Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies - NIHR Health ...

© Queen’s Printer and Controller of HMSO 2003. All rights reserved.AuthorOrigin aModified toolTool purpose bStudy designscovered cType of tool d(weighting)Mullen, 1992 274 m Haynes, 1976 273 7 RCTs, NRS c n n NR na 90.6% a na na na n nMulrow, 1986 197 n 7 RCTs, NRS; Coh c n n 13 na 94% a na na na n nMurtagh, 1995 332 n 7 Any c n y 17 na 95% a na na na n nNaldi, 1990 333 m Chalmers, 1981 51 2 RCTs, NRS; Coh c n n 8 na na na na na n nNaylor, 1987 334 m Chalmers, 1981 51 7 RCTs, NRS s n n NR na na na na na n nNewcastle-Ottawa 66 n 7 Coh, CCS s u n y 8 na na na na na n nNicolucci, 1989 77 m Chalmers, 1981 51 7 RCTs s u n n 16 na 88% a na na na n y 335Nielsen, 1985 336 n 3 Any c n n 24 na na na na na n nNyberg, 1974 337 n Jonsson, 1969 406 1/3 CCTs s e n n 11 na na na na na n nOakley, 1994 128 n 7 RCTs, CTs c n n 8 na na na na na n y 338–340Ogilvie-Harris, 1995 341 m Weiler, 1992 388 7 RCTs, CCTs s e n n 10 na na na na na n nOsberg, 1997 342 n 2 Outcome research c n n 8 FC na na na na n nOxman, 1994 343 n 7 RCTs, NRS c n n 6 na na na na na n nPowe, 1994 344 n 7 NRS, s e n y 11 na 93.5 K na na na n nPuig Barbera, 1995 345 n 7 RCTs, Coh c n n 8 na na na na na n nReisch, 1989 111 n 1/3 Therapeutic studies s e n n 57 na 0.99 P for objective na na na n y Cochranescore; 0.71 P forIBDsubjective score 114GroupRey, 1997 346 n 7 RCTs, Coh or case reports s n n 5 na na na na na n nRied, 1994 347 m Chalmers, 1981 51 7 RCTs, CCTs s e n n 9 na na na na na n nRowe, 1997 348 n 7 RCTs, NRS; uncontrolled s n n 12 na na na na na n nItems justified?Items by design?No. of itemsTool validity eInter-raterreliability fIntra-raterreliability fTest-retest fInternalconsistency fTime to completeUsed in otherreviews?Review referencenumbercontinuedHealth Technology Assessment 2003; Vol. 7: No. 27131