H e m a t o lo g y E d u c a t io n - European Hematology Association
H e m a t o lo g y E d u c a t io n - European Hematology Association
H e m a t o lo g y E d u c a t io n - European Hematology Association
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
TRM was higher for patients who received a transplant<br />
from a 1- or 2-antigen mismatched related donor compared<br />
to an HLA-identical sibling. 7<br />
Since donor-derived T-lymphocytes in the graft are the<br />
major cause of GVHD in al<strong>lo</strong>geneic SCT, var<strong>io</strong>us attempts<br />
were made to deplete T-cells from BM pr<strong>io</strong>r to infus<strong>io</strong>n.<br />
The first ex vivo T-cell depleted bone marrow transplants<br />
(BMT) using soybean agglutinin and rosette format<strong>io</strong>n<br />
with sheep red b<strong>lo</strong>od cells were performed in children<br />
with immunodeficiency syndromes. 8 Subsequently,<br />
Henslee–Downey and colleagues used intensive total<br />
body irradiat<strong>io</strong>n (TBI) based mye<strong>lo</strong>ablative preparative<br />
regimens with partial in vitro T-cell deplet<strong>io</strong>n of hap<strong>lo</strong>identical<br />
BM using anti-CD3 antibodies (T10B9 or<br />
OKT-3) with a 1–1.5 <strong>lo</strong>g reduct<strong>io</strong>n of T-cells and posttransplant<br />
pharmaco<strong>lo</strong>gical GVHD prophylaxis. 9 In this<br />
large series of 201 patients, 98% engrafted with 5-year<br />
cumulative incidences of relapse and TRM of 31% and<br />
51%, respectively. The cumulative incidences of grade<br />
II-IV acute GVHD and chronic GVHD were 13% and<br />
15%, respectively. An encouraging survival probability<br />
of 20% was seen in patients with advanced hemato<strong>lo</strong>gical<br />
malignancies.<br />
Challenges of hap<strong>lo</strong>identical transplantat<strong>io</strong>n<br />
Based on the initial experience using unmanipulated<br />
or partially T-cell depleted bone marrow and fully ablative<br />
condit<strong>io</strong>ning regimens, the major challenges in hap<strong>lo</strong>identical<br />
stem cell transplantat<strong>io</strong>n turned out to be<br />
and still are: (i) the prevent<strong>io</strong>n of severe acute and<br />
chronic GVHD; (ii) the reduct<strong>io</strong>n of the risk of graft<br />
reject<strong>io</strong>n; (iii) the accelerat<strong>io</strong>n of the delayed<br />
immunoreconstitut<strong>io</strong>n associated with a high incidence<br />
of severe and often lethal infect<strong>io</strong>us complicat<strong>io</strong>ns; and<br />
(iv) the implementat<strong>io</strong>n of strategies for the select<strong>io</strong>n of<br />
the best mismatched donor in terms of natural killer<br />
(NK) cell al<strong>lo</strong>reactivity and post-transplant cellular therapeutic<br />
strategies to prevent the risk of relapse.<br />
Approaches to overcoming these challenges<br />
Megadose transplantat<strong>io</strong>n of positively selected<br />
CD34+ stem cells<br />
The ‘megadose’ concept was first described by<br />
Reisner et al. in animal models of hap<strong>lo</strong>identical transplantat<strong>io</strong>n.<br />
10 It is based on the observat<strong>io</strong>n that the<br />
transplantat<strong>io</strong>n of large numbers of purified hematopoietic<br />
stem cells can overcome the HLA barrier of hap<strong>lo</strong>identical<br />
transplantat<strong>io</strong>n due to the presence of ‘veto’<br />
cells within the CD34+ selected populat<strong>io</strong>n. 11,12<br />
To translate this concept into a clinical setting, Aversa<br />
et al. devised a strategy for the combinat<strong>io</strong>n of BMderived<br />
CD34+ stem cells and CD34+ stem cells purified<br />
from granu<strong>lo</strong>cyte co<strong>lo</strong>ny-stimulating factor (G-<br />
CSF)-mobilized peripheral b<strong>lo</strong>od stem cells (PBSC) from<br />
hap<strong>lo</strong>identical donors using soybean agglutinin and Erosetting.<br />
13 With this graft-engineering strategy, a 3 <strong>lo</strong>g<br />
reduct<strong>io</strong>n in T-cells was achieved and large numbers of<br />
CD34+ stem cells with a <strong>lo</strong>w number of graft-contaminating<br />
T-cells were transplanted. Primary engraftment<br />
was achieved in 16/17 patients with end-stage<br />
London, United Kingdom, June 9-12, 2011<br />
leukemia. In the absence of any pharmaco<strong>lo</strong>gical GVHD<br />
