You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Ties <strong>that</strong> Bind<br />
419 http://www.muslimnews.co.<br />
uk/paper/index.php?article=4360<br />
420 Ibid.<br />
421 Ibid.<br />
422 http://www.pickledpolitics.<br />
com/archives/5178<br />
88 | policyexchange.org.uk<br />
Portraying itself as a representative body of British Muslims, surely the MCB should<br />
be best placed to learn the historical lessons of the British Muslim experience and<br />
chart a way through the current challenges they face.<br />
In an interview with Muslim News, then Chief of the General Staff, General Sir<br />
David Richards, expressed his frustration at the lack of an ‘alternative view’ being<br />
given to young Muslims:<br />
This is a war <strong>that</strong> needs to be fought and can be won. We haven’t sold this very well and we’ve debated<br />
it before and we need to do better. It is very important for the Muslim community to be exposed to an<br />
alternative view as it is for the rest of the nation. The Taliban kill many more Muslims than we do. 419<br />
That they do – but there are few who are prepared to make <strong>that</strong> case to young<br />
Muslims in the way Indian leaders did during the last century. General Richards<br />
went on to explain <strong>that</strong> he does not want Britain to be ‘perceived as the enemy<br />
force’ and outlined the necessity of his mission in Afghanistan: 420<br />
If we gave up Afghanistan tomorrow, I absolutely guarantee <strong>that</strong> if you are an AQ [al-Qa’ida]<br />
member or Taliban they will pour back into southern Afghanistan and they will have the<br />
freedom to then plan and train and conduct operations which now they don’t have.<br />
[...]<br />
We have promised the people of Afghanistan we would help them and bring them out of the<br />
impasse and horrors of the two generations worth of war. So if we are going to renege on our<br />
promises and let the Taliban and AQ back [ordinary Afghans] are going to be extremely anti<br />
west at <strong>that</strong> point and will probably have no option but to welcome AQ back into their midst. 421<br />
There is a case, of course, for saying the MoD should resist engaging with<br />
Muslims through communal and religious groups, appealing to them directly as<br />
they would any other citizen. Yet, if it does wish to continue partnering with<br />
Muslim organisations, then there are alternatives to the MCB, such as Shaaz<br />
Mahboob from British Muslims for Secular Democracy (BMSD). He has been<br />
much more forthright than any other Muslim leader in expressing his thoughts<br />
about the dangers and challenges currently facing British soldiers. Like Indian<br />
Muslim leaders who rationalised the situation in which they found themselves<br />
after Turkey entered the Great War in 1914, Mahboob points out:<br />
British Muslims did not object to the military campaign against former Yugoslavia, in fact<br />
hailed it, when fellow Muslim Kosovars benefited from the war on foreign soil, deemed by<br />
the Serbs as foreign invasion and interference. Yet when it comes to brutal regimes and their<br />
atroci<strong>ties</strong> such as the ones in Darfur or Afghanistan, the Muslim silence is deafening.<br />
It is high time British Muslims recognise and acknowledge <strong>that</strong> in order to exert their rights<br />
as British people, they must also fulfil their civic and moral responsibili<strong>ties</strong> by beginning to<br />
show solidarity with the rest of the society, especially where it matters the most. 422<br />
Yet, because groups such as BMSD do not market themselves as gatekeeper<br />
‘umbrella’ organisation with scores of affiliates, their views too often go unheard<br />
by officialdom. Similarly, Khurshid Ahmed, speaking whilst Chairman of the<br />
British Muslim Forum, issued a statement in 2006 telling British Muslims <strong>that</strong> if<br />
they joined the armed forces and were killed, they would be considered