Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Hobbes - Leviathan.pdf
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
any power to give sentence.<br />
From hence it followeth that one Church cannot be excommunicated<br />
by another: for either they have equal power to excommunicate each<br />
other, in which case excommunication is not discipline, nor an act<br />
of authority, but schism, and dissolution of charity; or one is so<br />
subordinate to the other as that they both have but one voice, and<br />
then they be but one Church; and the part excommunicated is no more<br />
a Church, but a dissolute number of individual persons.<br />
And because the sentence of excommunication importeth an advice<br />
not to keep company nor so much as to eat with him that is<br />
excommunicate, if a sovereign prince or assembly be excommunicate, the<br />
sentence is of no effect. For all subjects are bound to be in the<br />
company and presence of their own sovereign, when he requireth it,<br />
by the law of nature; nor can they lawfully either expel him from<br />
any place of his own dominion, whether profane or holy; nor go out<br />
of his dominion without his leave; much less, if he call them to<br />
that honour, refuse to eat with him. And as to other princes and<br />
states, because they are not parts of one and the same congregation,<br />
they need not any other sentence to keep them from keeping company<br />
with the state excommunicate: for the very institution, as it<br />
uniteth many men into one community, so it dissociateth one<br />
community from another: so that excommunication is not needful for<br />
keeping kings and states asunder; nor has any further effect than is<br />
in the nature of policy itself, unless it be to instigate princes to<br />
war upon one another.<br />
Nor is the excommunication of a Christian subject that obeyeth the<br />
laws of his own sovereign, whether Christian or heathen, of any<br />
effect. For if he believe that "Jesus is the Christ, he hath the<br />
Spirit of God,"* "and God dwelleth in him, and he in God."*(2) But<br />
he that hath the Spirit of God; he that dwelleth in God; he in whom<br />
God dwelleth, can receive no harm by the excommunication of men.<br />
Therefore, he that believeth Jesus to be the Christ is free from all<br />
the dangers threatened to persons excommunicate. He that believeth<br />
it not is no Christian. Therefore a true and unfeigned Christian is<br />
not liable to excommunication: nor he also that is a professed<br />
Christian, till his hypocrisy appear in his manners; that is, till his<br />
behaviour be contrary to the law of his sovereign, which is the rule<br />
of manners, and which Christ and his Apostles have commanded us to<br />
be subject to. For the Church cannot judge of manners but by<br />
external actions, which actions can never be unlawful but when they<br />
are against the law of the Commonwealth.<br />
-<br />
* John, 5. 1<br />
*(2) Ibid., 4. 15<br />
-<br />
If a man's father, or mother, or master be excommunicate, yet are<br />
not the children forbidden to keep them company, nor to eat with them;<br />
for that were, for the most part, to oblige them not to eat at all,<br />
for want of means to get food; and to authorize them to disobey<br />
their parents and masters, contrary to the precept of the Apostles.<br />
In sum, the power of excommunication cannot be extended further than<br />
to the end for which the Apostles and pastors of the Church have their<br />
commission from our Saviour; which is not to rule by command and<br />
coercion, but by teaching and direction of men in the way of salvation<br />
in the world to come. And as a master in any science may abandon his<br />
scholar when he obstinately neglecteth the practice of his rules,<br />
but not accuse him of injustice, because he was never bound to obey