Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies - NIHR Health ...

© Queen’s Printer and Controller of HMSO 2003. All rights reserved.AuthorOrigin aModified toolTool purpose bStudy designscovered cType of tool d(weighting)Lee, 1997 189 m Cook and Campbell, 7 RCTs, between-subjects s e n n 7 na na na na na n n1979 50 design; within-subjectsdesignLee, 1994 312 n 7 RCTs, NRS s e n n 29 na 94% a na na na n nLevine, 1980 190 n 3 CCTs s e n n 30 na na na na na n y 313Linde, 1999 95 n 2/7 RCTs, NRS s e n n 7 Cr na na na na n y 314Lionel, 1970 315 n 3 Prospective therapeutic c n n 42 na na na na na n ntrialsLittenberg, 1998 316 n 7 RCTs, comparative studies; s e n n 5 na na na na na n nCSLongnecker, 1988 317 n 7 CCS, CCS s u n y 15 na na na na na n nLuborsky, 1975 318 m Fiske, 1970 404 2 RCTs, NRS s e n n 12 na 0.84 r na na na n nLyons, 1991 319 m Smith, 1980 364 7 RCTs, NRS c n n 28 na na na na na n nMacLehose, 2000 26 m Downs and Black, 7 RCTs, NRS; Coh; CCS s n n NR FC, > 60% a na na na n n1998 85 CoMacMillan, 1994 191 m Chalmers, 1981 51 7 RCTs, NRS s u n n 9 na >90% a na na na n nMahon, 1964 320 n 3 Drug trials c n n 4 na na na na na n nMargetts, 1995 321 n 3 Coh, CCS s u n y 31 na CCS 0.71 r ; Similar na na n nCoh 0.92 rMargolis, 1995 322 n 7 RCTs, NRS c n n 6? na na na na na n nNRMarrs, 1995 323 n 7 RCTs, NRS c n n 22 na Categorical na na na n nvariables: 0.891 K(0.625–1);continuous variables:0.933 K (0.693–1)Massy, 1995 324 n 7 RCTs, CTs; uncontrolled s u n y 14 na na na na na n nstudiesItems justified?Items by design?No. of itemsTool validity eInter-raterreliability fIntra-raterreliability fTest-retest fInternalconsistency fTime to completeUsed in otherreviews?Review referencenumbercontinuedHealth Technology Assessment 2003; Vol. 7: No. 27129