12.07.2015 Views

Full report. - Social Research and Demonstration Corp

Full report. - Social Research and Demonstration Corp

Full report. - Social Research and Demonstration Corp

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

learn$ave Project: Final Reportother outcomes. Separate survey research on financialliteracy finds that, while levels of financial literacy arevery low overall, adults with low incomes <strong>and</strong> even thosewith low literacy may still match or even out-performhigh-income adults on some elements of financial managementsuch as keeping track of income <strong>and</strong> expenses(Atkinson, 2007; Atkinson, McKay, Kempson, <strong>and</strong> Collard,2006), likely because their lack of income forces themto. This finding calls into question the traditional IDAprogram requirement of financial management training,or at least suggests that the need for increases in financialliteracy may be as great or greater among higher-incomeindividuals outside IDA programs. Other research suggeststhat financial education, such as the kind offeredin IDA programs, may increase financial knowledge <strong>and</strong>contribute to improvements in financial behaviour oractions but other factors can also come into play (Hilgert,Hogarth, <strong>and</strong> Beverly, 2003).of financial management training, case management, <strong>and</strong>program parameters in that activity; Chapter 6 presentsimpacts on budgeting, total savings, assets, debts, networth, <strong>and</strong> hardship; <strong>and</strong> Chapter 7 looks at education<strong>and</strong> labour market impacts. Chapter 8 includes a costeffectivenessanalysis of the program. Chapter 9 drawskey policy lessons <strong>and</strong> insights gathered through all thestudy phases.While the above research is informative, it raises morequestions than it answers about IDAs. Without further<strong>and</strong> rigorous research like the learn$ave demonstration,there is insufficient evidence on the utility of IDAs (orrelated savings instruments) for reaching certain socialpolicy goals, including encouraging adult education<strong>and</strong> training. The learn$ave project is unique in at leastthree ways. First, it is one of only two rigorous researchprojects on this type of matched savings instruments, theother one being the ADD controlled IDA experiment atTulsa referred to previously. Second, it is a demonstrationof the IDA model in a mainly adult learning context,whereas most other IDAs have other purposes in additionto adult PSE, if PSE as a use for the credits was permittedat all. Third, it is distinguished by its rigorous test of theseparate additional impact of financial literacy training<strong>and</strong> enhanced case management services on top of theincentives, whereas past projects can measure only thecombined effect of the incentives <strong>and</strong> services whendelivered as a package. As such, learn$ave can uniquelyinform policy-makers in Canada <strong>and</strong> abroad aboutthe potential for IDAs as a social policy instrument topromote participation in adult learning <strong>and</strong> education.Outline of this <strong>report</strong>The rest of this <strong>report</strong> presents the description of thelearn$ave program design <strong>and</strong> its operations (Chapter2), followed by a description of the research questions<strong>and</strong> the methodology used to address them (Chapter 3).Findings from the demonstration project are <strong>report</strong>ed insubsequent chapters: Chapter 4 reviews lessons learnedfrom the program implementation of learn$ave <strong>and</strong>examines the role of community-based non-profit organizationsin the delivery of learn$ave; Chapter 5 presentssaving <strong>and</strong> cash-out activity on IDAs accounts <strong>and</strong> the role<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Demonstration</strong> <strong>Corp</strong>oration Chapter 1 | 7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!