12.12.2012 Views

Strategic Planning for Species Conservation: A Handbook - IUCN

Strategic Planning for Species Conservation: A Handbook - IUCN

Strategic Planning for Species Conservation: A Handbook - IUCN

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

62<br />

8. Actions<br />

evaluations can, of course, be a recommended Action within the SCS, if this has not been<br />

completed at the time of developing the Plan.<br />

Table 8.3 Real-world examples of Actions which could reasonably have been expected<br />

to have beneficial effects, but proved damaging in practice<br />

Citing of these examples implies no criticism of the conservation programmes involved; all went on to<br />

achieve growing populations, with spectacular success in some cases.<br />

<strong>Species</strong> Action Outcome Reference<br />

Black-footed ferret<br />

Mustela<br />

nigripes<br />

Large blue<br />

butterfly<br />

Maculina arion<br />

Wood duck<br />

Aix sponsa<br />

Kakapo<br />

Strigops<br />

habroptilus<br />

San Clemente<br />

loggerhead shrike<br />

Lanius<br />

ludovicianus<br />

mearnsi<br />

Vaccination of newly<br />

captured animals with<br />

modified live vaccine<br />

against canine distemper<br />

virus<br />

Exclusion of livestock from<br />

reserve to reduce<br />

disturbance<br />

Installation of large<br />

numbers of nest boxes to<br />

encourage population<br />

growth<br />

Supplementary feeding of<br />

females to encourage<br />

successful breeding<br />

Euthanasia (and more<br />

recently live capture) of<br />

critically endangered island<br />

foxes (Urocyon littoralis)<br />

during the shrike (and fox)<br />

breeding season to avoid<br />

nest predation<br />

Vaccine caused clinical<br />

distemper and death<br />

Loss of grazing made<br />

habitat unsuitable <strong>for</strong> the<br />

butterfly’s host species and<br />

the butterfly became locally<br />

extinct<br />

Conspicuous nest boxes<br />

encouraged brood<br />

parasitism and reduced<br />

hatching success<br />

Artificial food attracted<br />

Polynesian rats, which are<br />

nest predators<br />

Fox population declined but<br />

shrike population did not<br />

increase; cessation of this<br />

management did not reduce<br />

shrike recruitment<br />

Carpenter et<br />

al. 1976<br />

Thomas 1980<br />

Eadie,<br />

Sherman and<br />

Semel 1998<br />

Merton 1989,<br />

cited in<br />

Caughley and<br />

Gunn 1996<br />

Roemer and<br />

Wayne 2003;<br />

Swarts 2006<br />

Evidence of the effectiveness of particular management approaches should be provided, or<br />

cited, in the narrative sections of the SCS, to give managers and decision-makers<br />

confidence that recommended Actions will work. Tests of particular management<br />

approaches may be recommended as Actions, if (as will often be the case) they have not<br />

been conducted prior to the development of the SCS.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!