Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies - NIHR Health ...
Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies - NIHR Health ...
Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies - NIHR Health ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
144Author Review IV type b Topic Total RCTs NRS Other Type of QA Tool QA results dtype atool cDe Oliveira, 1996 246 MA Pharm Schizophrenia 18 ? ? 0 S de Oliveira, 1995 96 NR; all scored above acertain thresholdDetsky, 1987 309 MA Diet Surgical patients 18 11 7 0 S L’Abbe, 1987 120 OSDevine, 1992 250 MA Psych Surgical patients 173 119 54 0 C Author’s own Not reportedDevine, 1983 251 MA Psych Postsurgical patients 49 37 12 0 C Author’s own No. meeting certaincriteriaDevine, 1995 252 MA Psych-ed Hypertension 88 51 37 0 NR Author’s own No. using each methodof assignmentDevine, 1995 253 MA Psych Cancer 98 67 31 0 C Author’s own Not reportedDodhia, 1998 368 Nar Pharm Pertussis transmission 13 2 4 7 LoE Stevens and Raftery, 1994 367 Not reportedDowns, 1996 112 Nar Surg Stress incontinence 76 11 65 0 S Downs, 1998 85 ItemisedDurlak, 1997 255 MA Prim prev Mental health 177 108 69 0 C Author’s own No. meeting eachcriteria reportedEastwood, 1996 394 Nar Org Asthma care 27 9 4 14 C CRD guidelines 119 NarEPI Centre, 1996 338 Nar H promo Sexual health 110 34 NS NS C Oakley, 1994 128 No. each criteriareportedErnst, 1998 287 Nar Alt med Dental pain 16 11 5 0 S Jadad, 1996 46 Itemised; OSErnst, 1998 302 Nar Alt med Muscle soreness 8 3 5 0 S Kleijnen, 1991 69 OSFiscella, 1995 267 Nar Other Pregnancy 50 11 12 C Gordis, 1990 101 NarFlint, 1995 326 Nar Respite Dementia 4 2 2 0 C McMaster, 1981 80 NarcareFloyd, 1997 371 MA Psych Mental health 25 ? ? 0 S Suydam, 1968 370 Not reportedFoxcroft, 1997 340 Nar Psych Alcohol misuse 33 ? ? 0 C Oakley, 1994 128 % meeting eachcriterion reportedGam, 1995 229 MA Physio Musculoskeletal disorders 22 9 13 0 C Chalmers, 1981 51 % meeting eachcriterion reportedGansevoort, 1995 261 MA Pharm Hypertension 41 20 21 0 C Author’s own ItemisedGarg, 1998 263 Nar Pharm Myocarditis 7 3 4 0 C Author’s own ItemisedGlantz, 1997 182 MA Other Obstetrics 5 2 3 0 S Modified Chalmers, 1981 51 Itemised; OSAppendix 6continued