Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
in all those things that to the administration of a great Commonwealth<br />
are necessary to be known, no man is presumed to be a good<br />
counsellor but in such business as he hath not only been much versed<br />
in, but hath also much meditated on and considered. For seeing the<br />
business of a Commonwealth is this; to preserve the people in peace at<br />
home, and defend them against foreign invasion; we shall find it<br />
requires great knowledge of the disposition of mankind, of the<br />
rights of government, and of the nature of equity, law, justice, and<br />
honour, not to be attained without study; and of the strength,<br />
commodities, places, both of their own country and their<br />
neighbours'; as also of the inclinations and designs of all nations<br />
that may any way annoy them. And this is not attained to without<br />
much experience. Of which things, not only the whole sum, but every<br />
one of the particulars requires the age and observation of a man in<br />
years, and of more than ordinary study. The wit required for<br />
counsel, as I have said before (Chapter VIII), is judgement. And the<br />
differences of men in that point come from different education; of<br />
some, to one kind of study or business, and of others, to another.<br />
When for the doing of anything there be infallible rules (as in<br />
engines and edifices, the rules of geometry), all the experience of<br />
the world cannot equal his counsel that has learned or found out the<br />
rule. And when there is no such rule, he that hath most experience<br />
in that particular kind of business has therein the best judgement,<br />
and is the best counsellor.<br />
Fourthly, to be able to give counsel to a Commonwealth, in a<br />
business that hath reference to another Commonwealth, it is<br />
necessary to be acquainted with the intelligences and letters that<br />
come from thence, and with all the records of treaties and other<br />
transactions of state between them; which none can do but such as<br />
the representative shall think fit. By which we may see that they<br />
who are not called to counsel can have no good counsel in such cases<br />
to obtrude.<br />
Fifthly, supposing the number of counsellors equal, a man is<br />
better counselled by hearing them apart than in an assembly; and<br />
that for many causes. First, in hearing them apart, you have the<br />
advice of every man; but in an assembly many of them deliver their<br />
advice with aye or no, or with their hands or feet, not moved by their<br />
own sense, but by the eloquence of another, or for fear of displeasing<br />
some that have spoken, or the whole by contradiction, or for fear of<br />
appearing duller in apprehension than those that have applauded the<br />
contrary opinion. Secondly, in an assembly of many there cannot choose<br />
but be some interests are contrary to that of the public; and these<br />
their interests make passionate, and passion eloquent, and eloquence<br />
draws others into the same advice. For the passions of men, which<br />
asunder are moderate, as the heat of one brand; in assembly are like<br />
many brands that inflame one another (especially when they blow one<br />
another with orations) to the setting of the Commonwealth on fire,<br />
under pretence of counselling it. Thirdly, in hearing every man apart,<br />
one may examine, when there is need, the truth or probability of his<br />
reasons, and of the grounds of the advice he gives, by frequent<br />
interruptions and objections; which cannot be done in an assembly,<br />
where in every difficult question a man is rather astonied and dazzled<br />
with the variety of discourse upon it, than informed of the course<br />
he ought to take. Besides, there cannot be an assembly of many, called<br />
together for advice, wherein there be not some that have the<br />
ambition the ambition to be thought eloquent, and also learned in<br />
the politics; and give not their advice with care of the business