23.06.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The habitation or residence of a minor child is, by operation of law, determined and<br />

fixed by that of the parent legally entitled to the custody and control of the child<br />

unless the parent has voluntarily surrendered such right.<br />

The only way Eva could acquire a Kansas domicile is by becoming emancipated.<br />

The emancipation of a child by a parent may be proved by circumstantial evidence<br />

or may be implied from the conduct of the parties<br />

Wills v. Wills, 16 Neb. App. 559, 745 N.W.2d 924 (2008)<br />

Facts: 1992 New Mexico divorce. Dad to pay child support until children emancipate under<br />

NM law (age 18). Later both parents and the children move to NE, and Mom has NE court<br />

modify, and resets emancipation age to 19. Held: No can do! The court takes an extensive<br />

look into the various UIFSA amendments, and the official commentary accompanying those<br />

amendments, in reaching its decision.<br />

Section 42-746 states, in pertinent part:<br />

I Except as otherwise provided in section 42-747.03, a tribunal of this state<br />

shall not modify any aspect of a child support order that cannot be modified<br />

under the law of the issuing state, including the duration of the obligation<br />

of support. . . .<br />

(d) In a proceeding to modify a child support order, the law of the state that is<br />

determined to have issued the initial controlling order governs the duration of<br />

the obligation of support. The obligor’s fulfillment of the duty of support<br />

established by that order precludes imposition of a further obligation of support<br />

by a tribunal of this state.<br />

Despite a basic difference in the nature of the case, we rely upon the decision in<br />

Groseth v. Groseth, 257 Neb. 525, 600 N .W.2d 159 (1999), for guiding principles.<br />

… First, we properly look to the official comments contained in a model act on which<br />

a <strong>Nebraska</strong> statute or series of statutes was patterned for some guidance in an effort<br />

to ascertain the intent of the legislation. … Second, dicta in Groseth supports our<br />

interpretation. Third, a court must look to a statute’s purpose and give to the statute<br />

a reasonable construction which best achieves that purpose, rather than a<br />

construction which would defeat it.<br />

A comment to the 2001 UIFSA amendments…(states): The fact that the State of the<br />

new controlling order has a different duration of for [sic] child support is specifically<br />

declared to be irrelevant by UIFSA. … This comment refers to the 2001 amendment<br />

to UIFSA § 611 adding a new section (d), which was, in turn, adopted essentially<br />

verbatim by the <strong>Nebraska</strong> Legislature as the current § 42-746(d). Section 42-476I<br />

was also amended to expressly refer to the duration of the obligation of support as<br />

an aspect that cannot be modified under the law of the issuing state.<br />

[T]he duration of the support obligation remains fixed despite the subsequent<br />

residence of all parties in a new state with a different duration of child support.<br />

Wulff v. Wulff, 243 Neb. 616, 500 N.W.2d 845 (1993)<br />

Whether there has been an emancipation is a question of fact, but what is emancipation<br />

is a question of law.<br />

Emancipation is not necessarily a continuing status; even if once established, it<br />

may be terminated at any time during the child’s minority.<br />

A minor child giving birth may be one factor to be considered in the determination<br />

of whether a minor has achieved a new status or position inconsistent with parental<br />

control, but should not alone be dispositive.<br />

- 66 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!