust decree," and "that these were then the only theatres which could be disposed of in the Detroit area." It is charged that UDT would sell only in a block, and that, because of past friendship, indicated they would give Goldhar a chance "upon terms much more favorable" than offered others. It is charged that UDT declined to show its books on the operation of the theatres involved, because Paramount considered them confidential, but that it was represented that the Alger was earning $35,000 per year net income after taxes; the Regent $15,000; and the Annex $5,000, and that it was represented GZ "would be readily able to meet all current expenses of ojjeration out of current receipts from the three theatres" and in addition "... readily able to pay the principal and interest on the obligations they were required to assume." Following signing of the agreements, it is charged, GZ found that revenue of the theatres was greatly less than they had been led to believe—from May 25 to Dec. 31, income before taxes at the Alger was given as $5,000: Regent, loss of over $2,500; Annex, loss of over *25,000—a total loss of $22,500 or over for six months, compared to the claimed represented profit of $55,000 after taxes—with Income of the one profitable house, the Alger, taken before taxes. pi^^^urgh variety Tent 'Adopts' a Nursery PITTSBURGH—Variety Tent 1 of Pittsburgh, which for years has adopted an orphan child each year and selected the foster parents, has "adopted" a whole foundling home. Last week, the original chapter of the showmen's philanthropic organization disclosed plans to erect a $250,000 nursery building for the Roselia Foundling Home and Maternity hospital as a memorial to Mrs. Eleanor Harris, mother of John H. Harris, founder of the Variety Club. In addition. Tent 1 announced an annual $12,000 grant for establishing a protective adoption placement program at the home. The twin Variety projects are aimed at making Roselia one of the finest adoption placement agencies in the country. An architect already is drawing the blueprints for a circular three-story structure on property next to the Cliff street location of Roselia. Named to a committee to supervise the projects were Tom Troy, George Eby, Peter Dana, I. Elmer Ecker and John D. Walsh with Ben Steerman chairman. Pincus Quits Intermountain; To Join Blumenfeld Chain SALT LAKE CITY—Charles M. Pincus, manager of the Centre Theatre, an Intermountain Theatres first run house in downtown Salt Lake, resigned Thursday (8) to accept a position with Blumenfeld circuit in the East Bay region near San Francisco. Pincus will leave Salt Lake in two weeks to take over his new job. No successor has been announced as yet by Intermountain. Pincus has been a Salt Lake showman since 1933, with the exception of two years in San Francisco. He has gained nationwide attention for exploitation and showmanship on world premieres, children's shows and other events. He has managed the Utah and Centre theatres during years spent in Salt Lake. He was featured on the cover of BOX- OFFICE nearly two years ago, when he told of the value of his children's shows and how to run them properly. Court Allows 20th-Fox New April 1 Deadline NEW YORK—Twentieth Century-Fox has been granted an extension to April 1 for filing its plan for divorcement. Since that day falls on a Sunday, the due date will be the following day. The Department of Justice had approved the company's request for an extension and the New York statutory court granted it Monday (5), the date previously set for filing. Both the company and the Department of Justice told the court that agreement on a consent decree is near. The court also approved an extension to April 1 for final dissolution of 20th-Fox interest in Golden State Theatres, which had been set for March 15. The annual stockholders meeting has been scheduled for May 15. At that time a vote will be taken on the terras of the consent decree. 14 BOXOFFICE March 10. 1951
