Historical Painting Techniques, Materials, and Studio Practice
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
palettes as described above, it is clear that the level of accomplishment required<br />
was of a quite different nature to the methods of painters from the<br />
later nineteenth <strong>and</strong> twentieth centuries, who, thanks to the full palette, could<br />
now work on the whole painting at once. This fact clearly explains the somewhat<br />
"muddy" effect, compared to earlier paintings, characteristic of Jozef<br />
Israels <strong>and</strong> many of his contemporaries <strong>and</strong> successors.<br />
Research into the borderline region between style <strong>and</strong> technique throws light<br />
on unexpected aspects of seventeenth-century studio practice. It is clear, for<br />
instance, that the view on the genesis of paintings presented here must have<br />
implications for scientific research into Baroque paintings. Analytical studies<br />
of the binding media used in the seventeenth century (e.g., by Rembr<strong>and</strong>t)<br />
suggest that a different blend of media is likely to be found in every giornate<br />
of the painting (25).<br />
This study has produced a picture that may be relevant to the discussion of<br />
the interrelation of style <strong>and</strong> technique, namely that of a development of<br />
Baroque painting in which artists strove for a unified tonal image that did<br />
not appear to be composed by additive methods. The fact that these additive<br />
techniques were used gives a different picture of the artist at work, one in<br />
which technical limitations actually constituted the "coefficient of friction"<br />
(to use Riegl's term) that thwarted the artists in their pursuit of a new style.<br />
It was even necessary for the seventeenth-century painters to introduce a new<br />
art-theoretical concept, namely houding, to bring the discussion of these efforts<br />
to a new level of abstraction. Only in the nineteenth century did the<br />
technical materials <strong>and</strong> means arise-namely, the full color palette, paint in<br />
tubes, <strong>and</strong> the associated large palette sizes-that made it possible to apply a<br />
technique appropriate to the painter's stylistic aspirations (as exemplified by<br />
Cezanne's remark, "You must underst<strong>and</strong> that I h<strong>and</strong>le the whole painting at<br />
once, in its totality") (26). Semper appears to be borne out, on the other<br />
h<strong>and</strong>, if one observes that a late Rembr<strong>and</strong>t, placed between a Raphael <strong>and</strong><br />
a nineteenth-century piece of "Rembr<strong>and</strong>tism" such as a late work by Jozef<br />
Israels, shows closer kinship to the Raphael than to the Israels. Indeed, the<br />
technique of additive painting has an unmistakable determinative effect on<br />
the style of a painting.<br />
Aclrnowledgll1ents<br />
Thanks are hereby expressed to Jos Koldeweij , Hayo Menso de Boer, Paul Broeckhof,<br />
Dieuwertje Dekkers, Karin Groen, <strong>and</strong> Charlie Srnid. Much of the research underlying<br />
this study was carried out within the framework of the Rembr<strong>and</strong>t Research<br />
Project, financed by the Netherl<strong>and</strong>s Organization fo r Scientific Research, <strong>and</strong> also<br />
received valuable support from the Director <strong>and</strong> the Head of the Art History Department<br />
of the Central Laboratory for Research on Objects of Art <strong>and</strong> Science,<br />
Amsterdam.<br />
Notes<br />
1. Vasari on technique. 1960. Ed. B. Brown. New York, 230.<br />
2. van M<strong>and</strong>er, K. 1604. Den grondt der ede! vry Schilderconst. Haarlem, fol. 64r. P<br />
Taylor of the Warburg Institute, London, is carrying out research on the concept<br />
"glowing" in connection with the painting of flesh in the early seventeenth<br />
century.<br />
3. Semper, G. 1860-1863. Der Stil in den technischen und tektonischen KiJnsten. Frankfurt<br />
am Main. See also Viollet-Ie-Duc, E. E. 1863-1872. L'entretien sur I'architecture.<br />
Paris.<br />
4. Riegl, A. 1893. Stilfragen. Berlin, v-xix, 20, 24. See also Kultermann, U. 1966.<br />
Geschichte der Kunstgeschichte. Vienna, 288.<br />
5. Giovanni Battista Volpato: Modo da tener nel dipingere. 1967. In Original Treatises<br />
on the Arts oj <strong>Painting</strong>. Ed. M. P Merrifield. New York, 726-55, especially<br />
746-48.<br />
6. Mora, P, L. Mora, <strong>and</strong> P Philippot. 1984. Conservation oj Wall <strong>Painting</strong>s. London,<br />
138-64.<br />
7. van de Wetering, E. 1977. De jonge Rembr<strong>and</strong>t aan het werk. In Qud Holl<strong>and</strong><br />
(91):7-65, especially 20-24.<br />
202<br />
<strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Painting</strong> <strong>Techniques</strong>, Maten:als, <strong>and</strong> <strong>Studio</strong> <strong>Practice</strong>