© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Corrosion Testing — Background and Theoretical Considerations 125<br />
TABLE 7.2<br />
Exposure Results from Colton, California, and East Chicago, Indiana<br />
Coating<br />
Gloss loss (%)<br />
E. Chicago<br />
Gloss loss (%)<br />
Colton<br />
Even if only one coating and one substrate were to be tested, it would not be<br />
possible to design an accelerated test that would perfectly suit all the exposure sites<br />
mentioned in this section — much less all the sites in the world.<br />
7.3.2 DIFFERENT COATINGS HAVE DIFFERENT WEAKNESSES<br />
Ranking, E.<br />
Chicago<br />
Ranking,<br />
Colton<br />
Epoxy-urethane 3 0 1 1<br />
Urethane 38 31 2 3<br />
Waterborne alkyd 56 6 3 2<br />
Epoxy B 65 83 4 5<br />
Acrylic alkyd 68 77 5 4<br />
Epoxy A 98 98 6 6<br />
Data from: Glueckert, A.J., Correlation of accelerated test to outdoor exposure for railcar exterior<br />
coatings, in Proc. Corros. 94, NACE, Houston, 1994, Paper 596.<br />
Cured coatings are commonly thought of as simple structures: the usual depiction<br />
is a layer of binder containing pigment particles. The general view is that of a<br />
homogenous, continuous, solid binder film reinforced with pigment particles. In<br />
reality, the cured coating is a much more complex structure.<br />
For one thing, instead of being a solid, it contains lots of empty space:<br />
pinholes, voids after crosslinking, gaps between pigment and binder, and so on.<br />
All of these voids are potential routes for water molecules to slip through the<br />
cured film. What is important for accelerated testing is that the amount of empty<br />
space in the coating is not constant — it can change during weathering, as both<br />
the binder and the pigment change. Some pigments, such as passivating pigments,<br />
are slowly consumed, causing the empty space between pigment and binder to<br />
increase. Other pigments immediately corrode on their surface. The increased<br />
volume of the corrosion products can decrease the empty space between particles<br />
and binder.<br />
Binders also change with time, for many reasons. The stresses in the binder caused<br />
<strong>by</strong> film formation can be increased, or relieved, during aging. The magnitude of the<br />
stresses caused <strong>by</strong> film formation, and what happens to these stresses upon weathering,<br />
depends to a large extent on the type of polymer used for the binder. The same could<br />
be said for UV degradation, or any stress that ages binders: the binder’s reaction, both<br />
in mechanism and in magnitude, depends to a large extent on the specific polymer<br />
used. Even if only one exposure site were really to be used, it would not be possible<br />
to design an accelerated test that would be suitable for all binders and pigments.<br />
<strong>©</strong> <strong>2006</strong> <strong>by</strong> <strong>Taylor</strong> & <strong>Francis</strong> <strong>Group</strong>, <strong>LLC</strong>