07.04.2013 Views

Hampton Court ... Illustrated with forty-three drawings by Herbert ...

Hampton Court ... Illustrated with forty-three drawings by Herbert ...

Hampton Court ... Illustrated with forty-three drawings by Herbert ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ANDREA MANTEGNA 185<br />

order, and on one wall, so that the scheme may be<br />

followed, and none of the effect which that stately<br />

march is intended to give is lost. But in summer<br />

at least, the sunshine,or the reflection, on the glass,<br />

makes it difficult to observe them clearly or continuously.<br />

It is rarely, indeed, that the whole of any<br />

picture can be seen at one time. No arrangement<br />

of position thatIcan discover, or of the blinds that<br />

can be drawn down the great windows, makes much<br />

difference. We can only see them imperfectly and<br />

piecemeal. It is bad enough to see them; but worse<br />

remains behind. They have been patched, restored,<br />

repainted, treated <strong>with</strong> every indignity that can be<br />

"<br />

imagined. In the entire series there are perhaps<br />

not a dozen square inches in which Mantegna's hand<br />

is still visible," is the judgment of one of the latest<br />

and most competent critics.1 They are rather, says<br />

another, " a memory than a work still extant; the<br />

question not being which parts of the composition<br />

are due to the restorer, but which,if any, reveal to<br />

the careful observer any traces of Mantegna's own<br />

handling." 2<br />

This is true enough, it must be admitted; and<br />

from the point of view of the connoisseur, who<br />

judges a picture according to the standard which<br />

his knowledge of its artist compels him to set up,<br />

it is fatal. But for the historian, and for the general<br />

observer, the "Triumph " retains an attraction which<br />

1 Mary Logan,"The ItalianPictures at <strong>Hampton</strong> <strong>Court</strong>."<br />

2 C. Phillips, " The Picture Gallery of Charles I.," p. 69.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!