o_195qg5dto17o4rbc85q1ge61i84a.pdf
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
80<br />
anarchism: a beginner’s guide<br />
Where anarchists have had political disagreements it is often<br />
because they dispute the sources of domination or oppression in the<br />
state, not because they have different ideas about what constitutes<br />
‘woman’ (though this is an important debate in other feminist circles).<br />
Anarcha-feminists like Nicki Clarke link liberation to overcoming<br />
the alienation exhibited in and through the pornographic<br />
objectification of women in commodity culture. Anarchists associated<br />
with Class War divorce ‘middle class’ feminist concerns with<br />
pornography from the power relations that support capitalist forms<br />
of exploitation: the problem is not the ‘pictures of naked adults<br />
having sex’ it is the ‘damaging, hierarchical and sexist class society<br />
that introduces the idea of sexual abuse and male power and<br />
dominance over women’. 77<br />
The debate between communitarians and libertarians adds an<br />
important dimension to anarchist discussions of the state and the<br />
organization of anarchy but it does not suggest any particular<br />
mapping between state critiques and anarchist ideals. It is possible to<br />
argue – as Guérin did – that the collective struggle against exploitation<br />
will support libertarian ends or, as Tolstoy held, that life in<br />
community – Christian fellowship – is based on the exercise of<br />
individual conscience. The possible mappings are represented in the<br />
diagram below:<br />
Mapping Collectivism, Individualism, Communitarianism and Libertarianism<br />
Authority Power Liberty Anarchy<br />
Struggle against alienation/exploitation<br />
collective<br />
communitarian<br />
Command<br />
Autonomy<br />
Individual<br />
collective<br />
libertarian<br />
communitarian<br />
Control<br />
Individuality<br />
Individual<br />
collective<br />
libertarian<br />
communitarian<br />
Corruption<br />
Altruism<br />
Individual<br />
libertarian