prophylaxis, severe acute GVHD occurred in only one<br />
patient and no cases of chronic GVHD were observed.<br />
In a subsequent study, the same group then used positively<br />
selected CD34+ stem cells from leukapheresis as<br />
the sole source of stem cells with a higher degree of Tcell<br />
deplet<strong>io</strong>n (4 <strong>lo</strong>gs) fol<strong>lo</strong>wing a preparative regimen<br />
composed of TBI, th<strong>io</strong>tepa, fludarabine, and anti-thymocyte<br />
g<strong>lo</strong>bulin (ATG). The median number of transplanted<br />
CD34+ stem cells was 10x10 6 /kg recipient body<br />
weight, and the number of co-transplanted CD3+ Tcells<br />
was only 2 x 10 4 /kg. The engraftment rate was<br />
95%, and severe GVHD was not seen even in the<br />
absence of any pharmaco<strong>lo</strong>gical GVHD prophylaxis. 14<br />
However, due to the delayed immune reconstitut<strong>io</strong>n<br />
associated with this approach, there was a high rate of<br />
infect<strong>io</strong>us complicat<strong>io</strong>ns, and infect<strong>io</strong>ns were the leading<br />
cause of death and the main contributors to a TRM<br />
rate of 40%.<br />
The clinical introduct<strong>io</strong>n of a semi-automated device<br />
for the positive select<strong>io</strong>n of highly purified CD34+ stem<br />
cells and the high degree of indirect deplet<strong>io</strong>n of T-cells<br />
and B-cells to 4.5–5 <strong>lo</strong>g and more than 3 <strong>lo</strong>g, respectively,<br />
15 led investigators to evaluate hap<strong>lo</strong>identical transplantat<strong>io</strong>n<br />
using ‘megadoses’ of highly purified CD34+<br />
stem cells in patients with a variety of diseases. With<br />
this extensive T-cell deplet<strong>io</strong>n, almost no GVHD was<br />
seen even in the absence of any pharmaco<strong>lo</strong>gical GVHD<br />
prophylaxis and due to the indirect B-cell deplet<strong>io</strong>n<br />
associated with CD34+ select<strong>io</strong>n, post-transplant EBVrelated<br />
lymphoproliferative disorders were also absent<br />
in both pediatric 16 and adult patients. 17 Similar results<br />
were reported from other investigators using mostly<br />
TBI-based mye<strong>lo</strong>ablative preparative regimens fol<strong>lo</strong>wed<br />
by the transplantat<strong>io</strong>n of large numbers of highly purified<br />
CD34+ peripheral stem cells without any addit<strong>io</strong>nal<br />
GVHD prophylaxis. 18–22 All these studies in both pediatric<br />
and adult patients have in common delayed<br />
immune reconstitut<strong>io</strong>n, which was associated with a<br />
high incidence of severe and lethal infect<strong>io</strong>ns. In an<br />
analysis on behalf of the Acute Leukemia and Pediatric<br />
Disease Working Parties of the <strong>European</strong> Group for<br />
B<strong>lo</strong>od and Marrow Transplant (EBMT), of the outcome<br />
of 102 children with ALL in remiss<strong>io</strong>n receiving hap<strong>lo</strong>identical<br />
transplants with CD34+ positively selected<br />
stem cells, the impacts of the number of transplanted<br />
CD34+ stem cells and the transplant center size (in<br />
terms of number of hap<strong>lo</strong>identical transplants performed<br />
per year) were demonstrated. 23 Patients who<br />
received more than 12.4 x 10 6 /kg CD34+ positively<br />
selected stem cells had a leukemia-free survival (LFS) of<br />
35±7% compared with 17±6% in patients who received<br />
less than 12.4 x 10 6 /kg. Patients who received their<br />
transplant at a larger transplant center had a LFS of<br />
39±7% compared with the LFS of 15±6% in patients<br />
transplanted in smaller centers.<br />
In a survey of adult patients with high risk acute<br />
leukemia in remiss<strong>io</strong>n at transplantat<strong>io</strong>n who received<br />
positively selected CD34+ stem cells, the LFS for<br />
patients with AML in CR1, more than or equal to CR2<br />
or advanced disease were 48±10 %, 21±%, and 1±1%,<br />
respectively. The LFS for patients with ALL in CR1,<br />
more than or equal to CR2 and advanced disease were<br />
13±%, 30±8%, and 7±5%, respectively. 24 A reduced<br />
Hemato<strong>lo</strong>gy Educat<strong>io</strong>n: the educat<strong>io</strong>n programme for the annual congress of the <strong>European</strong> Hemato<strong>lo</strong>gy Associat<strong>io</strong>n | 2011; 5(1) | 65 |