XV-15 litho - NASA's History Office
XV-15 litho - NASA's History Office
XV-15 litho - NASA's History Office
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
component occurred during the STO tests. This component, called the “yoke,”<br />
to which the blades are attached, was manufactured of titanium because it<br />
afforded valuable weight saving over steel while still providing the required<br />
fatigue life.<br />
On October 1, 1982, while performing STO operations at the Crows Landing<br />
NALF, at the <strong>XV</strong>-<strong>15</strong>’s maximum takeoff gross weight, a telephone call was<br />
received by the Ames test director Shorty Schroers, from engineers at the Bell<br />
facility in Texas. They informed Schroers that they had just discovered that<br />
the strength of titanium material used for the rotor yokes was significantly<br />
lower than that used in their design. The flight crew was informed about this<br />
new and somewhat disturbing development while in flight. They landed the<br />
<strong>XV</strong>-<strong>15</strong> safely and removed the weights added for the STO tests. After further<br />
consultation with Bell engineers, it was decided to “gingerly” fly the aircraft<br />
back to Ames taking special care to keep the hub yoke oscillatory loads at a<br />
low level.<br />
The full story regarding the titanium fatigue strength anomaly emerged later.<br />
While performing design work for another project, a Bell engineer came across a<br />
published fatigue strength allowable load level for titanium that was lower than<br />
that used for the design of the <strong>XV</strong>-<strong>15</strong> yokes. Although the titanium identified by<br />
the Bell engineer and the titanium used for the proprotor were the same, a difference<br />
existed in their fatigue strength because of heat treatment (a process by<br />
which the strength and other properties of metals are altered by exposure to specific<br />
thermal conditions). As luck would have it, the heat treatment for the<br />
titanium used for the <strong>XV</strong>-<strong>15</strong> yokes was the one which resulted in the lower<br />
fatigue strength. This meant that aircraft N703NA had been operating at significantly<br />
higher loads than the lower strength titanium could bear for the duration<br />
of the flight program.<br />
Operation of both <strong>XV</strong>-<strong>15</strong> aircraft was continued but with the installation of a<br />
new set of titanium yokes and with the allowable loads reduced until a better<br />
solution was found. The solution was replacement of the titanium yokes with<br />
steel yokes of the same design. Steel yokes were installed on aircraft N703NA in<br />
July of 1985 and have been used continuously since then without incident.<br />
Flow Visualization Studies<br />
In the early 1980s, a number of tilt rotor technical issues remained unexplained.<br />
One of these was that acoustic measurements in the hover mode of flight<br />
revealed that noise, rather than being at about an equal intensity around the aircraft,<br />
was greater behind the aircraft than at an equal distance along its sides.<br />
Another issue was that, although the magnitude of the download was now<br />
accepted as being greater than initially estimated (based on recent performance<br />
investigations), verification of the reason for this was needed. In an attempt to<br />
answer these questions and to better understand the airflow around the tilt rotor<br />
71