Toll Facility Safety Study Report to Congress - About
Toll Facility Safety Study Report to Congress - About
Toll Facility Safety Study Report to Congress - About
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Toll</strong> <strong>Facility</strong> <strong>Safety</strong> <strong>Study</strong> <strong>Report</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Congress</strong><br />
In 1990, Zilocchi described a success s<strong>to</strong>ry on the Garden State Parkway dealing with the<br />
addition of branch <strong>to</strong>ll lanes <strong>to</strong> improve safety and operations at <strong>to</strong>ll plazas. This practice is used<br />
by several <strong>to</strong>ll agencies when expanding <strong>to</strong>ll plazas <strong>to</strong> create more <strong>to</strong>ll lanes. Traditionally, <strong>to</strong>ll<br />
plazas were expanded by adding lanes horizontally, which caused issues with increased right-ofway,<br />
construction time needed, disruption of traffic, opposition from the community, and cost.<br />
Branch lanes are used <strong>to</strong> add <strong>to</strong>ll lanes either ahead of or after the existing lanes as a branch of<br />
the mainline plaza. Zilocchi stated that safety was a prime concern and thus the safety aspects<br />
were carefully moni<strong>to</strong>red. One issue deals with mo<strong>to</strong>rists traveling <strong>to</strong>o fast on the approach <strong>to</strong><br />
the branch lanes, and thus signing was used <strong>to</strong> successfully cut down on approach speeds. Of<br />
additional concern was <strong>to</strong>ll worker safety, and thus the New Jersey State Police were asked <strong>to</strong><br />
carefully moni<strong>to</strong>r the branch <strong>to</strong>ll lanes due <strong>to</strong> an increased danger of robbery or other<br />
inappropriate action with <strong>to</strong>llbooth personnel in the branch lanes. Other concerns included<br />
protecting collec<strong>to</strong>rs from being injured by vehicles, and thus impact attenua<strong>to</strong>rs and sidewalks<br />
with steel guiderails were added <strong>to</strong> make the branch lanes as safe as the traditional lanes.<br />
Zilocchi reported that as of publication of the article, there were not any serious accidents in the<br />
branch lanes and that there did not seem <strong>to</strong> be any reason <strong>to</strong> think that the lanes were inherently<br />
unsafe as designed.<br />
Driver and Occupant <strong>Safety</strong> in the Area of <strong>Toll</strong> Facilities<br />
In 2003, Mohamed Abdel-Aty (2003) published a paper analyzing driver injury severity levels<br />
and what fac<strong>to</strong>rs had the most influence. In the paper, models were developed at roadway<br />
sections, intersections, and <strong>to</strong>ll plazas in Central Florida. The <strong>to</strong>ll plazas analyzed were on the<br />
Central Florida expressway system on state roads 408, 417, and 528 for a <strong>to</strong>tal of 79 miles. Ten<br />
mainline <strong>to</strong>ll plazas and 42 ramp <strong>to</strong>lls are located in the system. The ETC was added starting in<br />
1994 and the installations were completed by 1998. Police reports were obtained in 1999 and<br />
2000 <strong>to</strong> analyze the results.<br />
Variables collected fell in<strong>to</strong> the categories of crash, driver, vehicle, plaza, and roadway. Crashrelated<br />
fac<strong>to</strong>rs included age, gender, driver license type, alcohol involvement, driver violation,<br />
presence in an ETC lane, and ETC user. Vehicle fac<strong>to</strong>rs included vehicle type, point of impact,<br />
number of impacts, and speed ratio (as compared with the posted limit). Plaza fac<strong>to</strong>rs included<br />
mainline versus ramp, and roadway fac<strong>to</strong>rs included weather condition, lighting condition, and<br />
time and day information. Of 1,932 <strong>to</strong>tal crashes on the system in 1999 and 2000, 447 crashes<br />
(23.1 percent) occurred near a <strong>to</strong>ll plaza with 803 drivers involved. The type of crashes were:<br />
rear-end (40.1 percent), sideswipe (26.5 percent), fixed object (21.3 percent), backed-in<strong>to</strong> (6.4<br />
percent), and other (5.7 percent). As for data that indicated crash location relative <strong>to</strong> the <strong>to</strong>ll<br />
plaza (725 vehicles), 43.6 percent of the accidents were when the vehicle was approaching, 43.7<br />
percent were when the vehicle was at the plaza, and 12.7 percent were when the vehicle was<br />
leaving the plaza. When looking at injury severity, 61.0 percent had no injury, 21.0 percent had<br />
possible injury, 15.3 percent had evident injury, and 2.8 percent had a severe or fatal injury.<br />
The results showed that older drivers, male drivers, and occupants not wearing a seat belt had a<br />
higher probability of severe injury. Additionally, drivers of passenger cars, vehicles struck on<br />
the driver’s side, and vehicles that were speeding experienced higher severity injury.<br />
Additionally, it was found that vehicles with an ETC transponder had a higher injury rate <strong>to</strong><br />
those without the transponders. This may occur when a vehicle without a transponder s<strong>to</strong>ps in<br />
the lane with fast-moving ETC transponder users.<br />
Appendix B – Literature Review Page B-4