Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
TRINITY & OTHER DOCTRINES OF GOD:<br />
PROF. M. M. NINAN<br />
To put an end to the dispute, Emperor Theodore II called a council at Ephesus, which<br />
was to convene on the day of Pentecost, 431. This became known as the Third<br />
Ecumenical Council. St Cyril of Alexandria arrived with 40 Egyptian bishops; the other<br />
churches were represented by Yuvenali of Jerusalem with Palestinian bishops, Thermos<br />
of Caesarea in Cappadocia, and Flavian of Thessaloniki. Nestorius arrived with his<br />
bishops and two governement officials-Candidian and Ireneaus, representing the<br />
Emperor. Memnon of Ephesus hosted the Council. The only representatives not there<br />
were John of Antioch and the Syrian bishops and the legates of Pope Celestine of Rome.<br />
After waiting for 10 days for the arrival of the absent delegates, St Cyril of Alexandria<br />
decided to convene the Council without them on June 22, 431. The 200 bishops present<br />
read the teachings of Nestorius, the teachings of St Cyril of Alexandria, the writings of<br />
the Fathers, and found that Nestorius was teaching heresy and the St Cyril's teaching<br />
reflected the Orthodox position. The decisions of the Council were signed and sent to<br />
Constantinople for the Emperor and the Constantinopolitan faithful. Nestorius was<br />
invited to attend and defend himself, but refused to do so, and a wrote to the Emperor<br />
accusing St Cyril and Memnon of holding an illegal council and plotting against<br />
Nestorius.<br />
At this time, John of Antioch and 33 Syrian bishops arrived at Ephesus. Not recognizing<br />
the decision of the Council, John and the Syrian bishops refused to enter into<br />
communion with St Cyril, and, together with Nestorius and a few bishops who defected<br />
from St Cyril's council organized a rebel council. At this council, they condemned St Cyril,<br />
Memnon of Ephesus, and the other Fathers, falsely accusing them of the heresies of<br />
Arius, Apollinarius, and Eunomius. The proceedings were signed and sent to<br />
Constantinople.<br />
Emperor Theodore, unsure of the proper course of action, ordered both councils to close,<br />
the proceedings to be destroyed, and the all the Fathers to convene one Council. While<br />
messengers were going back and forward between the Palace and Ephesus, St Cyril of<br />
Alexandria convened his Council again. At the second session, the Council found<br />
Orthodox the epistle of Pope Celestines, finally delivered by his legates. At the third<br />
session, the legates signed the condemnation of Nestorius. At the fourth session, the<br />
Council found invalid the condemnation of St Cyril and Memnon by John of Antioch and<br />
his council. At the fifth session, St Cyril and Memnon condemned the heresies of Arius,<br />
Apollinarius, and Eunomius, and the Council condemned John of Antioch and the rebel<br />
council. At the sixth session, the council decreed that no changes or additions can be<br />
made to the Nicene Creed. At the seventh, and final session, the Council made decisions<br />
concerning the boundaries of various dioceses.<br />
Emperor Theodore, at the time under the influence of the Nestorian party at the Court,<br />
ordered Nestorius, Memnon, and St Cyril to be arrested and a new council to be<br />
convened. No agreement, however, could be reached. St Cyril, meanwhile, wrote to<br />
Abba Dalmatius in Constantinople, calling him to action for the defence of Orthodoxy.<br />
Abba Dalmatius, who for 48 years never left his monastery, marched together with the<br />
Constantinopolitan faithful to the Palace and called on the Emperor to release the<br />
Orthodox bishops and to condemn Nestorius. The people then proclaimed anathema on<br />
Nestorius.<br />
92