1st Joint ESMAC-GCMAS Meeting - Análise de Marcha
1st Joint ESMAC-GCMAS Meeting - Análise de Marcha
1st Joint ESMAC-GCMAS Meeting - Análise de Marcha
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
O-50<br />
GAIT ANALYSIS IN CHILDREN TREATED NONOPERATIVELY FOR CLUBFOOT:<br />
PHYSIOTHERAPY VS PONSETI CASTING<br />
Lori Karol, M.D. 1 , Ron El-Hawary, M.D. 2 , Kelly Jeans, M.S. 1<br />
1 Texas Scottish Rite Hospital<br />
Dallas, Texas, United States of America<br />
2 Isaac Walton Killam Health Center, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada<br />
Summary/Conclusions<br />
There is no significant difference in the likelihood of normal sagittal plane ankle kinematics or<br />
normal gait between 2 yr old children with clubfeet treated by either physical therapy (PT) or<br />
Ponseti casting. While PT patients are more likely to walk in some <strong>de</strong>gree of equinus, those<br />
who have un<strong>de</strong>rgone the Ponseti protocol have a higher prevalence of increased stance phase<br />
ankle dorsiflexion.<br />
Introduction<br />
Reports of ankle stiffness, loss of ankle power, knee hyperextension, and internal rotation 10<br />
yrs after posteromedial release for clubfeet[1-3] led our institution to support nonoperative<br />
treatment. [4] The French PT technique consists of daily manipulation and taping of the<br />
infant’s foot. [5,6] The Ponseti technique consists of weekly casts to externally rotate the foot<br />
about the talar head, usually accompanied by tendoachilles release at 6 wks, with use of an<br />
abduction bar nightly for 3 yrs. [7] As we offer both programs, the purpose of this study was to<br />
compare gait analysis results in 2 yr olds after successful treatment with PT or Ponseti casting.<br />
Statement of Clinical Significance<br />
PT and Ponseti casting result in similar functional results at 2 yr follow-up. Continued efforts<br />
to treat clubfeet nonoperatively are merited.<br />
Methods<br />
Forty-one children with 56 clubfeet treated nonoperatively by Ponseti casting and 47 children<br />
with 71 clubfeet treated by the French PT program were enrolled. Pretreatment Dimeglio<br />
scores ranged between 10 and 17, where 0 represents normal and 20 a rigid foot. [8] The<br />
pretreatment Dimeglio score for both groups was 12.9, indicating similar severity. Mild and<br />
mo<strong>de</strong>rate feet scoring 1 SD of normal (> 9°) in<br />
the final 25% of swing, and increased DF > 1 SD of normal (> 13°) during stance phase.<br />
Results<br />
There were no statistically significant differences in ca<strong>de</strong>nce, walking speed, or stri<strong>de</strong> time<br />
between the treatment groups and normals. There were two clear kinematic patterns i<strong>de</strong>ntified<br />
between groups. More children treated with PT walked in equinus (15%) compared to children<br />
who had Ponseti casting (0%)(p