Ali Ibn Abi Talib - Volume 2 of 2

712 Weak andfabricated hadiths about 'Ali ibn Abi Trilib
Tirmidhi's words: This is a svange munkar ha dith... we do not
know this hadith from any wstworthy narrator fiom Shurayk.
No. 3723. Ibn al-Jawzi said: This is a fabricated hadith. Mishkrit
al-Ma~iibeeh, 311777. Ibn d-Jawzi deemed it to be a lie - Al-
Mawdoo 'iit, 11349.
30. "You, 0 'Ali, and your party, &hey are the best of creatures)
(Qur'an 98: 7)." Its chain of narration includes Ahu alJarood,
Ziy2d ibn al-Mundhir d-Kufi, whom al-Hz& - ibn E]lajar called:
a Rsidi whom Yabya ihn Ma'een deemed to he a liar. At-
Taqreeb, no. 2101.
31. "Allah revealed to me three things concerning 'Ali: he is the
leader of the believers, the leader of the pious and the leader of
those with bright faces and limbs." Al-Hh said in al-
Manciqib: Its chain of narration is sound. I say: Rather it is very
weak and also intetnpted. Ithcif al-Maharah, 11344. He said that
'Umar ibn d-Husayn d-'Aqeeli and his shaykh Yahya ibn al-
'Ala' ar-Rki are both rejected. In fact, he stated clearly that this
hadith is fabricated.
32. "What great news, 0 'Ali. You have become our mawla and the
mawla of every believing man and woman." Its chain of
narration includes 'Ali ibn Zayd ibn Jad'an, of whom al-
Jawzjini said: His hadith is weak. Ash-Shajarah fi Abcil ar-
Rijcil, p. 194. Ibn dJawzi said in al-'Ilal al-Mutaniihiyah fil-
Ahcideeth al-Wiihiyah (11226): It is not permissible to quote this
hadith as evidence. From that man hack to Abu Hurayrah, all its
narrators are weak. AI-Bazzir said: A number of scholars spoke
about it. Kashf al-Astiir, 490. Ad-Diraqu@i said: It is not strong.
Sunan ad-Diiraqupi, 11103.
33. "May Allah have mercy on 'Ali. 0 Allah, cause truth to be with
him wherever he goes." Narrated by d-Hgkim, who said: It is