23.06.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

3. Finally, we conclude that for future cases, the standard of proof in civil contempt<br />

proceedings is clear and convincing evidence, unless the Legislature has mandated<br />

another standard.<br />

A jurisdictional issue that does not involve a factual dispute presents a question of<br />

law, which an appellate court independently decides.<br />

[B]oth an original marital dissolution pro eding and proceedings for modification of<br />

dissolution decrees are equitable in nature. Because of the court’s continuing equity<br />

jurisdiction over the decree, the power to provide equitable relief in a contempt<br />

proceeding is particularly appropriate. But there are limits to a court’s power to order<br />

equitable relief in a contempt proceeding. We have held that a court cannot modify<br />

a dissolution decree in a contempt proceeding absent an application for a<br />

modification and notice that a party seeks modification. … So, if a complainant<br />

seeks, or a court is considering, a modification of the underlying decree as an<br />

equitable sanction for contempt of the court’s decree, the alleged contemnor must<br />

first have notice that a modification and a finding of contempt will be at issue. But<br />

when the alleged contemnor has notice and an opportunity to be heard, a court can<br />

modify the underlying decree as a remedy for contempt if the violation cannot be<br />

adequately remedied otherwise.<br />

Civil contempt proceedings are remedial and coercive in their nature.<br />

only civil contempt orders issued before a final judgment in the main action are<br />

interlocutory (and unappealable).<br />

A court that has jurisdiction to issue an order also has the power to enforce it. A<br />

court can issue orders that are necessary to carry its judgment or decree into effect.<br />

<strong>Nebraska</strong> courts, through their inherent judicial power, have the authority to do all<br />

things reasonably necessary for the proper administration of justice. And this<br />

authority exists apart from any statutory grant of authority. The power to punish for<br />

contempt is incident to every judicial tribune. It is derived from a court’s constitutional<br />

power, without any expressed statutory aid, and is inherent in all courts of record.<br />

A court of equity has the power to interpret its own injunctive decree if a party later<br />

claims that a provision is unclear. The critical question for appeal purposes is<br />

whether a clarification order merely interprets an injunctive decree or whether it<br />

modifies the decree in a way that affects a party’s substantial right.<br />

An appellate court, reviewing a final judgment or order in a contempt proceeding,<br />

reviews for errors appearing on the record. When reviewing a judgment for errors<br />

appearing on the record, the inquiry is whether the decision conforms to the law, is<br />

supported by competent evidence, and is neither arbitrary, capricious, nor<br />

unreasonable.<br />

Under <strong>Nebraska</strong> law, an order of contempt in a postjudgment proceeding to enforce<br />

a previous final judgment is properly classified as a final order; the contempt order<br />

affects a substantial right, made upon a summary application in an action after<br />

judgment.<br />

For appeal purposes, the distinction between criminal and civil contempt sanctions<br />

has no relevance to whether a party may appeal from a final order in a supplemental<br />

postjudgment contempt proceeding.<br />

A trial court’s factual finding in a contempt pro eding will be upheld on appeal<br />

unless the finding is clearly erroneous.<br />

When a party to an action fails to comply with a court order made for the benefit of<br />

the opposing party, such act is ordinarily a civil contempt, which requires willful<br />

- 12 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!