Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Red Wine<br />
France - Bordeaux<br />
Saint-Emilion<br />
CHATEAU L'ARROSEE Grand Cru Classe Saint-Emilion 2009<br />
Bottle<br />
DECANTER MAGAZINE ****<br />
£33.78<br />
Clearly a distinguished wine. Long, linear, fresh. Elegant bouquet. Finely worked tannins. Drink<br />
2015-2028. (17 points)<br />
ROBERT PARKER 92-94 points<br />
This outstanding l’Arrosee is consistent with the Burgundian style that this terroir routinely<br />
produces. Never massive, at its best it offers intense flavors of kirsch, raspberry, crushed rock,<br />
and spice box. The full-bodied flavors are ethereal in their delicacy. Full, but stylish, precise,<br />
intense, and never heavy, this beauty can be drunk early or cellared for two decades or more.<br />
(Tasted three times.)<br />
CHATEAU LE TERTRE ROTEBOUEF Grand Cru Saint-Emilion £119.50<br />
1999 Bottle<br />
Château Tertre Roteboeuf's fine reputation is relatively recent, dating from when François<br />
Mitjavile took over management in 1997. After inheriting a small (less than 6-hectare) estate<br />
on the southern part of the St. Emilion slope, François Mitjavile perfected his winemaking<br />
skills with help from Thierry Manoncourt of Château Figeac. Located in the south-east part of<br />
the appellation, Tertre Roteboeuf has clay-limestone soil and a fine microclimate. Grape<br />
varieties are approximately 80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc. Tertre Roteboeuf is the<br />
opposite of a rough wine. Its tannins are incredibly soft and the Merlot gives it an opulent<br />
side. This shows the owner's talent for obtaining healthy, ripe grapes without the need for<br />
green harvesting (bunch thinning). This results in a voluptuous, full-bodied, and very complex<br />
wine.<br />
CLOS DE SARPE Grand Cru Saint-Emilion 2005 Bottle<br />
£59.95<br />
ROBERT PARKER 94-96 points 'This is a wine for readers with incredibly long life-expectancies<br />
as it possesses the power and longevity associated with many pre-phylloxera, 19th century<br />
wines of Bordeaux. Like so many of the small St.-Emilion estates, there are no compromises<br />
at Clos de Sarpe. It will be bottled unfiltered. This opaque purple-colored, massive, ferociously<br />
tannic offering reveals scary concentration levels, huge dry extract, and technical numbers<br />
that are off the charts. Despite its impressive credentials, size, richness, and overall balance, it<br />
will close down after bottling, and re-emerge 10-15 years later. My conservative guess is that<br />
this gigantic, colossal St.-Emilion will be drinkable around 2015-2020, and last for 40-50 years.'<br />
CLOS FOURTET 1iere Grand Cru Classe (B) Saint-Emilion 2009 £74.95<br />
Bottle<br />
DECANTER MAGAZINE 4****<br />
Round, caressing. Lovely volume of succulent fruit. Shows the ripeness of the year. Polished<br />
and refined. Drink 2016-2035. (17.5 points)<br />
TIM ATKIN MW 95 points<br />
14.8% alcohol. 88M, 8CS, 8CF - The proportion of Cabernet Sauvignon is lower than usual at<br />
this much improved<br />
property, but its inclusion in the blend still adds freshness to a wine that carries its high<br />
alcohol lightly. This is aromatic and balanced, with sweet blackcurrant and plum fruit, smooth<br />
tannins and good concentration. Surprisingly fresh on the palate. 15+ years.<br />
ROBERT PARKER 95-98<br />
This is a perennial superstar thanks to the efforts of proprietor Philippe Cuvelier and the<br />
estate’s manager, Tony Ballu. This beautifully-situated, nearly 48-acre vineyard, high on the<br />
clay and deep limestone plateau just adjacent to the town walls of St.-Emilion, was harvested<br />
between September 28 and October 13, with yields of 34 hectoliters per hectare. The natural<br />
