23.06.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The second is used in aid of an execution at law, as to set aside an encumbrance<br />

or a transfer of property made to defraud creditors.<br />

There are three requirements for an equitable assets creditor's bill. First, the<br />

creditor must have a judgment against the debtor: second, the creditor must "`allege<br />

and show that he has exhausted his remedy at law,'" i.e., the creditor must show that<br />

execution has not satisfied the judgment: and finally, the debtor must have some<br />

interest in property that the creditor is unable to reach through execution.<br />

The dispositive issue here is whether [the NCP’s] beneficial interest in the<br />

discretionary support trusts is an "interest in property" which may be reached by an<br />

equitable assets creditor's bill to satisfy [the CP’s] judgment for child support<br />

arrearage.<br />

[W]e held that an equitable assets creditor's bill may reach a judgment debtor's<br />

beneficial interest in a resulting trust which came into being because of the debtor's<br />

failed attempt to dispose of real estate by inter vivos trust, reasoning that the debtor<br />

remained the equitable owner of property which could be used to satisfy the<br />

judgment. We have also held that a debtor's contingent interest as an heir in an<br />

estate under administration may be reached by an equitable assets creditor's bill,<br />

reasoning that while such interest was contingent, it was still an interest in property<br />

which was not exempt from being applied to the payment of the debt.<br />

Our jurisprudence is consistent with the following statement of the general rule for<br />

determining whether a beneficiary's interest in a trust created by a third party is a<br />

property interest which may be reached by an equitable assets creditor's bill:<br />

[I]n order for equity to subject to the claims of creditors the interest of the beneficiary, it<br />

is essential that it be such an interest as could be enforced by the beneficiary himself:<br />

creditors cannot reach the beneficiary's interest if the trustee has complete<br />

discretion not only as to the time and manner of conferring the intended benefit but<br />

also as to whether it shall be conferred at all, or if disbursements are restricted to such<br />

amounts as are necessary for the comfortable maintenance and support of the cestui que<br />

trust.<br />

21 Am. Jur. 2d Creditors' Bills § 35 at 30 (1998).<br />

Fox v. Whitbeck, 280 Neb. 75, 783 N.W.2d 774 (June 2010)<br />

Facts: Dad owed back child support to two mothers. Mom #1 had a lien on his real estate, but the lien<br />

had lapsed. Mom #2 initiated an execution and sheriff’s sale of the real estate, and purchased the<br />

property at a fire sale price. Mom #1 objected.<br />

Held: Even though Mom #1 no longer had a valid lien on the real estate, she had standing to object to<br />

the fire sale price of the dad’s property.<br />

The term “execution” is not specifically defined in § 42-371, but it is generally defined<br />

by Neb. Rev. Stat. § 25-1501(Reissue 2008) as a “process of the court.” This<br />

statutory definition is consistent with the commonly accepted understanding of the<br />

term as a “formal document issued by the court that authorizes a sheriff to levy upon<br />

the property of a judgment debtor” or a “court order directing a sheriff or other officer<br />

to enforce a judgment, usu[ally] by seizing and selling the judgment debtor’s<br />

property.”<br />

Garnishment is a legal remedy which involves issuance of a summons and a court<br />

order as a means of enforcing the authority of a court with respect to a judgment.<br />

The Legislature has stated that while income withholding under the IWCSA is the<br />

“preferred technique” for enforcement of such obligations, “other techniques such as<br />

liens on property and contempt proceedings should be used when appropriate.”<br />

- 119 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!