11.04.2013 Views

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

SESSION NO. 8<br />

documented only on hardground hosts. Hardground sample occurrence and encrustation<br />

frequency fall <strong>with</strong>in the expected range for shallow euphotic zone sclerobiont suites, but richness<br />

is significantly higher than expected. These data suggest that suites or sclerobiont taxa may be<br />

effective indicators <strong>of</strong> sedimentation in addition to paleodepth.<br />

8-4 BTH 8 Green, Jeremy L. [218512]<br />

THE INFLUENCE OF BITE FORCE ON THE FORMATION OF DENTAL MICROWEAR IN<br />

XENARTHRANS (MAMMALIA)<br />

GREEN, Jeremy L., Geology, Kent State University at Tuscarawas, 330 University Dr NE,<br />

New Philadelphia, OH 446636, jgreen72@kent.edu and MCAFEE, Robert K., Ohio Northern<br />

University, Department <strong>of</strong> Biological and Allied Health Sciences, 525 South Main Street, Ada,<br />

OH 45810<br />

Xenarthrans are a group <strong>of</strong> placental mammals (including tree sloths, armadillos, ground sloths,<br />

and glyptodonts) that lack enamel on their adult teeth, having instead an outer layer <strong>of</strong> s<strong>of</strong>ter<br />

orthodentine. Prior analyses <strong>of</strong> microscopic scars (termed “dental microwear”) on the chewing<br />

surface <strong>of</strong> xenarthran teeth reveal a correlation between orthodentine microwear patterns<br />

and feeding ecology, thereby providing a proxy for paleodiet in extinct xenarthrans. However,<br />

the specific formative mechanism <strong>of</strong> microwear features (e.g. scratches, pits) on xenarthran<br />

orthodentine remains poorly understood. It stands to reason that bite force (generated by<br />

mandibular closure during mastication) should influence the formation <strong>of</strong> microwear patterns, but<br />

no studies have specifically tested this hypothesis. We attempt to fill this gap in our knowledge<br />

by investigating the potential effects <strong>of</strong> variable bite force on microwear formation in tree sloths.<br />

Relative ratios <strong>of</strong> bite force were estimated from 16 skulls <strong>of</strong> Bradypus (three-toed sloth) and<br />

Choloepus (two-toed sloth) by applying a geometric model for calculating input forces from<br />

masticatory muscles (e.g., temporalis and masseter) relative to lever arm moments <strong>of</strong> the<br />

mandible. For each skull, microwear was examined on epoxy resin casts <strong>of</strong> the upper right<br />

tooth row. Using low-magnification (35×) light microscopy, we analyzed five microwear variables<br />

(i.e., number <strong>of</strong> scratches, presence <strong>of</strong> hypercoarse scratches, gouges, large pits, and crossscratches)<br />

on four tooth positions (M1–M4) from each skull. ANOVA tests were applied to<br />

compare each microwear variable <strong>with</strong> the estimated bite force at each tooth position per taxon.<br />

While there is some positive correlation <strong>of</strong> increasing microwear variables and strength <strong>of</strong> force<br />

as one moves posteriorly, the pattern is not consistent across the entire tooth row for either taxon.<br />

The lack <strong>of</strong> a significant correlation between microwear variables and bite force values suggests<br />

that tooth scars in sloths are not being generated by pure orthal closure <strong>of</strong> the mandible, but<br />

rather are more influenced from other jaw movements. Further analyses that incorporate all<br />

masticatory muscles to create a more realistic and three-dimensional assessment <strong>of</strong> the chewing<br />

cycle should help to clarify how microwear patterns are generated in theses taxa.<br />

8-5 BTH 9 Guensburg, Thomas E. [218000]<br />

AGAINST HOMOLOGY OF CRINOID AND BLASTOZOAN ORAL PLATES<br />

GUENSBURG, Thomas E., Sciences Division, Rock Valley College, 3301 North Mulford<br />

Road, Rockford, IL 61114, t.guensburg@rockvalleycollege.edu, SPRINKLE, James,<br />

Department <strong>of</strong> <strong>Geological</strong> Sciences, Jackson School <strong>of</strong> Geosciences, University <strong>of</strong> Texas,<br />

1 University Station C1100, Austin, TX 78712-0254, and MOOI, Rich, Dept. <strong>of</strong> Invertebrate<br />

Zoology and Geology, California Academy <strong>of</strong> Sciences, 55 Music Concourse Drive,<br />