alcohol turned out to be 14%. A magical wine, it may have a hard time eclipsing the 2005, but it<br />
is another prodigious effort in its own right. The dense purple color offers up notes of white<br />
chocolate, blueberry, blackberry, crushed rock, and white flowers. Textured, full-bodied,<br />
enormously pure, and voluptuously textured, it is nearly too easy to drink because of the<br />
exquisite balance and seamless integration of all its component parts. This is a killer Clos<br />
Fourtet that should drink well young yet evolve for 20+ years. (Tasted five times.)<br />
MONDOT 2nd Wine of Ch. Troplong-Mondot Saint-Emilion £26.95<br />
2008 Bottle<br />
***** TASTING NOTE FOR CHATEAU TROPLONG-MONDOT 2008 ***** - ROBERT PARKER 95-97<br />
'What a worthy rival to the prodigious 2005! This is another superb success from proprietress<br />
Christine Valette, but it is distressing to hear that this property may be up for sale. The<br />
inky/blue/purple-colored, formidably concentrated 2008 exhibits aromas of smoke, blueberry<br />
and blackberry liqueur, roasted coffee, and spice box. Boasting fabulous fruit and purity, a<br />
multilayered texture, full body, and prominent, but sweet, well-integrated tannin, this is a<br />
tour de force in winemaking from an outstanding and a perfectionist proprietor. Give it 5-6<br />
years of bottle age, and drink it over the following three decades.'<br />
PETIT CORBIN DESPAGNE 2nd Wine of Grand<br />
£14.95<br />
Corbin-Despagne 2006/08 Bottle<br />
A fresh and elegant wine coming from a specially selected parcel at Château Grand Corbin<br />
Despagne. There is excellent balance of fruit, acidity and supple but persistent tannins which<br />
indicate a wine which will continue to improve with age.<br />
Saint-Estephe<br />
Red Wine<br />
France - Bordeaux<br />
Saint-Estephe<br />
CHATEAU CALON-SEGUR 3ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe £49.95<br />
2008 Bottle<br />
ROBERT PARKER 90-93 points '"Perhaps that explains the elegant, but rich style of the 2008<br />
Calon Segur, which is dominated more than usual by Cabernet Sauvignon. Cropped at 40<br />
hectoliters per hectare, it is a blend of 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, 18% Merlot, and 2% Petit<br />
Verdot. Its sweet perfume of black currants, tobacco leaf, and licorice is followed by a wine<br />
with superb purity, good freshness, and a full-bodied style with ripe tannin as well as a long<br />
finish. Somewhat reminiscent of the 1996, although this vintage carries a much higher<br />
percentage of Cabernet Sauvignon, the 2008 should be relatively approachable given the<br />
sweetness of the tannins, and will evolve for 20-25 years.'<br />
CHATEAU COS D'ESTOURNEL 2ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe £164.50<br />
1986 Bottle<br />
ROBERT PARKER 93 points - "The 1986 is a highly extracted wine, with a black/ruby color<br />
(some pink is showing in the rim) and plenty of toasty, smoky notes in its bouquet that<br />
suggest ripe plums, licorice and black currants. Evolving at a glacial pace, it exhibits massive,<br />
huge, ripe, extremely concentrated flavors with impressive depth and richness. It possesses<br />
more power, weight, and tannin, and it is a wine for long-term ageing. Anticipated maturity:<br />
now-2020."<br />
Jancis Robinson 17/20 - "Lovely deep crimson shading to purple. Particularly healthy colour.<br />
Deep, dense, strongly Cabernet aromas that are still unyielding. This wine could mature into<br />
something eventually finer than the Talbot but, boy, will it take time."<br />
CHATEAU COS D'ESTOURNEL 2ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe £99.50<br />
1999 Bottle<br />
Cos d’Estournel is the probably the greatest St-Estèphe. Only Montrose comes close to<br />
