11.04.2013 Views

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

Abstracts with Programs - Geological Society of America

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SESSION NO. 24, 8:00 AM<br />

Friday, 3 May 2013<br />

T5. Quaternary Research in the Great Lakes Region II:<br />

The Holocene, Part I<br />

Fetzer Center, Putney Auditorium<br />

24-1 8:00 AM Hladyniuk, Ryan [218332]<br />

THE N-ALKANE AND CARBON-ISOTOPE SIGNATURES OF ORGANIC CARBON IN LAKE<br />

ONTARIO SINCE 14,000 CAL YR BP<br />

HLADYNIUK, Ryan, DILDAR, Nadia, and LONGSTAFFE, Fred J., Department <strong>of</strong> Earth<br />

Sciences, The University <strong>of</strong> Western Ontario, 1151 Richmond Street, Biological and<br />

<strong>Geological</strong> Sciences Building, London, ON N6A5B7, Canada, rhladyni@uwo.ca<br />

The n-alkane abundances and carbon-isotope compositions <strong>of</strong> organic matter (OM) from Lake<br />

Ontario sediments reveal a complex history <strong>of</strong> variation in both source and lacustrine productivity<br />

over the last 14,000 cal yr BP. Glacial sediments containing ~0.2-0.3 % organic carbon (OC) are<br />

dominated by C23 through C29 n-alkanes. These compositions most likely represent allochtonous<br />

contributions <strong>of</strong> peat, higher terrestrial plant matter and clay-associated OM delivered by glacial<br />

meltwaters from the periglacial environment. Subordinate amounts <strong>of</strong> C17-C19 n-alkanes<br />

may indicate limited primary lacustrine productivity at this time. Transition from glacial to postglacial<br />

conditions in the Lake Ontario basin was marked by a lowering <strong>of</strong> water levels, rising<br />

OC contents, and increased abundances <strong>of</strong> C17-19 n-alkanes. Little systematic carbon isotopic<br />

variation was found for individual n-alkanes in the glacial and transitional sediments: C17-C19,<br />

–30 per mil; C21, –33 to –30 per mil; and C23+, –33 to –32 per mil, which likely reflects wellmixed,<br />

multiple OM sources. Hydraulic closure <strong>of</strong> Lake Ontario beginning at about 12,300 cal yr<br />

BP produced its lowest recorded levels. Approximately equal abundances <strong>of</strong> C17-C19, C23-C25,<br />

and C27+ n-alkanes at this time are tentatively interpreted to indicate lacustrine, (submergent)<br />

macrophyte and terrestrial OM contributions. C17-C19 n-alkanes showed little carbon isotopic<br />

variation from the older sediments. However, a 2 per mil decrease in carbon-13 for C23 and<br />

enrichments <strong>of</strong> ≤8 per mil for C25+ n-alkanes (C25> C27> C29) occurred by the end <strong>of</strong> hydraulic<br />

closure. Increased littoral zone productivity may have been favoured by low lake levels. Warming<br />

beginning at 8,300 cal yr BP triggered a transition from cold/dry to warm/wet conditions, during<br />

which water levels gradually rose. OC in associated lake sediments reaches 2 % and contains the<br />

highest fraction <strong>of</strong> C27+ n-alkanes, which have carbon isotopic compositions <strong>of</strong> –33 to –30 per<br />

mil. These data suggest that Lake Ontario received significant terrestrial OM from its catchment<br />

at this time. The progressive 5 per mil depletion <strong>of</strong> carbon-13 in C17 and C25 n-alkanes upwards<br />

through this interval remains to be explained.<br />

24-2 8:20 AM Loope, Walter L. [218627]<br />

CAN PALEOECOLOGICAL PROXIES ADEQUATELY FORECAST SURFACE COVER ACROSS<br />

NORTH CENTRAL NORTH AMERICA? (A CAUTIONARY TALE)<br />

LOOPE, Walter L., United States <strong>Geological</strong> Survey, N8391 Sand Point Road, P.O. Box 40,<br />

Munising, MI 49862, wloope@usgs.gov<br />

Pollen stratigraphy provides the core body <strong>of</strong> paleoecological perspective across north central<br />

