Aanesthetic Agents for Day Surgery - NIHR Health Technology ...
Aanesthetic Agents for Day Surgery - NIHR Health Technology ...
Aanesthetic Agents for Day Surgery - NIHR Health Technology ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
128<br />
Appendix 4<br />
TABLE 66 contd Summary of adult clinical outcomes studies<br />
Study Investigations and subjects Outcome Results Conclusions and<br />
measures grade of evidence<br />
Nathanson et al., (1) Propofol, sevoflurane, N 2O (n = 21) (a) Open eyes (a): (1) 7.8, (2) 4.8 min; Grade II–1b<br />
1995, 100 USA p < 0.05<br />
(2) Propofol, desflurane, N 2O (n = 21) (b) Obey<br />
Controlled study command (b): (1) 10.2, (2) 6.4 min; NS<br />
N 2O: given<br />
(c) Orientation (c): (1) 11.2, (2) 9.3 min; NS<br />
Premedication: none<br />
(d) Sit unaided (d): (1) 90, (2) 107 min; NS<br />
Opioid: vecuronium, fentanyl<br />
(e) Walk (e): (1) 124, (2) 126 min; NS<br />
Procedures: laparoscopic sterilisation<br />
(f) Discharge (f): (1) 193, (2) 201 min; NS<br />
Nelskyla et al., (1) Sevoflurane (n = 22) (a) PONV (a): (1) 6%, (2) 1%; p < 0.01 Grade I<br />
1999, 101 Finland<br />
(2) Propofol + alfentanil (n = 22) (b) Pain (b): (1) 21, (2) 19; NS Randomisation by<br />
RCT sequential coded<br />
N 2O: given (c) Time to (c): (1) 6.5, (2) 3.5 min; envelopes<br />
eyes open p < 0.05<br />
Premedication: none Not blind<br />
(d) Time to (d): (1) 7.5, (2) 5.0 min;<br />
Procedures; evacuation orientation p < 0.05<br />
Age: > 18 years; mean ± SD, (e) Time to (e): (1) 30, (2) 22 min; NS<br />
28 ± 30 years fluids<br />
(f): (1) 149, (2) 166 min; NS<br />
(f) Time to<br />
discharge (g): (1) 86%, (2) 100%; NS<br />
(g) Patient<br />
satisfaction<br />
Nielsen et al., (1) Propofol TIVA, alfentanil (n = 28) (a) P-deletion Data only given <strong>for</strong> all tests Grade I<br />
1991, 102 Denmark variant 2 h postoperatively<br />
(2) Thiopentone TIVA, alfentanil Method of randomisation<br />
RCT (n = 28) (b) Coordination (a–d): No differences not reported<br />
post-box<br />
N 2O: not given (e): No recollection of Blind<br />
(c) Coordination picture used; (1) 5,<br />
Premedication: none pegboard (2) 13; p < 0.05<br />
Gender: women (d) Short-term<br />
memory<br />
Age: 18–60 years<br />
(e) Long-term<br />
memory<br />
Nightingale and<br />
Lewis, 1992,<br />
(1) Propofol TIVA, alfentanil, no N2O (a) Simple No significant difference Grade I<br />
103<br />
(n = 25) reaction time between groups <strong>for</strong><br />
England any variable Method of randomisation<br />
(2) Propofol, isoflurane, N2O, alfentanil (b) Choice not reported<br />
RCT (n = 25) reaction time<br />
Not blind<br />
N2O: given in group 1 (c) CFFT<br />
Premedication: none (d) PONV<br />
Procedures: minor gynaecological<br />
Gender: women<br />
continued