Part II Community-Based Forest Management Program - ppmrn

ADEQUATE MONITORING ACTIVITIES
Province
Nueva
Vizcaya
Project
Brgy. San
Isidro
Integrated
Social Forestry
Multi-purpose
Cooperative
(BSIISFMPC)
Deficiency in Monitoring Activities
Conditions
• Funders of the proposed livelihood projects of POs has yet to
be tapped;
• Members could not pay their monthly dues and capital shares
due to financial constraints; and
• Marketing outlets were not yet established due to lack of
funders for the proposed project.
The following were reported but not quantified in the
Accomplishment Report:
• Livestock raising to augment individual income of members;
• Patrolling of CBFM area; and
• Cross visits to other successful POs.
The DMADAI submitted to DENR in March 2005 its accomplishment on CY 2003
AWP. The report was apparently not evaluated by the DENR. The team’s
evaluation revealed that a number of activities in the AWP were actually not
undertaken:
Activities
Per approved 2003
AWP
Target
Target
Date
Accomp.
As of
3/2005 * Remarks
Conversion of PO into 1 July - PO did not apply for
Cooperative
CDA registration.
Membership
not Dec - No reported activity
development and
quantified
continuing education and
training
Plantation and protection
maintenance
Foot patrol
1,710 has 1,710 has
Co nstruction and 213 has.
213 has.
maintenance of
fireline
Implementation of FS 2 - No reported activity.
Per team’s interview,
the PO is not capable
of conducting
feasibility studies.
Implementation of
Livelihood projects
2 - No reported activities.
No
Establishment of Demo 1 - Reason provided to the
Farm
team.
Conduct of training on 2 Dec. -
leadership and project
management for PO
Officers.
Conduct of inventory of
stumps, branches and
28.0 cu.m.
Not
-
No report ed activities
roots
indicated
Conduct Monthly BOD
meetings 3 3
Submit periodic reports 3 3
* Per PO’s Capsule Report covering January to March 2005
The PENRO, however, reported in its 2004 Annual Report that compliance by 17
POs, including DMADAI, with CBFMA was monitored. The extent of monitoring
actually undertaken and POs’ compliance with the CBFMAs were, however, not
discussed.
The team also noted that DENR- Region II developed a simplified tool in
86