North <strong>America</strong>. Pollen based methodologies have matured over nearly a century and are<br />

now joined by a vast and vetted literature focused on paleolimnology, wetland dynamics, soil<br />

stratigraphy and landscape ecology. The COHMAP project <strong>of</strong> the 1970s and 80s placed these<br />

data sets in spatial context across the continent and more recent updates and refinements <strong>of</strong><br />

these maps have been developed. The utility and importance <strong>of</strong> paleoecological models are more<br />

apparent given recognition <strong>of</strong> anthropogenic climate forcing. Concurrent <strong>with</strong> their adoption and<br />

broad use in discussions <strong>of</strong> such forcing, however, caveats and limitations <strong>of</strong> paleoecological<br />

data, prominently voiced by their authors, must be honored. Linda Brubaker, a pioneer in the<br />

application <strong>of</strong> pollen stratigraphy to Upper Michigan, recognized in 1975 that patchy habitats<br />

<strong>of</strong>ten impose permanent control on vegetation pattern on varying spatial scales. The scale <strong>of</strong><br />

patchiness varies across landscapes and greatly complicates their classification as well as<br />

any assessment <strong>of</strong> their projected behavior. In broad and roughly uniform landscapes these<br />

complications may be minimal; in patchy landscapes, they may defy intuition and interpretation.<br />

As Brubaker pointed out, some <strong>of</strong> the more obvious drivers <strong>of</strong> patchiness in the upper Midwest<br />

are differences in soil texture and development and in the nature <strong>of</strong> regolith. These differences<br />

are invisible in broad pattern but detectable on a local level. Pollen-based maps <strong>of</strong> surface cover<br />

in eastern Upper Michigan prove inadequate in detecting the major climatic anomaly that drove<br />

hydrologic closure <strong>of</strong> the Upper Great Lakes ~10-8 ka. In contrast, an intensive study <strong>of</strong> 2 ponds<br />

<strong>with</strong>in a small sandy tract in Alger County clearly identifies this and other major droughts at that<br />

time, albeit on different scales. Maps <strong>of</strong> Quaternary vegetation at sub-continental scales are<br />

useful across uniform environments but may fail to portray important local and even regional<br />

differences. This has long been recognized and expressed by pollen practitioners but may be<br />

glossed over by modelers who need to summarize projected change across the continent.<br />

24-3 8:40 AM Yansa, Catherine H. [218716]<br />

A 8500-YEAR RECORD OF LAKE-EFFECT CLIMATE FROM MINER LAKE, SOUTHWESTERN<br />

LOWER MICHIGAN<br />

YANSA, Catherine H., Department <strong>of</strong> Geography, Michigan State University, 227 Geography<br />

Building, East Lansing, MI 48824-1117, yansa@msu.edu and RAWLING, J. Elmo III,<br />

Geography/Geology, University <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin Platteville, 1 University Plaza, Platteville, WI<br />

53818<br />

Miner Lake (42.7°N, 85.8°W) in Allegan County, southwestern Lower Michigan, is located<br />

30 km east <strong>of</strong> Lake Michigan. Today, the local vegetation is comprised <strong>of</strong> primarily beech-maple<br />

forest and has a lake-mediated climate characterized by higher snowfall and warmer winter<br />

temperatures than inland locations. The objective <strong>of</strong> our research was to test whether the lakeeffect<br />

climate in the past was a more dominant influence on the local climate <strong>of</strong> the Miner Lake<br />

area than regional paleoclimate patterns. We did this by analyzing sediment cores from Miner<br />

Lake for pollen, plant macr<strong>of</strong>ossils and sedimentology (particle size, % organic matter (OM), and<br />

% calcium carbonate (CaCO )), and compared these data to paleoclimate data from two lakes<br />

3<br />

from inland locations <strong>with</strong> similar latitudes.<br />

Over the past 8500 cal yr BP, the sedimentology and paleobotany <strong>of</strong> Miner Lake indicate that<br />

there has been little environmental change in the area. In general, the %OM increases from ~25<br />

to 40%, %CaCO decreases from ~20 to 10% and the median grain size ranges from ~10 to 25<br />

3<br />

microns. The high %OM and CaCO , and fine median grain size in the sediments <strong>of</strong> Miner Lake<br />

3<br />

SESSION NO. 24<br />

suggest that this lake received little influx <strong>of</strong> clastic material. The pollen and plant macr<strong>of</strong>ossil<br />

records indicate four intervals <strong>of</strong> vegetation change. A pine-oak forest characterizes Zone I<br />

(~8500 to 7000 cal yr BP), prior to the arrival <strong>of</strong> beech in the region. Zone II (~7000-3200 cal yr<br />

