Chapter 2. THE HISTORY OF IAN DONALD SCHOOLretroperitoneal, genitourinary and involving the abdominal wall— and also alltypes <strong>of</strong> ascites, benign as well as malignant. Naturally, pregnancy, as quite thecommonest cause <strong>of</strong> female abdominal distension, came under ultrasonicscrutiny as well, but not initially by us before 1956-57. This was mainly dueto the geographic separation at that time <strong>of</strong> my gynecological unit from myobstetric hospital.I do not deny that we had our full share <strong>of</strong> discouraging problems and ourearly apparatus was laughably crude. As I commented in our first article inThe Lancet, what surprised and delighted us was that we got any results at all.You must remember that we had no yardsticks by which to control the rate ormethod <strong>of</strong> scanning, or even the best frequencies to use, and it was only theready feedback <strong>of</strong> information such as one gets in gynecology, which made itpossible to standardize our scanning techniques. Even so, we had very serioustechnical difficulties 20 or more years ago, such as the unreliability <strong>of</strong> oursine/cosine potentiometers, poor transducers, no controllable persistence cathoderay tubes, let alone storage tubes and computer storage systems, whichtoday you all take for granted. We worked literally in the dark in more sensesthan one.Pr<strong>of</strong>. IAN DONALD with the fi rst generation <strong>of</strong> the students at his <strong>School</strong> in Dubrovnik, 1982.Looking back over what has been a long story <strong>of</strong> trial and even more <strong>of</strong> error,I cannot help feel a sense <strong>of</strong> surprise at all the lucky strikes which have beenmade over the years and their associated spin-<strong>of</strong>fs. Who, for example, wouldhave thought that our crude early work would have made possible the correctdiagnosis <strong>of</strong> hydatidiform mole within a matter <strong>of</strong> minutes or that we wouldultimately, subsequent to this, have refined the technique to demonstrate theplacenta, both its site and its nature. Here I must acknowledge our co-operationwith our friends in Denver, Colorado with whom we have maintaineda happy liaison over the years. Our experiments in 1961 in measuring the biparietaldiameter proved to be the start <strong>of</strong> all the present sophisticated forms<strong>of</strong> fetal biometry.25
Chapter 2. THE HISTORY OF IAN DONALD SCHOOLNewcomers to the field <strong>of</strong> ultrasound must be bewildered as to which sort <strong>of</strong>apparatus to select. There are many manufacturers, but I have noticed a steadilyincreasing convergence as to quality <strong>of</strong> performance as well as price, sothat you get roughly what you pay for. Cheap apparatus, cheap results. Expensiveapparatus may yield results beyond your clinical needs, so you shouldthink well before choosing.Much will depend upon the sort <strong>of</strong> work you want to do, and the availableanatomical access. For example, if you want to look deeply into the pelvis atvery early pregnancy or for early tumor or even for ripening ovarian follicles,the keyhole approach provided by sector scanners through the full bladderwill, in my opinion, give the best results. The same remarks in favor <strong>of</strong> thesectorized view apply to subcostal studies in the upper abdomen and throughthe intercostals spaces and particularly in echocardiology, anywhere, in fact,where access is small and the window area requires a sectorized view. Theview can be improved considerably if a compound sector scan can be employedwhich provides an appreciation <strong>of</strong> the organ under study in its relationshipto the rest <strong>of</strong> the body, particularly the urinary bladder. Unfortunately, theuse <strong>of</strong> sector scanners calls for more skill than the linear array systems which,though providing a blinkered «mouth organ» type <strong>of</strong> view, are very much easierto handle, especially in the hands <strong>of</strong> the relative novice who is able, proprioceptively,to appreciate just how well he is lining up his linear array. Theirmost impressive use is in the middle trimester <strong>of</strong> pregnancy when the fetus islikely to be no longer than the array system and the abdominal wall will bes<strong>of</strong>t enough to accommodate it throughout its entire length.The advent <strong>of</strong> real-time scanners, both linear and sector, has revolutionizedultrasonic diagnosis, chiefly because it not only allows the continuous movementpatterns <strong>of</strong> what is being studied to be graphically displayed and recordedbut, even more important, it speeds up the whole process <strong>of</strong> ultrasonicsearch. Added to this, various methods <strong>of</strong> frame-grabbing or framefreezing canbe employed which provide static records for later scrutiny. This facility enormouslyincreases the throughput <strong>of</strong> patients, since it speeds up the whole examination.The various storage, recording, and photographic systems are mainlyresponsible for the differences in price between one apparatus and another.A real-time scanner can be combined with a static compound sector scanner.There is a choice <strong>of</strong> sector scanners between the wholly electronic phasedarraysystems, which are expensive, though very compact, and particularlyuseful in cardiology, and the combined mechanical and electronic systemsemploying either spinning rotors with several transducers or rockers, eithertransducer crystals or mirrors. The linear-array systems are all electronic andwithout moving parts, as in the case <strong>of</strong> phasedarray scanners. As they say inEnglish slang, «You pays your money and takes your choice».It distresses me that there are sometimes arguments about who should be incontrol <strong>of</strong> ultrasound scanning —just like dogs squabbling over a bone. Naturally,I now expect you all to be so much better at the ultrasonic art than me, sothat I can safely withdraw into my old age. But I do recognize that there aremany disciplines involved. On the whole, in medical sonar, there has been a26