San Francisco, CA 94118<br />

Cambrian echinoderms include the earliest pentaradiate forms, blastozoans and edrioasteroids<br />

sensu lato, but no living classes. The earliest unequivocal crinoids appear early in the Ordovician.<br />

One side in the ongoing debate over crinoid origins recently promoted similar oral region<br />

morphology as evidence <strong>of</strong> blastozoan ancestry, the two historically assigned pelmatozoans<br />

(stemmed echinoderms). Instead we find evidence <strong>of</strong> ancestry <strong>with</strong>in edrioasteroid-like taxa,<br />

recently found to also include stemmed forms.<br />

Does the oral region, and specifically oral plating surrounding the peristome (mouth) provide<br />

synapomorphies indicating blastozoan-crinoid monophyly? Proponents document morphologic<br />

similarities including: hydropore position, moveable peristomial and ambulacral cover plates, 2-1-2<br />

ambulacral symmetry, arrangement <strong>of</strong> oral plates, and rigid attachment <strong>of</strong> the oral surface to the<br />

underlying calyx. These five traits are supposed to represent synapomorphies <strong>of</strong> some subset<br />

<strong>of</strong> blastozoans <strong>with</strong> crinoids. The early echinoderm record shows the first four <strong>of</strong> these traits<br />

actually comprise symplesiomorphies for all pentaradiate echinoderms, including edrioasteroids.<br />

Therefore they are uninformative for any blastozoan-crinoid linkage. The 2-1-2 symmetry and<br />

oral arrangement are closely related, the former constraining the latter. Lacking support from<br />

these similarities, blastozoan-crinoid oral homology becomes conjectural. Lastly, thecal rigidity<br />

represents an iterative theme in pentaradiate echinoderm evolution across the critical stratigraphic<br />

interval (Cambro-Ordovician), underscoring potential for homoplasy. Considering evidence from<br />

all other skeletal regions, we conclude that symplesiomorphy and homoplasy, not phylogenetic<br />

relationship, explain blastozoan and crinoid similarity, ruling against a pelmatozoan clade.<br />

8-6 BTH 10 Aucoin, Christopher D. [218100]<br />

A PRELIMINARY COMPARISON OF THE LATE ORDOVICIAN BUTTER SHALES OF THE<br />

CINCINNATI ARCH<br />

AUCOIN, Christopher D., Department <strong>of</strong> Geology, University <strong>of</strong> Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH<br />

45211-0013, aucoincd@mail.uc.edu, BRETT, Carlton E., Department <strong>of</strong> Geology, University<br />

<strong>of</strong> Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45221-0013, MALGIERI, Thomas J., Department <strong>of</strong> Geology,<br />

University <strong>of</strong> Cincinnati, 500 Geology/Physics Building, Cincinnati, OH 45221-0013, and<br />

THOMKA, James R., Department <strong>of</strong> Geology, University <strong>of</strong> Cincinnati, 500 Geology-Physics<br />

Building, University <strong>of</strong> Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45220<br />

The Upper Ordovician Cincinnatian strata <strong>of</strong> Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana contain several<br />

claystone units, colloquially referred to as “butter shales” or “trilobite shales”. These units are<br />

widely known for their relative abundance <strong>of</strong> well preserved trilobites Isotelus and Flexicalymene.<br />

Previous studies have focused on trilobite taphonomy and bed characteristics <strong>of</strong> individual<br />

butter shales; however, there has been little comparison between butter shales to assess lateral<br />

variation, or broader stratigraphic/facies context. This study takes a comparative approach<br />

by examining the geographic extent <strong>of</strong> each claystone unit, as well as lateral variations in<br />

bed thickness, paleoecology, taphonomy and clay sedimentology <strong>with</strong>in and between various<br />

butter shales.<br />

Field study and review <strong>of</strong> literature has identified three major butter shale units in the<br />

Waynesville Formation and several minor ones in the older Grant Lake and Arnheim formations.<br />

The Treptoceras duseri shale, the most extensively studied <strong>of</strong> the claystones, has produced<br />

a mollusk-dominated fauna adapted for environments characterized by muddy substrates,<br />

high turbidity and rapid sedimentation in contrast to the brachiopod dominated fauna <strong>of</strong> the<br />

surrounding units. Surprisingly, however, at least three <strong>of</strong> the butter shales also contain zones <strong>with</strong><br />

corals (Tetradium) and small stromatoporoids, unusual fauna for clay-dominated environments.<br />

