22.11.2016 Views

(Part 1)

JBTM_13-2_Fall_2016

JBTM_13-2_Fall_2016

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

JBTM Book Reviews<br />

119<br />

One of the weaknesses of the volume was the inconsistent assessment of the imputation<br />

of sin. For example, Macleod’s chapter presents two Reformed views of imputation in<br />

the Reformed tradition, the mediate view (inherited corruption which later results in guilt)<br />

and the immediate view (inherited guilt) (139–41). Contributors such as Yarborough and<br />

Hamilton speak of the inheritance from Adam in terms of sin, death, and corruption, and<br />

their chapters are consistent with the mediate view. However, Madueme locates the denial<br />

of inherited guilt with Pelagius (226). Also, Schreiner argues against both the interpretations<br />

of both Pelagius and Blocher’s mediate view of imputation (275–78). A reader might<br />

infer from the views of Madueme and Schreiner that one must explicitly affirm inherited<br />

guilt. However, Yarborough and Hamilton do not affirm inherited guilt in their biblicaltheological<br />

treatments of original sin. It seems that the Reformed tradition remains unclear<br />

on whether one must explicitly affirm inherited, or alien, guilt.<br />

Another weakness of the book was the insertion of human inability when discussing<br />

human sinfulness (253). One can affirm the universal sinfulness of humanity while rejecting<br />

the extreme positions of both human goodness and human inability. Finally, neither<br />

the title nor the subtitle reflect the organization of the material in the book. Presently,<br />

the book promises by its title to address Adam, the fall, and original sin. In the subtitle, it<br />

promises to address theological, biblical, and scientific perspectives. However, the major<br />

parts of the book deal with “Adam in the Bible and Science” (part 1), “Original Sin in History”<br />

(part 2), “Original Sin in Theology” (part 3), and “Adam and the Fall in Dispute” (<strong>Part</strong><br />

4). Perhaps in a subsequent edition, book chapters could be reorganized to reflect the order<br />

of topics presented in either the book’s title or its subtitle.<br />

Even with weaknesses noted above, the book should be required reading for all who<br />

desire to consider a comprehensive case for a historical Adam, his fall, and the doctrine<br />

known as original sin.<br />

- Adam Harwood, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, New Orleans, Louisiana<br />

Advances in the Study of Greek: New Insights for Reading the New Testament. By Constantine<br />

R. Campbell. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2015. 253 pages. Paperback, $34.99.<br />

Constantine R. Campbell is associate professor of New Testament at Trinity Evangelical<br />

Divinity School in Deerfield, Illinois, where he has served on faculty since 2013. He previously<br />

served as a senior lecturer in Greek and New Testament at Moore Theological College<br />

in Sydney, Australia. Campbell received a PhD from Macquarie University and is the<br />

author of several books including Basics of Verbal Aspect in Biblical Greek, Keep Your Greek:<br />

Strategies for Busy People, and Paul and Union with Christ: An Exegetical and Theological Study.<br />

His most recent work is Colossians and Philemon: A Handbook on the Greek Text.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!