16.01.2013 Views

Nord Stream: Not Just a Pipeline

Nord Stream: Not Just a Pipeline

Nord Stream: Not Just a Pipeline

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Contents<br />

Lists of Figures and Tables ii<br />

Acknowledgements iii<br />

Abbreviations v<br />

1 Introduction 1<br />

1.1 The Structure of the Report 2<br />

1.2 Source Material and Selection 4<br />

2 What is <strong>Nord</strong> <strong>Stream</strong>? 5<br />

2.1 Companies Involved 5<br />

2.2 Technical Features, Timeframe and Budget 6<br />

2.3 Legal Framework 7<br />

2.4 Recent Developments and Current State of Affairs 7<br />

3 First Perspective: ‘Bringing Gas to Europe’ 9<br />

3.1 The <strong>Nord</strong> <strong>Stream</strong> Consortium’s Explanation: The EU<br />

Needs Gas 9<br />

3.2 Alternative Explanation: Germany Needs Gas 13<br />

3.3 Overarching Assumption: Harmony through<br />

Interdependence 15<br />

4 Second Perspective: ‘Dividing Europe’ 18<br />

4.1 Main Sources of Concern 18<br />

4.2 Russian Energy Policy: Neo-Imperialism in the Making? 22<br />

4.3 The Real Threat: A Coming Russian Gas Deficit 25<br />

5 Third Perspective: ‘A Military-Strategic Problem’ 30<br />

5.1 The Swedish Debate: Paranoia or Cold War Revisited? 30<br />

5.2 Comparing Debates: Sweden, Finland and Estonia 33<br />

5.3 The Role of History and Geopolitics 35<br />

6 Fourth Perspective: ‘A Threat to the Baltic Sea Environment’ 40<br />

6.1 The Baltic Sea: <strong>Not</strong> Like Other Seas 40<br />

6.2 The North Sea Analogy 42<br />

6.3 Politicisation and the Role of Domestic Politics 46<br />

7 Conclusions 50<br />

Appendix: Energy Mix Charts 56<br />

References 63<br />

8.1 Interviews (by the Author) 63<br />

8.2 Printed Sources 64<br />

i

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!