31.07.2014 Views

Numéro 60--- ÉTÉ 2007 - Vho

Numéro 60--- ÉTÉ 2007 - Vho

Numéro 60--- ÉTÉ 2007 - Vho

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

GAZETTE DU GOLFE ET DES BANLIEUES / <strong>60</strong> / ÉTÉ <strong>2007</strong><br />

the landscape were shaped and plowed by farmers through generations. This is especially<br />

apparent in the Jerusalem hills, the shfela (Judean lowlands) and the Galilee.<br />

Hundreds of agricultural structures that once served a magnificent and successful<br />

network of irrigation in the Palestinian village of Ein Kerem can still be found around Ein<br />

Kerem, now a Jerusalem neighborhood. On the hills of Beit Nataf adjacent to Beit Shemesh,<br />

an area which the Israel Nature and National Parks Protection Authority (INNPA) wants to<br />

turn into a national park, the orchards of the Palestinian village that once stood there<br />

continue to shape the landscape. Historians who are very critical of the Zionist movement,<br />

such as Dr. Ilan Pappe, claim that disregarding the existence of Palestinian villages is part of<br />

a deliberate effort to erase their history in favor of creating a new one that suits the Zionist<br />

narrative of a country that was barren, and only flourished thanks to groups like the JNF. In<br />

a study he published, Pappe analyzes the information that JNF provides on several sites,<br />

including the Biria Forest, the Jerusalem Forest, the area of Ramat Menashe and the Sataf<br />

site near Jerusalem. "The Palestinian orchards are presented as a product of nature, and<br />

the history of Palestine is relocated to the period of the Bible and the Talmud," he writes in<br />

his discussion of the site of the village of Ein Zeitun in the Biria Forest.<br />

Pappe also points out that the JNF publishes information about unique sites in the<br />

Jerusalem Forest and Sataf that testify to the extensive agricultural activity in the region. The<br />

information emphasizes the presence of terraces, describing them as ancient, even if they<br />

were built and maintained by Palestinian villages. A recent study conducted by Noga<br />

Kadman (as part of her studies in the Department of Peace and Development Research at<br />

Goteborg University in Sweden, under the tutelage of Prof. Oren Yiftachel of Ben-Gurion<br />

University of the Negev), found about 86 Palestinian villages inside the JNF forests -<br />

sites she describes as "emptied." Most of the sites have directional signs, but only 15<br />

percent of them mention the villages by their Arab name. Most of the pamphlets and<br />

brochures do not even mention the villages. And in half of the literature where the villages<br />

are mentioned, the fact that their inhabitants were Arabs is elided. Only in one case did it<br />

say how many people lived in the village, and only in isolated instances is there any<br />

discussion of the lives of the inhabitants. "In most cases, the fact that the villages ceased<br />

to exist is not specifically mentioned," writes Kadman. "This can be concluded from the text<br />

regarding most of the villages, which are called 'abandoned,' and are described as ruins or<br />

remains, or mentioned in the past tense." Bronstein has already submitted Kadman's list of<br />

villages to the JNF. He also intends to approach INNPA and ask that it, too, mention the<br />

location of abandoned villages in nature reserves and national parks. The INNPA said in<br />

response that no site is given preference or ignored because of national or religious<br />

affiliation, and that there are several Palestinian villages that are mentioned in signs and in<br />

the informational material prepared by the authority.<br />

Yehuda Ziv, who heads the Government Names Committee's subcommittee for<br />

community names, and is considered one of the leading experts in Israel in the field,<br />

supports the idea of marking the location of abandoned Arab villages. "I support the<br />

mention of the Arab names of various sites, including villages, streams and other places,<br />

and I think that they should not have been erased from the map," says Ziv. "One reason is<br />

that these names often teach us about the country's Jewish past. There is an additional<br />

reason, and that is the fact that these names teach us the history of the country and its<br />

landscape. I claimed that original Arab names of existing communities should be added as<br />

part of a first map of Israel in Arabic being prepared by the Israel Mapping Center, but I was<br />

told that there is no room for that. However, regarding destroyed villages, I think that we<br />

should make do simply with a mention of the name of the village."<br />

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/870315.html<br />

— 45 —

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!