Table B-10: Life-Cycle Costs for RE Solutions Case, Base Case, and ROI (without incentives) Name Renewable Energy Initial Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle O&M Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Biomass Fuel Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Gas Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Electric Cost ($) RE Case Life-Cycle Cost ($) Base Case Life-Cycle Cost ($) Return on invest ment (%) Naco, AZ $70,556 $2,317 $0 $36,533 $561,820 $656,596 $697,006 10.0% Chateaugay, NY $28,841 $1,215 $0 $95,287 $186,674 $292,562 $307,451 9.8% Canaan, VT $24,276 $717 $0 $59,702 $176,414 $248,095 $261,045 9.7% Trout, River, NY $55,944 $1,255 $0 $78,526 $254,170 $371,460 $400,914 9.7% Niagra Falls, NY $1,383,426 $209,751 $42,494 $119,939 $1,378,087 $3,023,102 $3,746,085 9.6% Los Tomates, TX $1,131,309 $39,812 $0 $50,900 $2,041,062 $3,183,399 $3,791,946 9.5% St John Hwy, NY $70,551 $2,329 $0 $166,705 $142,933 $349,193 $383,476 9.5% Dunseith, ND $19,012 $0 $0 $33,922 $178,014 $222,609 $231,773 9.5% Douglas, AZ $220,785 $6,932 $0 $77,745 $1,655,824 $1,922,732 $2,033,183 9.4% RR Inspection, TX $2,760 $0 $0 $5,585 $5,762 $12,963 $14,416 9.4% Alburg Springs, VT $15,417 $434 $0 $54,162 $75,890 $135,159 $142,793 9.4% Fort Covington, NY $31,915 $990 $0 $67,929 $214,552 $300,255 $315,542 9.3% Andrade, CA $174,114 $5,086 $0 $176,370 $299,457 $613,811 $697,785 9.2% Gateway, TX $811,736 $27,069 $0 $59,433 $1,756,133 $2,590,613 $2,984,200 9.1% Massena, NY $109,903 $4,209 $0 $27,521 $439,608 $567,438 $615,736 9.1% Detroit Cargo, MI $77,868 $0 $0 $1,422,562 $2,572,481 $3,800,734 $3,839,007 9.1% Champlain, NY $415,889 $0 $0 $4,149,002 $9,021,117 $12,769,725 $12,963,556 9.1% West Berkshire,VT $32,551 $622 $0 $43,333 $136,805 $203,090 $217,239 8.9% Piegan, MT $137,642 $0 $0 $1,001,213 $542,764 $1,497,580 $1,557,310 8.8% Mooers, NY $28,052 $825 $0 $56,037 $152,735 $225,304 $236,566 8.6% Rouses Pt. NY $55,590 $1,544 $0 $165,992 $229,484 $419,324 $441,563 8.6% Kenneth Ward, WA $26,495 $0 $0 $131,221 $387,562 $517,919 $529,039 8.6% Highgate Springs 2, VT $107,349 $0 $0 $1,844,877 $1,479,443 $3,095,076 $3,137,323 8.5% Blaine, WA $188,460 $1,533 $0 $152,579 $671,314 $972,738 $1,040,623 8.3% Turner, MT $31,218 $256 $0 $0 $19,439 $49,283 $59,614 8.0% Blaine, WA $162,654 $0 $0 $180,098 $3,427,536 $3,700,823 $3,755,228 7.9% Point Robert, WA $176,860 $1,334 $0 $40,194 $413,220 $612,709 $667,543 7.9% Danville, WA $41,203 $0 $0 $15,813 $152,322 $203,316 $216,147 7.8% Blaine, WA $119,368 $0 $0 $64,493 $497,621 $660,308 $695,963 7.8% Brownsville TX $466,410 $13,212 $0 $62,723 $779,817 $1,282,641 $1,428,943 7.7% Alexandria Bay, NY $674,659 $16,969 $0 $56,798 $2,055,652 $2,744,416 $2,953,875 7.7% Roseau, MN $104,341 $0 $0 $195,362 $534,963 $791,280 $817,759 7.4% Kika de la Garza, TX $1,054,667 $35,212 $0 $173,590 $2,841,094 $4,000,071 $4,290,611 7.4% North Troy VT $24,896 $483 $0 $92,283 $3,894 $104,441 $110,418 7.2% Milltown ME $7,955 $378 $0 $15,014 $153,039 $172,052 $173,937 7.2% Marfa, TX $315,565 $6,640 $0 $111,241 $205,051 $602,769 $670,371 6.9% 124
Table B-10: Life-Cycle Costs for RE Solutions Case, Base Case, and ROI (without incentives) Name Renewable Energy Initial Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle O&M Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Biomass Fuel Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Gas Cost ($) RE Life- Cycle Electric Cost ($) RE Case Life-Cycle Cost ($) Base Case Life-Cycle Cost ($) Return on invest ment (%) Portal, ND $25,714 $0 $0 $73,680 $335,561 $418,026 $421,940 6.4% Intl Falls, MN $17,592 $0 $0 $87,388 $216,376 $303,514 $305,496 6.0% Chief Mt, MT $16,780 $0 $0 $469,955 $742,171 $1,140,375 $1,140,633 5.1% Highgate Springs 1, VT $1,911 $23 $0 $2,181 $3,871 $7,486 $6,193 -4.2% The following ten LPOE sites did not have cost-effective applications of RE technologies: • San Luis AZ (not built); • Amb. Bridge, MI; • Intl Bridge, MI; • Rooseville, MT; • Admin, TX (leased); • El Paso, TX (out leased); • McAllen TX (not built); • Highgate Springs 1, VT; • Mataline Falls. WA; • Sumas, WA. 125