BP) is that <strong>of</strong> a beech-maple forest <strong>with</strong> oak patches. Percentages <strong>of</strong> beech and maple are higher<br />

than in the two comparative pollen records, indicating that moisture provided by the lake-effect<br />

climate prevailed in the Miner Lake area during the peak Holocene warmth. Zone III (~3200-200<br />

cal yr BP) is characterized by cooler and moister conditions, as suggested by expansion <strong>of</strong> the<br />

beech-maple forest. Median grain size is most variable in Zone III. Zone IV (last 200 years) is<br />

distinguished by a spike in disturbance weeds, a sharp decrease in %OM, a dramatic increase<br />

in %CaCO 3 , and a sharp decrease in median grain size, likely resulting from agriculture. In<br />

summary, the paleoclimate record <strong>of</strong> Miner Lake was, for the most part, invariant during the past<br />

several millennia, which suggests that a “lake effect” climate induced by nearby Lake Michigan<br />

was a more dominant control than the regional climate for this site.<br />

24-4 9:00 AM Sonnenburg, Elizabeth [218504]<br />

PALEOENVIRONMENTAL RECONSTRUCTION OF THE ALPENA-AMBERLEY RIDGE<br />

SUBMERGED LANDSCAPE DURING THE LAKE STANLEY LOWSTAND (CA. 8.4-9 KA CAL<br />

BP), LAKE HURON<br />

SONNENBURG, Elizabeth, Museum <strong>of</strong> Anthropology, University <strong>of</strong> Michigan, Ruthven<br />

Museums Building 4016, 1109 Geddes Avenue, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, esonnenb@umich.edu<br />

The Great Lakes basin has high potential for submerged archaeological sites due to considerable<br />

water level changes during deglaciation and as a result <strong>of</strong> Holocene climate change. The<br />

Holocene period in the Great Lakes basin (ca. last 12,000 years) was marked by several phases<br />

<strong>of</strong> drier climate and low lake levels (lowstands) including major events between ca. 11,300-8,400<br />

cal BP recorded in sediments in Lake Huron and Georgian Bay (Lake Hough and Lake Stanley<br />

lowstands). During the Lake Stanley phase water levels in the Lake Huron basin were up to<br />

70-100 m below present and large areas <strong>of</strong> the lake bed were exposed terrestrial landscapes.<br />

In 2007 and 2008, a 300 meter-long series <strong>of</strong> boulders was discovered on the Alpena-Amberley<br />

Ridge in 30 m <strong>of</strong> water in Lake Huron during a side-scan sonar survey. The boulders, when<br />

mapped, resembled caribou drive lanes which are well-documented in the Arctic. During the Lake<br />

Stanley lowstand phase, the Ridge was a sub-aerially exposed causeway separating the lake into<br />

two basins, and the discovery <strong>of</strong> the potential drive lanes provides compelling albeit circumstantial<br />

evidence that the Ridge supported human habitation during the early Holocene. Little is known<br />

about the paleogeography and environment <strong>of</strong> the Ridge since there is limited sedimentation,<br />

and most lake-level and paleoenvironmental research in Lake Huron has focused on the more<br />

sediment loaded basins <strong>of</strong> the Georgian and Saginaw Bays. In 2011 and 2012, a total <strong>of</strong> sixtyseven<br />

core, sediment and rock samples were collected by divers and ponar sampler on an<br />

ROV. Thirty-six surface sediment grab samples and six short (10-25 cm) cores were obtained<br />

for analysis <strong>of</strong> microdebitage, micr<strong>of</strong>ossils, grain size, and organic content. Cores were subsampled<br />

at 2 cm intervals for analysis, lith<strong>of</strong>acies logged in detail and photographed. Preliminary<br />

paleoenvrionmental reconstructions based on results from these samples indicate that during the<br />

last Lake Stanley phase, the Ridge was a relatively stable landscape <strong>with</strong> sub-artic vegetation,<br />

small shallow ponds, sphagnum bogs, wetlands and rivers, and would have provided numerous<br />

potential resources for both caribou and pre-historic hunter-gathers.<br />

24-5 9:40 AM Thompson, Todd A. [218327]<br />

THE ELEVATION OF THE PEAK NIPISSING PHASE (MID HOLOCENE) AT OUTLETS OF THE<br />

UPPER GREAT LAKES<br />

THOMPSON, Todd A., Indiana <strong>Geological</strong> Survey, Indiana University, 611 North Walnut<br />

Grove, Bloomington, IN 47405-2208, tthomps@indiana.edu, JOHNSTON, John W.,<br />

Department <strong>of</strong> Physical and Chemical Sciences, University <strong>of</strong> Toronto Mississauga,<br />

