Everyone counts: all cultures contribute towards learning for a sustainable worldEnvironmental changeFew of the ESD programmes reviewed measured theirsuccess in terms of environmental outcomes. Therewas a common understanding that there is a need tochange the way we think and act to address unsustainabledevelopment. Therefore, most programmes soughtprimarily socio-economic or educational outcomes, as itwas understood that this would lead to environmentalchange 11 in the long term.Nevertheless, many of these initiatives did make directand indirect contributions to environmental change.These contributions included improving environmentalmanagement practices of schools and universities;protecting biodiversity and natural resources in smallrural communities; changing the consumer choicesof shoppers; reducing the environmental impact ofbusinesses; adoption of environment-friendly technoloissuesare often intertwined, it is helpful to consider the dynamicsand priorities at each level.Social changeA review of the case studies indicates that every project soughtsocial change 10 for sustainable development. Social change occursat a number of levels and in various contexts; for example, it canrange from changing consumer choices, to challenging businesspractices, to rediscovering (or revaluing) traditional knowledge andlocal languages. The ESD initiatives under review focus on particularsocial groups such as business leaders, youth, students, farmers,academics or vulnerable/socially excluded communities. They aimto empower these groups through capacity-building to develop newambitions for the future and to engage in social change to achievethem. These types of initiatives challenge visions, personal andprofessional practices, and lifestyle and consumer choices.At the heart of the ESD initiatives is an assumption that currentsocial frameworks and practices are exploiting people and theirenvironments. This means that the attainment of sustainable developmentrequires transformative change at the social and/or culturallevel. Some programmes and strategies explicitly refer to the creationof social capital as a key outcome of ESD initiatives. This requiresbuilding the confidence and skills to support engagement amongstakeholders, to improve their own and others’ lives, livelihoodsand environments.Many initiatives encourage consideration of new social frameworks,which link the protection of traditional cultural practices andindigenous knowledge to the exploration of new economic marketsand technological innovations that are more beneficial to peopleand to the planet. The type of capacity-building that is promoted isoften culturally sensitive and responsive to local needs and cultures.Intercultural dialogue and respect for cultural diversity underpinmany of these efforts to promote ESD and these kinds of outcomesare used to measure the success of initiatives.Some ESD initiatives measured their success by assessing thedegree of participation by target groups in sustainable developmentissues. Many such programmes prioritise citizen/employee/learnerparticipation and view active engagement in social issues as keyto the attainment of sustainable development. Other projects focusupon engagement of organizations or institutions, and their goalsImage: © UNESCO/Michel Ravassardtake the form of leadership for change towards sustainabledevelopment.Increasingly, notions of building social capital orcapacity for transition feature prominently in the goalsof ESD programmes. The notion of transition considersthe need for social adaptation to address current andfuture socio-economic and environmental realities. Itinvolves civil society, governments and professionalsin projects that illustrate social practices more clearlyaligned with sustainability. These projects’ impacts areassessed in terms of whether the ‘demonstration’ initiativeshave influenced mindset and social practices.Economic changeA large number of the case studies sought economicchange. These varied from improving the employabilityprospects of young people, to seeking costreductions in operational management, to providingincentives and/or skills to develop local economies.Many of these initiatives also sought improvementin the management of existing human, financial andnatural resources, with the aim of reducing environmentalimpact as well as expenditure.Interestingly, there was a clear sense across these initiativesthat it is important to develop economic literacyalongside environmental literacy. The need to changecurrent models of economic practice and not just pursuefurther economic development in line with existing modelsalso underpinned the ESD programmes featured. Neweconomic models, which were more responsible towardspeople and environments, were often explored as part ofthese initiatives. Such programmes often offered an opportunityfor stakeholders to consider commercial venturesaligned with sustainable development (e.g. organicfarming or ecotourism). Capacity-building for economicchange was a common feature of most programmes andthis involved the development of new skills and experiencesto support more sustainable forms of development.The capacity-building components supported individualsand groups to change their own practices as well as thoseof the systems within which they operate.[ 147 ]