stealing the title, but Cos is the more classic claret. This great Second Growth is<br />
extraordinarily consistent, year after year turning out a wine with a perfectly judged balance<br />
between structure and fleshy fruit. The owners have embraced modernity in the best possible<br />
way, using technology judiciously to produce a modern wine which is still unmistakably<br />
Bordeaux. ROBERT PARKER (2002) 88 points 'The dark ruby-colored 1999 Cos is a supremely<br />
elegant effort. The wine offers notes of dried Provencal herbs, smoke, licorice, black cherries,<br />
and cassis. This medium to full-bodied St.-Estephe is cerebral, intellectual, and refined.<br />
Anticipated maturity: 2004-2018.'<br />
CHATEAU COS D'ESTOURNEL 2ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe £94.50<br />
2002 Bottle/NC<br />
ROBERT PARKER 93 POINTS - "One of the candidates for wine of the vintage, this beauty has a<br />
dense purple color to the rim and a classic, noble nose of graphite intermixed with black<br />
currant, spice box, licorice, and red and black fruits. Medium to full-bodied with exceptional<br />
precision and definition, this beautifully textured wine stands out as one of the most<br />
successful wines of this irregular vintage. A brilliant effort, it should be at its best between<br />
2008 and 2020."<br />
CHATEAU COS D'ESTOURNEL 2ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe £89.50<br />
2007 Bottle<br />
DECANTER MAGAZINE **** 18 points 'Dense purple-red, full, plummy, smoky, fleshy, spicy,<br />
exotic fruit, with more firmness than usual from the 85% Cabernet Sauvignon, about as ripe as<br />
you could get this vintage with fine length and potential complexity. Drink 2012-25.'<br />
JANCIS ROBINSON 17 points 'Determinedly, almost exaggeratedly, modern style. Firm, very<br />
concentrated nose. Something strange on the nose – very distinctive. Extremely<br />
concentrated! And then reasonably supple on the palate – but quite low acid and freshness. A<br />
certain rawness but great attack and beef. One of the most distinctive wines of the vintage<br />
but a bit forced. All created by the early cutting of the shoots in June – taking a risk that the<br />
summer would not be hot. (Otherwise the fruit risked being sunburnt.) Strictly for<br />
modernists.'<br />
ROBERT PARKER 90-93 points<br />
CHATEAU COS LABORY 5ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe 2005 £34.95<br />
Bottle<br />
ROBERT PARKER 89 points 'One of the finest wines I have tasted from this estate, the 2005<br />
Cos Labory exhibits a deep ruby/purple hue, aromas of road tar, blackberries, creme de cassis,<br />
forest floor, smoke, and graphite, medium to full body, and abundant tannin. It is a complete,<br />
dense effort with high tannins in the finish. Once the tannins melt away, it should represent<br />
an outstanding example of the vintage. Anticipated maturity: 2015-2030.'<br />
NEIL PINEL 8/10 - Our Saint-Estephe of the vintage, quality and value for money wise. Excellent<br />
ripe, black wine gums and cassis aromas and flavours, Clean, creamy with good depth and<br />
length. Very, very good !<br />
CHATEAU COS LABORY 5ieme Cru Classe Saint-Estephe 2006 £19.95<br />
Bottle<br />
This Chateau is fantastically situated alongside Cos d’Estournel and over-looking Lafite.<br />
DECANTER 3*** - 'Good colour, good jammy fruit, ripe and smooth, fruit/acidity/tannins in<br />
balance, quite forward style. 2010-18.'<br />
www.winedoctor.com "Lots of sweet oak here, a honey-tinged, blackberry crumble nose with<br />
plenty of similarly sweet fruit. Nicely textured on the palate, a dry and structured midpalate,<br />
with grainy tannins. Quite a firm grip, with a good, savoury finish. Overall this is well put<br />
together although there is a lot of oak and structure for the fruit."<br />
Page<br />
34 of 90