1968_4_arabisraelwar
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
178 / AMERICAN JEWISH YEAR BOOK, <strong>1968</strong><br />
Premier Kosygin then introduced the Soviet resolution which charged<br />
Israel with "premeditated and previously prepared aggression against the<br />
United Arab Republic, Syria and Jordan." It asked the Security Council<br />
resolutely to condemn Israel's acts of aggression; demand that Israel "immediately<br />
and without any condition withdraw all its forces" to the pre-June 5<br />
armistice lines; demand that Israel pay in full and within the shortest possible<br />
time for "all the damage inflicted" on the neighboring Arab states and their<br />
nationals, and to return all seized property; in short, to undertake "immediate<br />
effective measures in order to eliminate all consequences" of the Israeli<br />
aggression.<br />
In the following weeks these themes were to be repeated countless times<br />
in the Assembly debates by Soviet bloc and Arab representatives. Almost<br />
buried under the avalanche of anti-Israel invective in Premier Kosygin's<br />
lengthy speech was one potentially significant point that set apart the Soviet<br />
position from that of the Arabs. In the midst of his tirade the Soviet Premier<br />
paused to note that "the Soviet Union is not against Israel—it is against the<br />
aggressive policy pursued by the ruling circles of that state." He then cited<br />
as one of the fundamental principles of Soviet policy the right of "every people<br />
. . to establish an independent national state of its own." It was this<br />
principle, he said, that moved the Soviet Union to support the 1947 UN<br />
plan to partition Palestine and to create two independent states, one Jewish<br />
and one Arab. "Guided by this fundamental policy," the Soviet Union recognized<br />
Israel and established diplomatic relations with it.<br />
It soon became clear that neither the American nor the Soviet resolution<br />
could command the two-thirds majority required for Assembly adoption. On<br />
July 4 the Assembly voted on the Soviet resolution, section by section, and<br />
rejected all parts.* The United States decided not to press its own resolution<br />
to a vote. The resolution submitted by Albania, Communist China's unofficial<br />
spokesman in the UN, was even more extreme than the Soviet in that it<br />
contained a condemnation of the United States and Britain for their "incitement,<br />
aid and direct participation" in the Israeli aggression, and a proviso,<br />
leaving to the UAR "alone to decide whether or not it can permit the passage<br />
of vessels of the Israel aggressors through the Suez Canal and the Strait of<br />
Tiran." The Albanian resolution was rejected by a vote of 71 to 22, with 27<br />
abstentions. It was supported by 10 Communist states (with Rumania and<br />
Yugoslavia abstaining) and 10 Arab states (with Libya, Morocco and Tunisia<br />
abstaining) as well as by Cambodia and Mauritania.<br />
Other Proposals<br />
Anticipating the defeat of its proposals, the Soviet Union threw its weight<br />
behind a draft resolution introduced by Yugoslavia and 16 "non-aligned"<br />
states. The Yugoslav resolution explicitly called on Israel to withdraw all its<br />
0 For tabulation of roll call votes, on July 4, on the Soviet and other resolutions see: US<br />
Monthly Chronicle (United Nations Office of Public Information), July 1967, pp. 78-79.