13.07.2015 Views

LABOULBENIALES - Agentschap voor Natuur en Bos

LABOULBENIALES - Agentschap voor Natuur en Bos

LABOULBENIALES - Agentschap voor Natuur en Bos

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Table XLI: Comparison betwe<strong>en</strong> Sonian Forest and Meerdaal Forest.Sonian Forest (deer)Meerdaal Forest (pig)Family # specim<strong>en</strong>s # species # specim<strong>en</strong>s # speciesBuprestidae - - 1 1Cantharidae - - 1 1Carabidae 22 4 1 1Cerambycidae - - 3 3Chrysomelidae - - 3 1Cleridae 1 1 9 4Curculionidae - - 4 3Dermestidae - - 8 2Elateridae - - 14 7Geotrupidae 122 1 4 1Histeridae 33 3 44 6Melyridae - - 2 2Nitidulidae - - 15 3Ptiliidae - - 1 1Scarabaeidae - - 6 3Scraptiidae - - 6 3Silphidae 37 7 66 8Staphylinidae 9 6 13 5T<strong>en</strong>ebrionidae - - 4 2TOTAL 224 22 205 57Notably more Geotrupes specim<strong>en</strong>s have be<strong>en</strong> recorded in the Sonian Forest.However, wh<strong>en</strong> recorded that much in the Sonian Forest, one should expectthem to also be pres<strong>en</strong>t in large numbers in the Meerdaal Forest, since theytypically feed on decomposing organic matter.Also noteworthy is the differ<strong>en</strong>ce in specim<strong>en</strong>s of carabids: 22 in the SonianForest against only 1 in the Meerdaal Forest.However, in the Meerdaal Forest only the Coleoptera with for<strong>en</strong>sic applicabilitywere collected: many Carabus violaceus and Geotrupes species wereobserved but not collected (YVES BRAET, pers. comm., 2011). Therefore, th<strong>en</strong>umber of specim<strong>en</strong>s collected in each forest cannot be compared since theprotocols were differ<strong>en</strong>t. It is suggested to replicate this research, focusing onthe following issues:(1) A single protocol should be used in both the Sonian Forest and MeerdaalForest;(2) Three plots should be studied in each forest, with all plots in the samevegetation type: a plot with deer cadaver, a plot with pig cadaver and acontrol plot;(3) Regarding the influ<strong>en</strong>ce during the weather (cfr. 4.1. WEATHER), allobservations should be done in the same season, under similar weatherconditions (temperature, humidity), at the same time in the course of aday.Adapting Table XLI following Table XII (in 1.1. FORENSIC ENTOMOLOGY) results in atable only comprising carrion beetles, thus with for<strong>en</strong>sic applicability:P a g e | 73

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!