Learning for change: the key to a sustainable futuregies in government; improving environmental health in excludedcommunities; and reducing ecological footprints and vulnerabilityto climate change.Much has been written about the relationship between education (orlearning) and environmental outcomes and impacts. 12 Many organizationsthat have conservation, biodiversity and environmental objectivesat the heart of their missions seek environmental action and change andsee education as an important platform for achieving these outcomes.It is important to note that there is widespread recognition that theachievement of these outcomes depends on processes of participation,inquiry and social learning to challenge existing unsustainable frameworksand practices, rather than the transmission of knowledge or thetraining of individuals and groups to behave in particular ways.Educational changeSome of the initiatives reviewed targeted pupils and students, employees,civil servants or community members, and built their capacity tocontribute to change. The majority of the initiatives, however, adopted asystemic approach to change, seeking to challenge existing educationalsystems, structures and/or practices, not just the knowledge and abilityof learners to engage with sustainable development. The reorientation ofeducation was seen as a core goal of these programmes. In other words,the contribution or success of these ESD initiatives was measured interms of the extent of educational change that had been achieved.The need to align education systems and practices to sustainabledevelopment is recognized as a priority by the DESD. This consists of:• The adoption of new ways of thinking about teaching andlearning• The active engagement of the learner in an exploratory learningprocess which builds capacity as well as knowledge• Changing education policies and curricula• Changing the professional development of facilitators and theeducation of teachers• Creating a culture of organizational learning and change towardssustainable development• Creating a culture of social learning where informal contextsprovide opportunities.A smaller number of the programmes reviewed appear to have adopteda holistic approach to change. Some ESD programmes contributed toImage:© UNESCO/Niamh Burkechallenging adult and child mindsets regarding exploitationof the environment. They also encouraged teachersto adopt sustainability education thinking and pedagogiesand to contribute to changing mainstream educationpractice. Some extended their contribution to supportingorganisational learning and change across the educationsystem, including the government ministries thatsupported it.The shifting of pedagogical approaches rather thanthe embedding of core sustainable development contentin the curriculum were key outcomes sought by manyof the initiatives reviewed. Another frequent feature ofthese initiatives was the emphasis they placed upon thecreation of learning partnerships.The contribution of the DESD to a better worldProcesses and learning in ESD 13 form the basis of the 2011DESD Monitoring and Evaluation Report. In this context,the term ‘processes’ refers to engagement opportunities,pedagogical approaches, or teaching and learning stylesadopted to implement ESD at different educational levelsand in varied educational settings. ‘Learning’ for ESD refersto the learning experienced by all those engaged in ESD,including learners themselves, facilitators, coordinators andfunders. Often learning in ESD is interpreted as gainingknowledge, values and theories related to sustainabledevelopment. In addition, the research undertaken as partof Phase II showed that ESD learning also means learning toask critical questions, envision more positive futures, clarifyone’s own values, think systemically, respond throughapplied learning opportunities, and explore the dialecticbetween tradition and innovation. 