HUNGARIAN STUDIES 11. No. 1. Nemzetközi Magyar ... - EPA

GÖRGEY, LEE, AND PERCEPTIONS 61such as Winston Churchill, write that "Lee was one of the greatest captainsknown to the annals of war." Such statements have not been forthcoming inGörgey's defense. Although Friedrich Engels considered Görgey, along withthe Pole József Bem, to be the most talented commanders of that age, few todayare familiar with Görgey's exploits during the Hungarian War of Independence.According to István Deák, he was "cold, sarcastic, overly modest,puritanical, and contemptuous." 3 Priscilla Robertson states that Görgeydid not care a fig for Hungary in his heart, or for any other ideal... He sneered, openlyor privately, at Kossuth and the government of Hungary, at the common people, at themilitia, at his own soldiers, and even at himself. 4These are not the personal traits which inspire admiraton and devotionamong anyone else but his soldiers. The South could forgive Lee for hisblunder at Gettysburg, but Görgey could never escape the charge that he hadsold his honor and country for a price.Regardless of Görgey's performance in battle and the common sense heshowed in surrender, accolades are never easily given to commanders who losea war - in particular, to an individual such as Görgey, whose contempt forpoliticians and military superiors, such as János Móga and the Pole HenrykDembinski, led him to obstruct, disobey, and interfere with their decisions.Machiavelli wrote "If a general wins a battle it cancels all other errors andmiscarriage." 5 The converse of this statement implies that if a general loses awar, all brilliance, daring, and audacity must be cancelled out by his failure.Charles Fair statesthere have been few men so strategically placed and so overpowering in their authoritythat they were able,... single-handedly, to bring on a general disaster... [and] in defeat,the first concern of those officially responsible is always to shift the blame onto othersand to prove their own conduct to have been above reproach, if not wasted in itsbrilliance. 6As far as Görgey's reputation is concerned, this is an occasion when aunique military leader falls in defeat, losing in the process both the war andhis reputation.Other factors besides generalship can lead to military failure. Command,according to Martin Blumenson,is an art to be mastered, a craft that requires specialized knowledge, a well-developedintuition, high intelligence, and the ability to reason. The process of motivating human