10 2013 GSA <strong>Abstracts</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>Programs</strong><br />

These coral/sponges are frequently overturned and heavily bored and encrusted, indicating<br />

reworking in relatively shallow water conditions during pauses in sedimentation. In terms <strong>of</strong><br />

sequence stratigraphy, butter shales appear to be consistently situated <strong>with</strong>in highstand portions<br />

<strong>of</strong> third-order cycles, apparently amplified by analogous phases <strong>of</strong> higher-order cycles. We<br />

suggest that this common position <strong>with</strong>in a 3 rd and 4 th order stacking reflects a sedimentational<br />

“sweet spot”, in which progradation during shallowing, regressive conditions permitted episodic<br />

pulses <strong>of</strong> mud deposition.<br />

8-7 BTH 11 Zambito, James J. [218267]<br />

NEW INSIGHTS INTO THE TRILOBITE AND CONODONT BIOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE<br />

MIDDLE-UPPER DEVONIAN GENESEE GROUP IN EASTERN NEW YORK STATE<br />

ZAMBITO, James J. IV, Department <strong>of</strong> Geology and Geography, West Virginia University,<br />

330 Brooks Hall, 98 Beechurst Street, Morgantown, WV 26506-6300, james.zambito@<br />

mail.wvu.edu and DAY, Jed, Geography & Geology, Illinois State Univ, Normal, IL<br />

61790-4400<br />

During the Middle Devonian (Givetian) Global Taghanic Biocrisis, numerous trilobite families<br />

underwent extinction including the Homalonotidae. In northeastern North <strong>America</strong>, the last<br />

occurrence <strong>of</strong> homalonotid trilobites (Dipleura dekayi) has previously been reported in strata<br />

deposited during the final stages <strong>of</strong> the Taghanic Biocrisis (semialternans Zone –latest Middle<br />

Givetian) including the Tully Formation <strong>of</strong> the northern Appalachian Basin and the Petoskey<br />

and Thunder Bay formations <strong>of</strong> the Michigan Basin. Globally observed low-oxygen conditions<br />

associated <strong>with</strong> the Taghanic Biocrisis, represented by the Geneseo and Antrim black shales<br />

in the Appalachian and Michigan basins, respectively, have been interpreted to be at least in<br />

part responsible for the local extinction <strong>of</strong> the Homalonotidae and other trilobite families. Recent<br />

geologic mapping in eastern New York State (northern Appalachian Basin) has documented the<br />

occurrence <strong>of</strong> Dipleura dekayi in siliciclastic-dominated, nearshore post-Taghanic strata that were<br />

deposited below fair-weather wave base. Although these strata have been mapped as Genesee<br />

Group, they have yet to be assigned a formation-level designation. An integrated stratigraphic<br />

approach, including litho-, sequence-, and conodont biostratigraphy has provided new insight into<br />

the stratigraphic succession in the eastern Genesee Group, representing marine shelf through<br />

non-marine settings. Lithostratigraphic correlation places the occurrence <strong>of</strong> Dipleura dekayi<br />

above the level <strong>of</strong> the Fir Tree Limestone <strong>of</strong> western, <strong>of</strong>fshore sections. Application <strong>of</strong> a sequence<br />

stratigraphic model has enabled the identification <strong>of</strong> time-rich intervals such as flooding surfaces<br />

and sequence boundaries that have yielded conodonts. Preliminary conodont biostratigraphic<br />

data suggests that Dipleura dekayi persisted into at least the latest Middle Devonian Lower<br />

subterminus Zone (=Lower disparilis Zone). Preliminary mapping further suggests that Dipleura<br />

dekayi may have even survived into the Late Devonian. Similar to other northern Appalachian<br />

Basin taxa that persisted through the Taghanic Biocrisis, Dipleura dekayi apparently found intrabasinal<br />

refuge in oxygenated, nearshore shelfal settings.<br />

8-8 BTH 12 Wulf, Shane [218741]<br />

TESTING SPECIES-ABUNDANCE MODELS OF THE HUGHES CREEK SHALE<br />

(CARBONIFEROUS) OF SOUTHEASTERN NEBRASKA<br />

WULF, Shane1 , JOHNSON, Daryl1 , and HANGER, Rex A. 2 , (1) Geography & Geology,<br />