ITS 34.928.741 READERS THE w im EXCITIN m^i ###### r^m- World Premiere IN Fort Worth MARCH 23rd BIGasTEXAS MP ' W ' ^"^ «NTURY-FOX UH^¥\M^
- Page 1 and 2: Errol Flynn and Dean Stockwcll in a
- Page 3 and 4: UP! "THE GREAT CARUSO" One BIG M-G-
- Page 5 and 6: l(bur Next Demonstration of the Pow
- Page 7 and 8: I I THE NATIONAL FILM WEEKLY Publis
- Page 9 and 10: No Shortage of Carbons Seen by Manu
- Page 11 and 12: I I I I I Independents Confident Of
- Page 13 and 14: Independents Confident Of UA Succes
- Page 15: ...Easter , * . The PARAMOUNTS VERY
- Page 19 and 20: Hughes, Government File Stock Brief
- Page 21 and 22: IRES PRODUCED BY REPUBLIC! THAT [7O
- Page 23 and 24: National Theatres Executives Discus
- Page 25 and 26: He Tells of His Success Paramount E
- Page 27 and 28: ^re's theJk^^at SjEZIS/ 2" X 3" DIE
- Page 29 and 30: British Economic Crisis Expected to
- Page 31 and 32: aucer-Director Clarence Brown's age
- Page 33 and 34: MGM Promotes Four In Realignment NE
- Page 35 and 36: CHESTER FRIEDMAN EDITOR HUGH E. FRA
- Page 37 and 38: I Tadi( adio Contests Spark New Hav
- Page 39 and 40: It The army brought up its heavy ar
- Page 41 and 42: ' beside Doyleslown, Pa., Key Seeks
- Page 43 and 44: Left, the Eastman 16mm. Projector,
- Page 45 and 46: I6th MMPTA Is Opposing Booth Standa
- Page 47 and 48: Eastman Kodak Net For 1950 Increase
- Page 49 and 50: . . . . Herb Jersey Showman Given C
- Page 51 and 52: . . Melvin . . The PHILADELPHIA par
- Page 53 and 54: (Hollywood Office— Suite 219 at 6
- Page 55 and 56: Left, the Eastman I6mm. Projector,
- Page 57 and 58: 'Hornblower' Debut In London April
- Page 59 and 60: i [ ment i during Waive Wage Freeze
- Page 61 and 62: Tcane Seattle Lioness Gets Film Con
- Page 63 and 64: . . Edward PHOENIX nctress Virginia
- Page 65 and 66: Kansas Bill Seeks To End Censorship
- Page 67 and 68:
Enjoy GREATER PROFITS because it's
- Page 69 and 70:
Allied Board Plans Spring Conventio
- Page 71 and 72:
[alco Chain Starts Profit-Sharing P
- Page 73 and 74:
$310,000 Theatre Honors E.R. Rogers
- Page 75 and 76:
Mayor Brings Change To Higher Type
- Page 77 and 78:
I with a large assortment of tropic
- Page 79 and 80:
MIAMI Tack Cohn, executive vice-pre
- Page 81 and 82:
VARIETY LEADERS WILL SPEAK AT OKLAH
- Page 83 and 84:
'Air Cadet' Will Open In San Antoni
- Page 85 and 86:
I Ben Cockrell Denver, Buys Out Gam
- Page 87 and 88:
. . . Jean Drive-In Near Waukegan F
- Page 89 and 90:
Stench Bombs Tossed In Louisville S
- Page 91 and 92:
Gordon, who operates a commercial f
- Page 93 and 94:
'On Demand' Garners Top Deiroit Gro
- Page 95 and 96:
CINCINNATI . . f^eorge Fetick, oper
- Page 97 and 98:
Conn. Film Men Join To Discuss 8 Bi
- Page 99 and 100:
BOSTON piizabeth Taylor, Anthony De
- Page 101 and 102:
Variety Village Affair To Be Held A
- Page 103 and 104:
People in Greece Look For Invasion
- Page 105 and 106:
BOXOFFICE BAROMETER • EXHIBITOR H
- Page 107 and 108:
attendance. Played Sat., Sun.—C.
- Page 109 and 110:
Alphabetical Picture Go/1/0 ladex a
- Page 111 and 112:
++VerY Good; + Good- ±Fair; -Poor
- Page 113 and 114:
CHECK RUNNING TIME WITH LOCAL EXCHA
- Page 115 and 116:
REPUBLIC _j (S5) Driuna SOOS MACBET
- Page 117 and 118:
20th Century-Fox Universal-Internat
- Page 119 and 120:
Opinions 00 Correof Prodaetlons; Ex
- Page 121 and 122:
I CLOSING DATE: Monday noon pracadi