20.03.2013 Views

Principios de Taxonomia

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Races are not populations of individuals who are different in a majority of their<br />

traits, but rather, they are populations of individuals who possess a few characteristic<br />

traits that are the diagnostic traits of their race (Chapter 5). It is easy to find differences<br />

in outward appearance (e.g., skin and hair color, morphology of the body and the face)<br />

between humans from different parts of the Earth.<br />

However, the necessity of adaptation to particular environmental conditions in<br />

different geographical areas has only led to changes in a small number of genes in<br />

the genome, specifically those that have been subjected to the adaptive pressure of<br />

adjusting to local environmental conditions. In humans, the diagnostic traits<br />

between races are mainly related to skin and hair color as adaptations to the<br />

varying intensity of solar radiation and allelic differences in specific metabolic<br />

enzymes as adaptations to varying diets (Kingsley, 2009). The majority of genes in<br />

the genome are not affected by these adaptations, and accordingly, the numbers of<br />

these changes vary among single organisms within a race to the same magnitu<strong>de</strong><br />

as between members of different races. Hence, a native Central European can<br />

differ from his equally Central European neighbor in more genetic traits than<br />

from a sub-Saharan African. Races are not generally different from each other,<br />

but they carry specific license plates, by means of which they can be i<strong>de</strong>ntified.<br />

This realization disproves a common prejudice about the nature of racial<br />

difference.<br />

The problem is that the differences between races concern very distinct adaptations<br />

to local environments, and these traits are altogether low in number. Who<br />

<strong>de</strong>ci<strong>de</strong>s which traits are awar<strong>de</strong>d the rank of being a distinguishing property of a race?<br />

What makes skin and hair color so special? There are hundreds of other traits that<br />

could in principle be used to divi<strong>de</strong> a species into diagnosable groups. Why do we<br />

consi<strong>de</strong>r native Africans to be a separate race, but not the Bavarians in contrast to<br />

the Westphalians in Germany? Both of these populations are diagnosable groups that<br />

are distinguished by certain specific traits.<br />

These consi<strong>de</strong>rations make it clear that races are typologically <strong>de</strong>fined, and the<br />

traits chosen in consi<strong>de</strong>ring a population as a race are a matter of highly subjective<br />

human <strong>de</strong>cision-making processes. Though races are useful tools for pragmatic<br />

classifications, they are nevertheless artificial classes formed into groups by the<br />

human mind. Races are preten<strong>de</strong>d to be biological units, but in fact they are only<br />

scientific or social or political constructs. No natural law <strong>de</strong>fines races as cohesive<br />

natural groups.<br />

The example of racial discrimination shows most clearly the fatal consequences<br />

human intuitions can face if they are not verified by scientific and logical foundations.<br />

2.12<br />

Species Pluralism: How Many Species Concepts Exist?<br />

2.12 Species Pluralism: How Many Species Concepts Exist?j33<br />

A remarkable number of species concepts are currently in use (May<strong>de</strong>n, 1997). This<br />

multiplicity <strong>de</strong>monstrates, above any other point, that all of these concepts must be<br />

fictitious. These concepts must be human constructs and cannot represent entities

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!