University <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin-Whitewater, Whitewater, WI 53190, WulfSA11@uww.edu,<br />

(2) Geography & Geology, University <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin-Whitewater, 800 West Main Street,<br />

Whitewater, WI 53190<br />

The Hughes Creek Shale Member <strong>of</strong> the Foraker Formation (Carboniferous) is exposed in<br />

road and stream cuts in Richardson County <strong>of</strong> southeastern Nebraska. Two coeval exposures<br />

separated by approximately 16 km were sampled extensively for (mostly) invertebrate fossil<br />

specimens, yielding over 5,000 individual specimens. Brachiopods dominate, but Bryozoans,<br />

Echinoderms, Molluscs , Cnidarians Arthropods and Chordates are also represented among<br />

the 36 species recovered. All taxa were identified to the lowest taxonomic level possible, then<br />

counted using (mostly) MNI (minimum number <strong>of</strong> individuals) methods. Counts <strong>of</strong> the fauna were<br />

then compared <strong>with</strong> the geometric, log-series and log-normal species abundance models. For<br />

a null hypotheses <strong>of</strong> no difference between actual data and the models, goodness <strong>of</strong> fit tests<br />

<strong>of</strong> all samples for both exposures were not significant for the geometric and log series models,<br />

but highly significant (P< 0.005)for the log-normal model. The log-normal model <strong>of</strong> species<br />

abundance fits many large, mature communities today, and that assumption is extended to the<br />

Hughes Creek Shale fauna. At both exposures, maximal faunal diversity occurs less than one<br />

meter above presumably anoxic, black shales, suggesting that reassembly <strong>of</strong> these mature<br />

paleocommunities occurred quickly once oxic conditions returned.<br />

8-9 BTH 13 Rivera, Alexei A. [218247]<br />

ECOLOGY OF LATE MESOZOIC HETEROMORPHIC AMMONITES: A CASE FOR ALGAL<br />

SYMBIOSIS?<br />

RIVERA, Alexei A., 20404 Peridot Lane, Germantown, MD 20876, alexei.a.rivera@gmail.com<br />

Once touted as inadaptive products <strong>of</strong> “racial senility”, the heteromorphs curiously depart<br />

from the typical planispiral form <strong>of</strong> ammonites and occupy a radically divergent range <strong>of</strong><br />

shell morphologies. Some resembled hairpins, others snails or even worms. Late Mesozoic<br />

heteromorphs, which include the ancylocones and hamiticones, probably arose suddenly<br />

through a single mutation and have been subject to a number <strong>of</strong> ecological interpretations. The<br />

recognition that algal symbiosis is widespread among bivalves and gastropods suggests that<br />

perhaps other molluscan stocks, for instance these aberrant ammonites, also served as hosts for<br />

photosynthetic unicellular algae. To benefit from this mutualistic relationship, such hosts obviously<br />

require tissues that are exposed to sunlight. Although ontogeny controls life position, functional<br />

morphology strongly indicates that the terminal aperture <strong>of</strong> adult ancyloconic and hamiticonic<br />

shells were oriented upward towards the ocean surface. These openings conceivably sported a<br />

radial fan <strong>of</strong> delicate filtering tentacles, which may have been adapted both for ensnaring plankton<br />

and providing the extensive surface area necessary for efficient algal photosynthesis. Several<br />

species possess structural features characteristic <strong>of</strong> an internal or semi-internal shell, allowing<br />

for increased mantle exposure. Indeed, most reconstructions <strong>of</strong> these heteromorphs argue that<br />

they were shallow-water vertical migrants living in the epipelagic zone, well <strong>with</strong>in the bathymetric<br />

depths at which light penetrates. While ancylocones and hamiticones were not exclusively<br />

restricted to tropical latitudes, they were apparently more abundant and competitive in oligotrophic<br />

habitats. And though massive, robust skeletons and rapid calcification rates are usually<br />

associated <strong>with</strong> benthic hosts, such as reef-building corals, giant heteromorphs are known from<br />

the fossil record. Lastly, geochemical evidence from the Cretaceous hamiticone Polyptychoceras<br />

reveals a significant inverse correlation between δ18O and δ13C stable isotope values (‰ VPDB),<br />

which is consistent <strong>with</strong> the hypothesis <strong>of</strong> photosymbiosis.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!