Appendix A_Pages266to338_9MB.pdf - Ottawa Confederation Line
Appendix A_Pages266to338_9MB.pdf - Ottawa Confederation Line
Appendix A_Pages266to338_9MB.pdf - Ottawa Confederation Line
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
DOWNTOWN OTTAWA TRANSIT TUNNEL<br />
TO3041/TO3049<br />
AGENCY CONSULTATION GROUP MEETING NOTES Page 7 of 8<br />
DOWNTOWN OTTAWA TRANSIT TUNNEL<br />
TO3041/TO3049<br />
AGENCY CONSULTATION GROUP MEETING NOTES Page 8 of 8<br />
Task<br />
No.<br />
Description<br />
Discussion / Status<br />
Question/<br />
Comment<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Task<br />
No.<br />
Description<br />
Discussion / Status<br />
Question/<br />
Comment<br />
Carmel<br />
Dufour<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Response: That document was prepared 25 years ago, and is<br />
based on the technology available at the time and<br />
currently used in Edmonton. Design guidelines for<br />
<strong>Ottawa</strong> will be developed by the Rail Implementation<br />
Office. 80 km/h is likely sufficient based on station<br />
spacing and the restrictive geometry in the built-up<br />
area of the City. Across the Greenbelt, higher speeds<br />
could be appropriate. You would need to specify a<br />
vehicle which can operate faster. Physical constraints<br />
of environment (existing Transitway alignment) limits<br />
achievable speed, unless you want to spend a lot<br />
more money to design system which would then not<br />
connect everything you want to connect.<br />
Question: When will there be an exercise to model travel time<br />
v. the current bus service? One objective is to make<br />
transit faster – that needs to be quantified.<br />
Residents are looking for a system which will make<br />
travel faster. Longer walk times within stations also<br />
needs to be addressed.<br />
Comment: Can’t compare today to 5-10 years from now when<br />
buses will be even slower due to congestion,<br />
crowding.<br />
Response: The real advantage is reliability, and the elimination<br />
of confusion of buses – every train will be your train<br />
and will be able to take you where you want to go.<br />
You will also have off-vehicle fare collection and<br />
multiple doors for boarding speeding up the overall<br />
journey time. The entire system needs to be taken<br />
into account not just in-vehicle travel time.<br />
Question: Is anything preventing OC from operating bus service<br />
like LRT proposed now?<br />
Response: Primarily the lack of transfer facilities at stations and<br />
capacity of downtown road network.<br />
Comment: You can only park so many buses in a given time<br />
interval.<br />
Response: Off-board fare collection will speed system, make it<br />
regular v. today where boarding is slowed by<br />
cash/ticket transactions at front doors. True test is<br />
how system operates not vehicle speed. Between<br />
Bronson-Elgin transit access will be similar to today,<br />
and integration will be improved (e.g. DTW station<br />
with direct connections to Place de Ville (5 buildings).<br />
Question: How do you organize system to allow LRT to skip<br />
stops?<br />
Response: It could be run just like a bus, with passengers<br />
required to request stop. San Jose and Edmonton<br />
operate like this. Can also have individual door<br />
operation, like on O-Train for efficiency.<br />
Klaus<br />
Beltzner<br />
Ian<br />
Donnelly<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Klaus<br />
Beltzner<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Cheryl<br />
Savage<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Comment: Can only skip stations if there is not someone waiting<br />
on platform.<br />
Response: Yes, but train operator will also know that any<br />
passenger waiting at a station is waiting for the train<br />
and not one of several bus routes, eliminating the<br />
need to stop for passengers who actually want a<br />
different bus.<br />
Question: LRT skipping stations does not fit a timetabled<br />
operation. Assume this will not be covered in EA?<br />
Response: It’s an operational decision. The current Transitway<br />
buses have a different operating speed at different<br />
times of the day which reflects, in part, that not all<br />
trips stop at all stations. This service is still<br />
scheduled.<br />
Comment: Raised the issue of alignment as we have had no<br />
opportunity to discuss previously. If corridor needs<br />
to be altered, whether it is not significant, it is an EA<br />
factor. Previous issues with train operation over S<br />
curves, even where you can have transitions. Want<br />
to make sure benefits of less curvy alignments have<br />
been considered.<br />
Response: Yes, that has been looked at.<br />
3. Closure As this is likely the last meeting of the ACG, members were thanked<br />
for their participation in the study. The meeting notes and<br />
presentation will be posted on the ftp site as soon as possible. The<br />
meeting ended at 11:30 a.m.<br />
Please report on errors or omissions to Paul Croft at p.croft@delcan.com by March 3, 2010.<br />
Attendees:<br />
Cheryl Savage – OC Transpo<br />
Dave Hart – Rogers Cable<br />
Mona Abouhenidy – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Bob Spicer – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Phil Pawliuk - MTO<br />
Klaus Beltzner – Transport Action Canada<br />
David Jeanes – Transport Action Canada<br />
Nadia Brescacin - MTO<br />
Arto Keklikian - NCC<br />
Allan Ireland - MTO<br />
Ian Donnelly – Downtown Coalition<br />
Sgt. Claude Parent – <strong>Ottawa</strong> Police<br />
Marylène Cormier – Transport Canada<br />
Sandra Candow – NCC<br />
Florence Robinson - Hydro One<br />
Carmel Dufour - STO<br />
Luc Masse – Transport Canada<br />
Stuart Edison – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Linda Carkner – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Phil Pawliuk - MTO<br />
Carina Duclos – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Rick Zarzosa – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
Gary O’Connor – City of <strong>Ottawa</strong><br />
David<br />
Jeanes<br />
Cheryl<br />
Savage<br />
David<br />
Jeanes<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
Klaus<br />
Beltzner<br />
David<br />
Hopper<br />
H:\ISO\TO3041\TOB\DOCS\Agency Consultation Group\Meeting6_Feb1710\ACG Meeting_Feb1610_Notes_Draft.doc