13.08.2013 Views

Environmental Assessment

Environmental Assessment

Environmental Assessment

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

AFFECTED ENVIRONMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES CHAPTER 3<br />

product industries both economically and culturally. Other communities within the Zone (such as<br />

Paulina, Silver Lake) can generally be defined as ranching or farming communities. These communities<br />

are closely tied to the Forests in work, subsistence, and play, and are directly affected by what happens on<br />

the Forests. These communities are linked more economically because of the need for summer forage for<br />

livestock, not timber, and to provide services for recreation and tourists. These communities generally<br />

have no manufacturing based industries and have small, undiversified economies. Like “rural industrial<br />

communities”, the people who reside in these communities use fuelwood, fish, and game for part of their<br />

subsistence and also recreational activities.<br />

The one over-riding demographic trend in the area is that of rapid population increase through inmigration.<br />

With the general gentrification that is occurring through the area and the influx of retirees,<br />

many of who are well to do, and professionals from many specialty areas, is resulting in rapid economic<br />

and social change.<br />

Economic and Social Analysis <strong>Environmental</strong> Consequences<br />

Economic Efficiency<br />

Forest Service Handbooks 1909.17 and 2409.18 direct the evaluation of Economic Efficiency for<br />

proposed projects. To assess the economic efficiency of Alternative 2, the costs and anticipated timber<br />

volumes were entered into TEA.ECON<br />

http://www.fs.fed.us/rp/nr/fp/FPWebPage/ForestProducts/ForestProducts.htm). The timber harvest sale<br />

was evaluated for the sale as a whole with a 4 percent discount rate. TEA.ECON uses the Transaction<br />

Evidence Appraisal (TEA) system to generate basic gross timber values and estimated advertised rates.<br />

Values for timber are generated using advertised rates in the appropriate geographic area and appraisal<br />

zone. Rates were updated for the analysis and used the following cost file: version 04411, 12/31/2004.<br />

The analysis can be used to compare alternatives, not to give an absolute number for the outputs.<br />

Numbers useful for comparing alternatives include a benefit/cost ratio, discounted benefits, discounted<br />

costs and present net value. Effects on the local economy include estimated number of jobs created or<br />

maintained.<br />

Volume<br />

Estimating value and volume is dependent primarily on species and the diameter of trees. Timber volume<br />

estimates are:<br />

• Alternative 2 (Proposed action) - Total volume of 11,568 CCF (5.9 million board feet<br />

(MMBF); 5,639 CCF of ponderosa pine sawtimber; 1,880 CCF of lodgepole pine; and<br />

4,049 CCF of fiber.<br />

• Alternative 3 - Total volume of 11,001 CCF (5.65 MMBF): 5,363 of ponderosa pine<br />

sawtimber; 1,788 CCF of lodgepole pine; and 3,850 CCF of fiber.<br />

Costs<br />

The commercial harvest operation costs were developed for Alternative 2 and Alternative 3. The net sale<br />

value would depend on the market value of the timber when sold and the actual logging costs. These<br />

figures are based on the analysis discussed above. Logging costs (Table 3-33) include stump to truck<br />

(what it costs to get the trees from the harvest unit to the landing), haul (getting the trees from the landing<br />

to the mill), road maintenance, temporary road development and slash disposal. Cost assumptions are as<br />

follows:<br />

• 2/3 of the zone average was used for both stump to truck and log haul due to short skidding<br />

distances, high production mechanized systems and mill vicinity<br />

3-119

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!