04.04.2013 Views

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

You can download this volume here - Electric Scotland

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

76 Corbett : The Campaign of Trafalgar<br />

THE CAMPAIGN OF TRAFALGAR. By Julian S. Corbett. Pp. xvi, 473,<br />

with Charts and Diagrams. 8vo. London : Longmans, Green & Co.<br />

1910.<br />

1 6s. nett.<br />

IT is hardly an exaggeration to say that if t<strong>here</strong> had been no battle of<br />

Trafalgar the naval campaign of 1805 would be very much better understood<br />

than it is. That most people have thoroughly erroneous ideas about<br />

it is partly because the true relation of the battle to the campaign is not<br />

grasped, and partly because Nelson's share in the campaign, invested with<br />

the special<br />

interest attaching to his<br />

personality, has unduly eclipsed the<br />

work of other men who, like Barham and Cornwallis, really played greater<br />

parts. The most conspicuous naval victory gained by England over<br />

the combined forces of France and Spain, the crowning moment in<br />

Nelson's career, to some extent the decisive battle of the Napoleonic<br />

wars, inasmuch as the destruction of the largest portion of his fleet<br />

made it impossible for Napoleon to revive his schemes for the invasion<br />

of England, and so drove him to have recourse to the ' Continental<br />

System' and all that it involved, Trafalgar was nevertheless merely the<br />

epilogue to the campaign of 1805, so far at least as that had as its<br />

object the invasion of England. That great project<br />

to which Napoleon<br />

had devoted so much thought and labour only to be countered by his<br />

less famous opponents with no less ingenuity and a much more accurate<br />

appreciation of the essentials of naval strategy, had been foiled two months<br />

before Trafalgar, and it is not that battle but Calder's action of July 22nd<br />

off the Spanish Finisterre, it<br />

tactically incomplete though was, which has the<br />

best claim to be called the decisive blow of the campaign as far as concerned<br />

the invasion of England. To students of naval history, these points are<br />

familiar enough ; but it is to be hoped that Mr. Corbett's admirable account<br />

of the campaign, told with all his vigour and vividness in narrative and all<br />

his<br />

lucidity<br />

in argument and exposition, will do much to make the true<br />

version of the story more universally recognised. And while Nelson's work<br />

is in no danger of being undervalued, certainly not by Mr. Corbett, it is high<br />

time that adequate justice should be done to the even greater services of<br />

Barham and Cornwallis, to say nothing of lesser men. But <strong>this</strong> is<br />

just what<br />

Mr. Corbett's<br />

study of the campaign does. It goes without saying that he<br />

has availed himself of the great mass of materials, published and unpublished,<br />

dealing with the naval side of the campaign, but what is of special value is<br />

that he has brought the naval events into their true connection with the<br />

military and the diplomatic, and that the different features of the story are<br />

arranged in their proper proportion.<br />

One is accustomed to expect something new in Mr. Corbett's books, not<br />

merely new facts brought to light by his researches, but new constructions<br />

put on old facts and new solutions of old puzzles. His wide knowledge, his<br />

ingenuity and his insight help him to bring fresh light to bear on the most<br />

familiar points, and it would have been surprising indeed had he not found<br />

reason to call for a reconsideration of some of the salient features of the<br />

Trafalgar campaign. His most important new contention is that one should<br />

not regard the campaign, as one of mere defence against invasion, not as a<br />

merely naval campaign, but as essentially offensive and closely connected

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!