Form 20-F 2005
Form 20-F 2005
Form 20-F 2005
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
KoSa France Holding<br />
KoSa France Holding S.A.R.L. (new partner of Rhodianyl in the Butachimie Joint Venture) filed a counter-arbitration proceeding<br />
on October 1, <strong>20</strong>04 before the Arbitration Court of the International Chamber of Commerce (the “ICC”). At the same time, an initial<br />
arbitration proceeding at the same Arbitration Court was in progress between Rhodianyl SNC and DuPont de Nemours (France)<br />
S.A.S. (its former partner in the Butachimie Joint Venture), in order to counter balance the expected ruling in the Rhodianyl/DuPont<br />
de Nemours (France) S.A.S. case. In the initial arbitration proceeding, Rhodianyl was asking the Arbitration Court to recognize the<br />
non-existence of any geographical limitations and/or material in relation to the sale, marketing export or use of the ADN produced<br />
by Butachimie. This case was decided in favor of Rhodianyl in the final ruling on June 13, <strong>20</strong>05 (final ruling, which cannot be<br />
appealed). Under these circumstances, the main claims (principally based on the opposite claims as those made by Rhodianyl<br />
and identical to those of DuPont France in its initial arbitration) made by KoSa France Holding in the counter-arbitration proceeding<br />
– for the amount of approximately €37 million lowered to €21.5 million in January <strong>20</strong>06, to which KoSa maintains should be added<br />
sums equaling affected sales in <strong>20</strong>06 until the award is rendered, or alternatively a sum of €147 million – are without merit and do<br />
not appear to be admissible by the Arbitration Court of the ICC. An arbitral award should be issued in the third quarter of <strong>20</strong>06. We<br />
have not recognized any provision with respect to this matter.<br />
Other procedures<br />
Securities and Exchange Board of India<br />
We are involved in proceedings in India brought by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”), which is seeking to require<br />
us to launch a public tender for <strong>20</strong>% of the shares of Albright & Wilson Chemicals India Limited (“AWCIL”), a listed subsidiary of<br />
the group formerly known as Albright & Wilson, which we acquired in <strong>20</strong>00. AWCIL is a listed Indian subsidiary of which we now<br />
own 72.79%. We would be required to acquire shares at a price of 278 rupees per share, based on the value of those shares at the<br />
time of our acquisition of Albright & Wilson, and increased by interest accrued since <strong>20</strong>00. An adverse decision by the SEBI would<br />
result in an increase in our holding of AWCIL from 72.79% to 92.79%. We would then be required, as a result of crossing the 90%<br />
threshold, to launch a mandatory public tender offer (or “squeeze out”) for the remaining 7.21% of the outstanding shares for the<br />
same price. In this case, we would therefore acquire all shares that we currently do not own (27.21%) for a total of approximately<br />
€7.2 million. We are contesting the SEBI’s proceeding on the merits. A final decision by the High Court of Mumbai, which is hearing<br />
the case on our appeal following an initial unfavorable judgment, is expected to occur in <strong>20</strong>06.<br />
Oil for food Program<br />
Two of our subsidiaries, Rhodia Silicones and Rhodia Middle East Jordan, were named in the report of the United Nations independent<br />
investigation committee concerning the “Oil for Food Program” in Iraq. The report notes alleged illicit payments worth $1.7 million<br />
made in regard to petroleum surpluses and humanitarian aid in the context of contracts with Iraq. We are conducting an internal<br />
investigation into this matter. At this stage, we have no knowledge of wrongdoing by our management or employees.<br />
US Department of Justice<br />
In the United States, on January 14, <strong>20</strong>04, one of our subsidiaries, Rhodia Inc., entered into a plea agreement with the U.S. Department<br />
of Justice in which it acknowledged the violation of certain provisions of the U.S. Federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act<br />
regarding waste storage at its former phosphorous manufacturing plant in Silver Bow, Montana. Rhodia Inc. also entered into an<br />
agreement with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency regarding future assessment and remediation of certain contamination<br />
at the site. This plea agreement was reviewed at a sentencing proceeding in April <strong>20</strong>04. An $18 million fine was paid in <strong>20</strong>04 and<br />
Rhodia Inc. is subject to a five year probation. In addition, Rhodia Inc. entered into an agreement with the U.S. Environmental<br />
<strong>Form</strong> <strong>20</strong> - F <strong>20</strong>05 - Rhodia<br />
83