04.04.2013 Views

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The History of Divorce in <strong>Scotland</strong> 47<br />

expressed how, under the Scots law, marriage <strong>can</strong> be regarded as<br />

a permanent contract. This view ignores the fact that divorce is<br />

a remedy for an abnormal state of matters, arising after marriage,<br />

which is never contemplated by the parties themselves at the time<br />

of marriage, and is never alluded to in the marriage service, any<br />

more than in the marriage contract, if t<strong>here</strong> be one. It is a<br />

remedy for a position which <strong>can</strong>not come into existence, except<br />

through the<br />

Accordingly,<br />

voluntary wrong-doing of one of the parties.<br />

from the Reformation, both Church and State in<br />

<strong>Scotland</strong>, in unison with the feeling of the people, have dealt with<br />

the relation as a permanent one. After the parties accept<br />

each<br />

other as spouses, both Presbyterian ministers and Episcopalian<br />

clergymen always pronounce the words, ' What (or whom) God<br />

hath joined together, let not man put asunder.' The permanency<br />

of the relation between married is people no more impaired by<br />

the existence of reasonable divorce laws than is the permanency<br />

of the tenure of ministers, professors, judges and town-clerks by<br />

the knowledge that, in their deeds of '<br />

appointment, the words ad<br />

'<br />

vitam' are followed by<br />

aut culpam.' In no country is t<strong>here</strong> a<br />

stronger sense than in <strong>Scotland</strong> of the sacredness of the marriage<br />

tie. Divorce may, or may not, be a justifiable remedy for<br />

grave matrimonial wrong, making it reasonably impossible, in<br />

the interests of the innocent spouse and the children, that the<br />

tie should continue. I<br />

express no opinion. But<br />

marriage<br />

the case of <strong>Scotland</strong> proves that its existence and enforcement,<br />

for desertion as well as for adultery, does not in any way<br />

deteriorate the public view of the importance and obligations<br />

of the married relation. It may be added that the Scotch<br />

statistics of divorce for both causes (which include a certain<br />

number of cases w<strong>here</strong> the defender, who <strong>can</strong>not be found, is,<br />

in fact, dead), furnish no ground for alarm. In relation to the<br />

increase of population, they may be called stationary. The<br />

numbers of divorce cases brought in <strong>Scotland</strong> from 1898 to<br />

1908<br />

are as follows :<br />

1898 153 1904 193<br />

1899 175 1905 182<br />

1900 151 1906 174<br />

1901 171 1907 203<br />

1902<br />

-<br />

223 1908 201<br />

1903<br />

- 201<br />

Lord Fraser's views in reference to <strong>Scotland</strong>, expressed at page<br />

1141 of his second <strong>volume</strong> on Husband and Wife, are still

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!