04.10.2012 Views

Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World

Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World

Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The Marriage of Scepticism and Wonder<br />

declare the origin of matter or human behaviour off-limits?<br />

Because its explanatory power is so great, once you get the hang<br />

of scientific reasoning you're eager to apply it everywhere.<br />

However, in the course of looking deeply within ourselves, we<br />

may challenge notions that give comfort before the terrors of the<br />

world. I'm aware that some of the discussion in, say, the preceding<br />

chapter may have such a character.<br />

When anthropologists survey the thousands of distinct cultures<br />

and ethnicities that comprise the human family, they are<br />

struck by how few features there are that are givens, always<br />

present no matter how exotic the society. There are, for<br />

example, cultures - the Ik of Uganda is one - where all Ten<br />

Commandments seem to be systematically, institutionally<br />

ignored. There are societies that abandon their old and their<br />

newborn, that eat their enemies, that use seashells or pigs or<br />

young women for money. But they all have a strong incest<br />

taboo, they all use technology, and almost all believe in a<br />

supernatural world of gods and spirits, often connected with the<br />

natural environment they inhabit and the well-being of the<br />

plants and animals they eat. (The ones with a supreme god who<br />

lives in the sky tend to be the most ferocious - torturing their<br />

enemies for example. But this is a statistical correlation only;<br />

the causal link has not been established, although speculations<br />

naturally present themselves.)<br />

In every such society, there is a cherished world of myth and<br />

metaphor which co-exists with the workaday world. Efforts to<br />

reconcile the two are made, and any rough edges at the joints tend<br />

to be off-limits and ignored. We compartmentalize. Some scientists<br />

do this too, effortlessly stepping between the sceptical world<br />

of science and the credulous world of religious belief without<br />

skipping a beat. Of course, the greater the mismatch between<br />

these two worlds, the more difficult it is to be comfortable, with<br />

untroubled conscience, with both.<br />

In a life short and uncertain, it seems heartless to do anything<br />

that might deprive people of the consolation of faith when science<br />

cannot remedy their anguish. Those who cannot bear the burden<br />

of science are free to ignore its precepts. But we cannot have<br />

science in bits and pieces, applying it where we feel safe and<br />

279

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!