14The literature has only recently begun to feature evaluativestudies that map the intended and existing contributionof ESD to bringing about changes for a better world. Effortscan be assessed in terms of outcomes, outputs and impactsof initiatives. The review of initiatives suggests that it ispossible to map a wide range of contributions through ESDto economic, environmental, social (including cultural)and educational change. A range of potential contributions,themes and priorities is apparent across these key initiatives.There is a need to recognize, however, that ESD remainspoorly researched and weakly evidenced. This review hasbeen informed mainly by programme or context-specificresearch studies and programme evaluations. There is alack of meta-analysis studies or longitudinal research. Thismeans there is not sufficient evidence to provide conclusiveresponses to the core questions that drive similar investigationsinto the value of ESD as a field of research and practice.These issues confront the Phase II monitoring and evaluationreport as it attempts to provide robust and meaningfulevidence of the impact of the DESD initiative as a whole.As the DESD continues, it is to be hoped that there will bemany opportunities to address these challenges.This document draws from Tilbury (<strong>2010</strong>) ‘AssessingESD Experiences during the DESD: An expert reviewof processes and learning for ESD’ commissioned byUNESCO Paris[ 148 ]
- Page 1 and 2:
TOMORROW TODAYUnited NationsEducati
- Page 9:
THE HONOURABLE DIANE MCGIFFORD, CHA
- Page 15 and 16:
ANNA TIBAIJUKA, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,
- Page 17:
KONRAD OSTERWALDER, RECTOR, UNITED
- Page 25 and 26:
Image: Lyle BenkoMid-Decade Assembl
- Page 28 and 29:
levels, and is an efficient mechani
- Page 32:
levels of education, taking part in
- Page 35 and 36:
Sustainable school feedingNancy Wal
- Page 37 and 38:
Image: WFP/Rein SkullerudImage: WFP
- Page 39 and 40:
How the Education for Rural People
- Page 41 and 42:
Image: FAOThe Education for Rural P
- Page 43 and 44:
Education for sustainable citiesTra
- Page 45 and 46:
Image: UN-HABITATChild washing hand
- Page 47:
sustainable land management practic
- Page 52:
Image: Inpyoung Elementary SchoolIm
- Page 55 and 56:
Reaching young people with sexual a
- Page 58 and 59:
Image: © BBC World Service Trust 2
- Page 62 and 63:
Image: Nat. Comm. UNESCO ChinaThe S
- Page 64 and 65:
Image: Japanese Nat. Comm. for UNES
- Page 66:
in July 2005, the RCE network has c
- Page 69 and 70:
Image: SEAMEO RIHEDThe third meetin
- Page 71 and 72:
Image: CEEImage: CEEYoung graduates
- Page 73 and 74:
Developing informed fishingcommunit
- Page 75 and 76:
Image: S Jayaraj, BOBP-IGOImage: S
- Page 77 and 78:
Let’s take care of the planet:edu
- Page 79 and 80:
Image: Ministry of Education, Brazi
- Page 82 and 83:
ten provinces and three territories
- Page 84 and 85:
provide tools and materials to supp
- Page 86 and 87:
• Projects for senior citizens, w
- Page 88 and 89:
From activists to the inclusion of
- Page 90 and 91:
Sweden’s pioneering role ineducat
- Page 92 and 93:
• Exposure to Swedish and interna
- Page 94 and 95:
To strengthen ESD work in the Nordi
- Page 96 and 97:
From personally relevant experience
- Page 98 and 99: Image: © Peter PurgBBCC members at
- Page 100 and 101: Beyond boundaries: implementing edu
- Page 102 and 103: Hurricane Gustav over the Caribbean
- Page 104 and 105: the first thirty years of the life
- Page 106: Image: NIE, SingaporeThe purpose-bu
- Page 109 and 110: Image: USM(ii) Alternative universi
- Page 111 and 112: Citizenship Project brings sustaina
- Page 113: During the workshop, the undergradu
- Page 117 and 118: GLE research campImage: GLOBE Thail
- Page 119 and 120: Minister. This is a step towards en
- Page 121 and 122: Caring for people through education
- Page 124 and 125: Politics and civil society in the U
- Page 126 and 127: National Committee in three ways. F
- Page 128 and 129: critically highly skilled human res
- Page 130 and 131: Child rights and equity throughclim
- Page 132 and 133: Image: © UNICEF/NYHQ2007-1390/Giac
- Page 134 and 135: Perspectives on higher education fo
- Page 136 and 137: Image: © RCE Graz-StyriaSignboard
- Page 138 and 139: African higher education networking
- Page 140: Collaborative links within an RCESo
- Page 143 and 144: Image: © RCE ZombaImage: UNU-IASSt
- Page 145 and 146: esearchers from developing countrie
- Page 147: Change for a better world:assessing
- Page 151 and 152: Curriculum and Instruction: Interna
- Page 153 and 154: identified. 8 These agents of chang
- Page 155 and 156: Turning today’s youth into tomorr
- Page 157 and 158: and implementation is based on an i
- Page 159 and 160: Image: Paulo Freire InstituteSeeds
- Page 161 and 162: Helping people take control of thei
- Page 163 and 164: Sihuan, China - Bio-digestors addre
- Page 165 and 166: of ‘sustainability’ that is mos
- Page 167 and 168: Entrepreneurship as thefishing rod
- Page 169 and 170: Image: GET’10 in East AfricaImage
- Page 171 and 172: WikiQuESD authoring and learning pl
- Page 173 and 174: Transforming childhood: from reinfo
- Page 175 and 176: Young students plant a vegetable ga
- Page 177: Image: © UNESCO/Katy AnisEducation
- Page 180 and 181: Democratizing education:the quantit
- Page 182 and 183: Image: FLAMEThe quality of college
- Page 184 and 185: The foundations of ESDin early chil
- Page 186: Free-range ecological hens, indoors
- Page 189 and 190: Waste in and around schoolscommunit
- Page 191 and 192: Promoting education for sustainable
- Page 193 and 194: of Education for Sustainable Develo