here - United Kingdom Parliament
here - United Kingdom Parliament
here - United Kingdom Parliament
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
819 Oral Answers<br />
1 DECEMBER 2010<br />
Oral Answers<br />
820<br />
Q14. [27571] Grahame M. Morris (Easington) (Lab): I<br />
have just got back from a visit to Israel and the west<br />
bank, and I was shocked to witness with my own eyes<br />
13-year-old Palestinian children in leg irons and<br />
manacles in Israeli military prisons. That is one of<br />
numerous breaches of the UN charter and of article 49<br />
of the fourth Geneva convention. Whether or not the<br />
Prime Minister is the legitimate son of Thatcher, I am<br />
sure that as a father he would join me in condemning<br />
that appalling practice, but what will the British<br />
Government do to put pressure on the Israeli<br />
Government to comply with their obligations under<br />
international law and to relieve the suffering of the<br />
Palestinian people in both the west bank and Gaza?<br />
The Prime Minister: The hon. Gentleman raises an<br />
extremely important point. Every country should obey<br />
the Geneva convention and the other conventions that<br />
it has signed, and Israel should be no exception to that.<br />
Ministers in the Government I lead raise those issues<br />
with Israeli Ministers, as we should, and that is extremely<br />
important. The fact is, what we really need is a long-term<br />
settlement of the Palestinian issue, and we want a<br />
two-state solution. It is very important that we put<br />
pressure on both sides at all times to ensure that we<br />
make progress. The lack of progress only plays into the<br />
hands of the extremists, and we can see that all the<br />
moderates in the middle east who are trying to make<br />
progress are being undermined by our failure to do<br />
better.<br />
Q15. [27572] Priti Patel (Witham) (Con): If the Human<br />
Rights Act is<br />
“a glaring example of what is going wrong in our country”,<br />
when will the Government put the human rights of the<br />
law-abiding majority above those of dangerous convicted<br />
criminals?<br />
The Prime Minister: It is right that we should be<br />
replacing the Human Rights Act with a British Bill of<br />
Rights. I have personally looked at the matter long and<br />
hard and believe that t<strong>here</strong> is no better solution than<br />
that. We are committed to starting a process of looking<br />
at that to see whether we can remove some of the<br />
nonsenses that have grown up over recent years and<br />
show that we can have a commitment to proper rights,<br />
but they should be written down <strong>here</strong> in this country.<br />
Eric Joyce (Falkirk) (Lab): The Government have<br />
announced an injection of £50 million of new money<br />
into the interim cancer drugs fund. Can the Prime<br />
Minister say whether t<strong>here</strong> will be Barnett consequentials<br />
for Scotland, because that is new money?<br />
The Prime Minister: We have not made any changes<br />
to the Barnett formula, so if that is Barnett-able, as it<br />
were, t<strong>here</strong> will be consequentials, and if it is not, t<strong>here</strong><br />
will not be.<br />
Bob Russell (Colchester) (LD): Does the Prime Minister<br />
think it fair that a war widow has to pay income tax on<br />
her war widow’s pension?<br />
The Prime Minister: My hon. Friend raises a very<br />
good point. We need to look at all those sorts of issues<br />
under the work that we are doing on the military<br />
covenant—t<strong>here</strong> are very complicated issues of pensions<br />
and interaction with taxes. I do not want to give a flip<br />
answer from the Dispatch Box; we have a proper process<br />
of looking at the military covenant, which is the right<br />
way to do things.<br />
Caroline Lucas (Brighton, Pavilion) (Green): Climate<br />
finance will be critical at the ongoing climate summit at<br />
Cancun. Although I welcome the fact that the Government<br />
have pledged £2.9 billion to the global climate fund, will<br />
the Prime Minister confirm that any future money<br />
pledge will be additional to existing aid budgets, and<br />
can he say what further innovative funding mechanisms<br />
he plans to employ to deliver the UK’s share of the<br />
annual $100 billion pledged at Copenhagen?<br />
The Prime Minister: The hon. Lady is absolutely<br />
right to raise that. Although Cancun will not achieve<br />
the binding global agreement that we want, it can make<br />
important steps towards that, so we can stay on track.<br />
On climate finance, first, we will stick to what was set<br />
out previously on the limit in the aid budget for money<br />
used for climate change purposes, although t<strong>here</strong> are<br />
very real connections between climate change and poverty;<br />
and secondly, t<strong>here</strong> is a commitment, which we will<br />
keep to, of £2.9 billion for climate change finance.<br />
Britain is a leader on that, but as she said, we must look<br />
at innovative ways of levering in more money from<br />
other parts of the world, including—frankly—from<br />
some fast-growing areas which, when Kyoto was first<br />
thought of, were very underdeveloped and are now<br />
fast-developing countries. We need to help them, but<br />
the finance should not flow only from us.<br />
Daniel Kawczynski (Shrewsbury and Atcham) (Con):<br />
Will the Prime Minister have urgent talks with the<br />
Leader of the House and the Business Secretary on<br />
introducing legislation for a national regulator or<br />
ombudsman for supermarkets before more suppliers<br />
are decimated by their conduct?<br />
The Prime Minister: We have new arrangements in<br />
terms of ensuring that supermarkets treat farmers fairly.<br />
All of us as constituency MPs have heard stories about<br />
supermarkets behaving very aggressively towards farmers,<br />
and it is right that t<strong>here</strong> is a proper way of trying to<br />
police that independently, so that our farmers get a fair<br />
deal for the food that they produce.