Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
means, contempt of honour, and hardness of heart concurred to make<br />
them sue for such an office. But amongst the Israelites it was a<br />
positive law of God their Sovereign that he that was convicted of a<br />
capital crime should be stoned to death by the people; and that the<br />
witnesses should cast the first stone, and after the witnesses, then<br />
the rest of the people. This was a law that designed who were to be<br />
the executioners; but not that any one should throw a stone at him<br />
before conviction and sentence, where the congregation was judge.<br />
The witnesses were nevertheless to be heard before they proceeded to<br />
execution, unless the fact were committed in the presence of the<br />
congregation itself, or in sight of the lawful judges; for then<br />
there needed no other witnesses but the judges themselves.<br />
Nevertheless, this manner of proceeding, being not thoroughly<br />
understood, hath given occasion to a dangerous opinion, that any man<br />
may kill another, in some cases, by a right of zeal; as if the<br />
executions done upon offenders in the kingdom of God in old time<br />
proceeded not from the sovereign command, but from the authority of<br />
private zeal: which, if we consider the texts that seem to favour<br />
it, is quite contrary.<br />
First, where the Levites fell upon the people that had made and<br />
worshipped the golden calf, and slew three thousand of them, it was by<br />
the commandment of Moses from the mouth of God; as is manifest,<br />
Exodus, 32. 27. And when the son of a woman of Israel had blasphemed<br />
God, they that heard it did not kill him, but brought him before<br />
Moses, who put him under custody, till God should give sentence<br />
against him; as appears, Leviticus, 24. 11, 12. Again, when Phinehas<br />
killed Zimri and Cozbi,* it was not by right of private zeal: their<br />
crime was committed in the sight of the assembly; there needed no<br />
witness; the law was known, and he the heir apparent to the<br />
sovereignty; and, which is the principal point, the lawfulness of<br />
his act depended wholly upon a subsequent ratification by Moses,<br />
whereof he had no cause to doubt. And this presumption of a future<br />
ratification is sometimes necessary to the safety of a Commonwealth;<br />
as in a sudden rebellion any man that can suppress it by his own power<br />
in the country where it begins, without express law or commission, may<br />
lawfully do it, and provide to have it ratified, or pardoned, whilst<br />
it is in doing, or after it is done. Also, it is expressly said,<br />
"Whosoever shall kill the murderer shall kill him upon the word of<br />
witnesses":*(2) but witnesses suppose a formal judicature, and<br />
consequently condemn that pretence of jus zelotarum. The Law of<br />
Moses concerning him that enticeth to idolatry, that is to say, in the<br />
kingdom of God to a renouncing of his allegiance, forbids to conceal<br />
him, and commands the accuser to cause him to be put to death, and<br />
to cast the first stone at him;*(3) but not to kill him before he be<br />
condemned. And the process against idolatry is exactly set down: for<br />
God there speaketh to the people as Judge, and commandeth them, when a<br />
man is accused of idolatry, to enquire diligently of the fact, and<br />
finding it true, then to stone him; but still the hand of the<br />
witness throweth the first stone.*(4) This is not private zeal, but<br />
public condemnation. In like manner when a father hath a rebellious<br />
son, the law is that he shall bring him before the judges of the town,<br />
and all the people of the town shall stone him.*(5) Lastly, by<br />
pretence of these laws it was that St. Stephen was stoned, and not<br />
by pretence of private zeal: for before he was carried away to<br />
execution, he had pleaded his cause before the high priest. There is<br />
nothing in all this, nor in any other part of the Bible, to<br />
countenance executions by private zeal; which, being oftentimes but