12.07.2015 Views

The Theology of Heraclitus: a Presocratic Pantheism

The Theology of Heraclitus: a Presocratic Pantheism

The Theology of Heraclitus: a Presocratic Pantheism

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

34"nonlna1" because they lack a verb.golrever, Lt 1s inportantto reallze that such sentences are only Dorphologlcally verb-Iess. By the nere fact that they are senterces at all theyDust syntactically possess a verb just as much as atry othersentence. llence 1t is nlsleailing to refer to the "nlssitrtve!b" ln such senteoces as belng C!!!. In such sentencesthere ls no verb nlssiog; Lt ls present ln the syotacticsenae <strong>of</strong> the I'ordls ho theos h€mera euphronE lgl. Maoy inflectedIanguages use s\rch nominal constructloos, but because Entli6has a rule cannot, a norphologtcally p!esent verb Dust be Lnsertedso as !o g3!glg!S from the Creek. It ls utfortunatethat we nust add a copulatlve nrhen we translate because rdhen\re do so we run lhe !isk <strong>of</strong> 1osin8 the fu11 BeanlnS <strong>of</strong> theo!iglna1, For as Benveniate has sholrn, ho theos aga!hos estldoes not Eean the same as ho theos agalhos. <strong>The</strong> verbelphrase reports a fact sltuated ln tlxoe and reletlve to thespeake! (or lrriter). It says thet this particular Bod ls atthe monren! good. Because it drairs attention to the speaker,verbal sentences are produc!s <strong>of</strong> dlscou!se. On the othe! haIId,the noniral version <strong>of</strong> these words usually has a ti!|eless,general tneaning. Thls holds true in English too Ln the onetype <strong>of</strong> nominal construction we do have: proverbs (e.g."finde!s keepers, losers weepers"). !g_$C9j_jg3$99 ."y"that god is ever good, regardless <strong>of</strong> who says thls, or uhy,or rhen. It is gnonic and absolute. <strong>The</strong>re is no way tocapture a1l this neaning in the Engltsh "the god Ls good".!{e can[o! say "the god good" anal hope to nake sense, so we

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!