3359 Mississauga Road N, Mississauga, ON L5L 1C6, Canada, and LEPPER, Kenneth,<br />

Department <strong>of</strong> Geosciences, North Dakota State University, P.O. Box 6050, Dept. #2745,<br />

Fargo, ND 58108-6050<br />

The Nipissing phase <strong>of</strong> ancestral Lakes Michigan, Huron, and Superior was the last pre-modern<br />

highstand <strong>of</strong> the upper Great Lakes. Reconstructions <strong>of</strong> past lake-level change and glacial<br />

isostatic adjustment (GIA), as well as activation and abandonment <strong>of</strong> outlets is dependent on<br />

an understanding <strong>of</strong> the elevation <strong>of</strong> the lake at each outlet. More than one hundred years <strong>of</strong><br />

study has established the gross elevation <strong>of</strong> the Nipissing phase at each outlet, but the mixing<br />

<strong>of</strong> geomorphic and sedimentologic data has produced interpreted outlet elevations varying by<br />

least several meters. Vibracore facies, optically stimulated luminescence and radiocarbon age<br />

control, and ground-penetrating radar transects from new and published studies were collected to<br />

determine peak Nipissing water-level elevations for the Port Huron (Lake Huron), Chicago (Lake<br />

Michigan), and Sault (Lake Superior) outlets. These data and published relative hydrographs<br />

were combined to produce one residual hydrograph for the Port Huron outlet from 6,000 to<br />

3,500 calendar years ago that best defines the rise, peak, and rapid fall <strong>of</strong> the Nipissing phase.<br />

Establishing accurate elevations at the only present-day unregulated outlet <strong>of</strong> the Great Lakes<br />

and the only ancient outlet that has played a critical role in draining the upper Great Lakes<br />

since the middle Holocene is a critical step to better understand GIA and water-level change<br />

geologically and historically. The geologic context may provide the insight required for water<br />

managers to make informed decisions to best manage the largest freshwater system in the world.<br />

24-6 10:00 AM Hanson, Paul R. [218692]<br />

IMPACT OF THE NIPISSING AND ALGOMA HIGH LAKE PHASES FROM OSL DATING OF<br />

BAYMOUTH BARRIER SYSTEMS IN THE DOOR PENINSULA, WISCONSIN<br />

HANSON, Paul R., School <strong>of</strong> Natural Resources, University <strong>of</strong> Nebraska-Lincoln, 3310<br />

Holdrege Street, Lincoln, NE 68583, phanson2@unl.edu and RAWLING, J.E. III, Geography<br />

and Geology Program, University <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin-Platteville, Platteville, WI 53818<br />

This study focuses on the geomorphology and geochronology <strong>of</strong> three baymouth barrier systems<br />

at Clark, Europe and Kangaroo Lakes in the Door Peninsula <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin. The Lake Michigan<br />

shoreline in the peninsula contains abundant evidence for fluctuations in lake level as evidenced<br />

by strandplains and beach ridges that lie up to ~ 7 m above the present shoreline. Our study was<br />

conducted on three baymouth barriers that contain beach ridges that were buried by varying<br />

depths <strong>of</strong> eolian sand in the form <strong>of</strong> sandsheets, as well as parabolic and transverse dunes <strong>with</strong><br />

relief <strong>of</strong> up to 21 m. The purpose <strong>of</strong> this study was to document when the barriers were deposited<br />

and when the subsequent eolian activity occurred. Our chronology for barrier emplacement and<br />

dune development is based on 65 OSL samples which were collected from lacustrine sediment<br />

<strong>with</strong>in the barrier fills (n = 17) and the overlying eolian sand (n = 48). Sediment samples were<br />

collected using bucket augers or a vibracoring device at depths ranging from 0.5 to 4.1 m below<br />

the ground surface. Our OSL ages show that baymouth barriers in each <strong>of</strong> our study sites were<br />

constructed between ~ 5.9 to 3.9 ka, and most <strong>of</strong> our ages correspond closely to the Nipissing<br />

high lake level phase. Both geomorphic and geochronological evidence from the Kangaroo Lake<br />

site shows portions <strong>of</strong> this barrier were re-occupied after the Nipissing phase. Our OSL ages<br />

from lacustrine sediment taken from <strong>with</strong>in the barrier suggest this occurred at 3.3 to 2.5 ka,<br />

2013 GSA North-Central Section Meeting 55

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!