28.02.2013 Views

Download File - JOHN J. HADDAD, Ph.D.

Download File - JOHN J. HADDAD, Ph.D.

Download File - JOHN J. HADDAD, Ph.D.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

166 Bot and Obrocea<br />

index, efficacy-to-noise ratio, diminishing the size of the clinical trials, and<br />

improving the odds that a specific investigational agent studied will gain market<br />

approval by the regulatory authorities. An obvious subcategory of biomarkers<br />

considered is that of target molecules themselves. If the target molecule is not<br />

expressed within the tumor tissue, irrespective of the MOA, the likelihood of<br />

clinical response is diminished should there be no significant “off target” effects.<br />

Well-known examples for such biomarkers in support of antibody-based treatment<br />

are Her-2/Neu expression or CD20 expression by tumor cells defining<br />

patients eligible for transtuzumab or rituximab treatment, respectively; but the<br />

paradigm spans other categories of molecular targeted therapies such as small<br />

molecules (bcr/abl in the case of imatinib, and EGFR polymorphism for<br />

gefitinib). It is not difficult to imagine that by not having a biomarker-based<br />

approach to stratify patients what would have been the fate of trastuzumab<br />

(Herceptin 1 ) since the treatment is relevant to only *35%ofbreastcarcinoma<br />

patients that display upregulation of Her-2/Neu. Due to the indirect and<br />

complex MOA, the challenges faced by active immunotherapy in light of this are<br />

considerably more significant. It would be ideal to have appropriate reagents and<br />

methodologies to determine and quantify the targets in clinical setting since the<br />

target molecules in many cases are MHC-peptide complexes expressed by the<br />

tumor cells. Unfortunately, this field is not mature yet; nevertheless, there is<br />

exciting new research on a new generation of antibody-like molecules that directly<br />

recognize MHC-peptide complexes (5). In the absence of measuring the target<br />

molecules, the next best approach—used by several groups developing antigenbased<br />

cancer vaccines—is to measure by immunohistochemistry the target antigen<br />

and MHC class I expression. Due to the fact that antigen processing and presentation<br />

is heterogeneous and subject to a variety of immune escape phenomena,<br />

this is obviously only a surrogate for target (MHC-peptide) molecule expression.<br />

A difficult aspect related to using such biomarkers is the correlation of the<br />

pharmacological activity with their biomarkers’ level of expression; in addition,<br />

the magnitude of the activity may depend to a high extent on the nature and<br />

potency of the investigational drug. Other approaches, for example, based on<br />

whole tumor lysates, allogeneic tumor cells or in general, not directed to a specific<br />

but a collection of antigens may not benefit from a target-related biomarker<br />

strategy. This increases considerably the risk throughout development. If we just<br />

consider the fact that a significant percentage of tumors show clear immune escape<br />

phenomena via MHC class I and/or TAP defects (between 20 and 50%), a lack of<br />

patient stratification based on target molecule expression may have drastic consequences<br />

in terms of reduction in response rate (even assuming an excellent<br />

pharmacological effect of the investigational drug). Conversely, use of such biomarker-based<br />

approaches to direct the testing of investigational agents in select<br />

populations—when afforded by the immunotherapeutic strategy—may have a<br />

negative impact on the number of patients treated in a specific disease setting.<br />

However this may ultimately result in an enhanced opportunity from medical and<br />

commercial standpoint due to a likely increased efficacy in clinic.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!