ENFORCEMENT
eop_ipec_jointstrategicplan_hi-res
eop_ipec_jointstrategicplan_hi-res
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Joint Strategic Plan on Intellectual Property Enforcement<br />
SECTION 4<br />
posts and ads; or rely on pseudonymous product<br />
reviews, blog entries or fabricated social media<br />
profiles to provide an aura of legitimacy?<br />
Research on Patents is Needed…<br />
• To assess the effects of recent amendments to the<br />
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Research into the<br />
effects on pleadings of the December 2015 reforms<br />
to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure is needed<br />
to assess the impact of those changes and whether<br />
further changes are necessary or advisable.<br />
• To assess the effects of recent judicial decisions on the<br />
patent landscape. Researchers are urged to evaluate<br />
the effects of recent Supreme Court decisions on<br />
the patent landscape, including: pleading standards<br />
as set forth in Bell Atlantic Corp v. Twombly and<br />
Aschcroft v. Iqbal; effects of litigation resulting from<br />
awarding of attorney’s fees as set forth in Highmark<br />
and Octane Fitness; and whether post-grant review of<br />
patent eligibility have improved patent quality and/or<br />
impacted the frequency of frivolous litigation.<br />
• To analyze litigation patterns. Policymakers would<br />
benefit from a greater understanding of patent<br />
litigation trends and patterns. For example, research<br />
focused on the causes of any increases in patent<br />
litigation both prior to and immediately after passage<br />
of the American Invents Act in 2011 would assist<br />
policymakers in understanding whether any increases<br />
were related to upticks in false marking cases or<br />
incentives resulting from the AIA’s change to the<br />
joinder rule.<br />
• To analyze litigation’s effects on the innovation<br />
economy. Research is needed to evaluate whether<br />
there is any relationship between patent litigation<br />
and various measures of innovation in the economy,<br />
including whether the patent litigation climate<br />
impacts the value of a patent.<br />
• To consider factors affecting awarding of damages.<br />
There is some indication that non-practicing entities<br />
(NPEs) may receive higher total damages than<br />
practicing entities (PEs). Research is needed into this<br />
possible difference, including root causes, and the<br />
effects of any settlement calculus employed by NPEs.<br />
Research into Commercial-Scale Piracy is<br />
Needed…<br />
• To assess the economic scope and magnitude of<br />
digital piracy. Beyond any top-line numbers, what is<br />
the magnitude of the harm suffered by the copyright<br />
owner? What is the impact on employment in the<br />
creative sectors? Who are the entities that profit from,<br />
or may be unjustly enriched by, the unauthorized<br />
exploitation of copyrighted materials?<br />
• To develop a clearer picture of rogue online actors.<br />
Topics that research might tackle include: (1) the<br />
structure and composition of entities deliberately<br />
facilitating the dissemination (downloading or<br />
streaming) of copyrighted content; (2) the business<br />
models employed by illicit actors to derive revenue<br />
from acts of commercial piracy; and (3) the evasive<br />
tactics employed to enhance resiliency from court<br />
orders and injunctive remedies.<br />
• To assess the nature of intermediary exploitation by<br />
criminal actors. Further research is needed on the<br />
extent to which intermediaries—including website<br />
hosting platforms, online marketplaces, banks,<br />
payment processors, social networks, and others—are<br />
exploited by criminal actors, and the size of revenue<br />
that may be generated by intermediaries as a result of<br />
third-party illicit activity.<br />
• To examine the range of attendant harms and risks to<br />
the public. What is the relationship between pirated<br />
content and incidents of malware, phishing, or other<br />
threats to the public?<br />
• To collect and compile data on the effectiveness of<br />
existing remedies, including the state of domestic<br />
and foreign injunctive relief and damages. What is the<br />
state of injunctive relief and damages for commercialscale<br />
piracy operations, domestically and abroad, and<br />
how have illicit actors responded or evolved to these<br />
legal actions? What trends exist?<br />
• To assess effectiveness of voluntary initiatives. What<br />
framework should be used to assess the effectiveness<br />
of voluntary initiatives and industry best practices in<br />
light of rapidly changing virtual and technological<br />
environment?<br />
146